University of Virginia Library

Search this document 
The Plan of St. Gall

a study of the architecture & economy of & life in a paradigmatic Carolingian monastery
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
 I. 
  
  
collapse section 
  
collapse section 
  
  
  

collapse sectionI. 
collapse sectionI. 1. 
  
 I.1.1. 
 I.1.2. 
 I.1.3. 
 I.1.4. 
collapse sectionI.1.5. 
  
collapse sectionI.1.6. 
  
 I.1.7. 
collapse sectionI. 2. 
 I.2.1. 
collapse sectionI. 3. 
 I.3.1. 
 I.3.2. 
 I.3.3. 
collapse sectionI. 4. 
 I.4.1. 
 I.4.2. 
collapse sectionI. 5. 
 I.5.1. 
 I.5.2. 
 I.5.3. 
collapse sectionI. 6. 
collapse sectionI.6.1. 
  
  
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionI. 7. 
 I.7.1. 
 I.7.2. 
collapse sectionI.7.3. 
  
  
  
 I.7.4. 
 I. 8. 
collapse sectionI. 9. 
collapse sectionI.9.1. 
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionI. 10. 
 I.10.1. 
 I.10.2. 
collapse sectionI. 11. 
collapse sectionI.11.1. 
  
  
  
 I.11.2. 
collapse sectionI. 12. 
 I.12.1. 
 I.12.2. 
 I.12.3. 
 I.12.4. 
 I.12.5. 
 I.12.6. 
 I.12.7. 
collapse sectionI. 13. 
 I.13.1. 
 I.13.2. 
 I.13.3. 
 I.13.4. 
 I.13.5. 
 I.13.6. 
 I.13.7. 
 I.13.8. 
collapse sectionI. 14. 
 I.14.1. 
collapse sectionI.14.2. 
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionI.14.3. 
  
  
  
  
  
 I.14.4. 
 I.14.5. 
 I.14.6. 
collapse sectionI.14.7. 
  
  
  
  
 I.14.8. 
 I.14.9. 
collapse sectionI. 15. 
collapse sectionI.15.1. 
  
 I. 16. 
 I. 17. 
collapse sectionII. 
collapse sectionII. 1. 
  
 II.1.1. 
 II.1.2. 
collapse sectionII.1.3. 
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionII.1.4. 
  
 II.1.5. 
collapse sectionII.1.6. 
  
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionII.1.7. 
  
  
  
collapse sectionII.1.8. 
  
  
  
collapse sectionII.1.9. 
  
  
collapse sectionII.1.10. 
  
  
 II.1.11. 
collapse sectionII.1.12. 
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
 II.1.13. 
collapse sectionII. 2. 
collapse sectionII.2.1. 
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionII.2.2. 
  
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionII. 3. 
 II.3.1. 
 II.3.2. 
 II.3.3. 
 II.3.4. 
 II.3.5. 
 II.3.6. 
 II.3.7. 
 II.3.8. 
 II.3.9. 
collapse sectionII.3.10. 
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionIII. 
collapse sectionIII. 1. 
 III.1.1. 
 III.1.2. 
 III.1.3. 
collapse sectionIII.1.4. 
  
  
  
collapse sectionIII.1.5. 
collapse section 
  
  
  
  
collapse section 
  
  
  
collapse sectionIII.1.6. 
  
  
  
collapse sectionIII.1.7. 
  
  
collapse sectionIII.1.8. 
collapse section 
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
collapse section 
  
collapse sectionIII.1.9. 
  
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionIII.1.30. 
collapse section 
  
collapse section 
  
  
  
  
collapse section 
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionIII.1.11. 
  
  
collapse sectionIII. 2. 
 III.2.1. 
 III.2.2. 
collapse sectionIII.2.3. 
  
  
  
collapse sectionIII.2.4. 
  
  
  
 III.2.5. 
collapse sectionIII.2.6. 
  
collapse section 
  
  
  
  
collapse sectionIII.2.7. 
  
  
  
 III.2.8. 
collapse sectionIII. 3. 
 III.3.1. 
 III.3.2. 
 III.3.3. 
 III.3.4. 
 III.3.5. 
III.3.5
collapse sectionIV. 
  
collapse sectionIV. 1. 
collapse sectionIV.1.1. 
  
  
  
 IV.1.2. 
 IV.1.3. 
 IV.1.4. 
 IV.1.5. 
 IV.1.6. 
 IV.1.7. 
 IV.1.8. 
 IV.1.9. 
 IV.1.10. 
 IV.1.11. 
 IV.1.12. 
collapse sectionIV. 2. 
 IV.2.1. 
 IV.2.2. 
collapse sectionIV.2.3. 
  
  
  
collapse sectionIV. 3. 
collapse sectionIV.3.1. 
  
  
collapse sectionIV. 4. 
 IV.4.1. 
 IV.4.2. 
collapse sectionIV. 5. 
 IV.5.1. 
collapse sectionIV. 6. 
collapse sectionIV.6.1. 
  
  
  
collapse sectionIV. 7. 
collapse sectionIV.7.1. 
  
  
  
collapse sectionIV.7.2. 
  
  
 IV.7.3. 
 IV.7.4. 
 IV.7.5. 
 IV.7.6. 
 IV.7.7. 

III.3.5

LATER PRACTICES

Separate quarters for the Abbot became a standard practice
in the monastic building tradition following the second
synod of Aachen. But during the Cluniac reform of the
eleventh century this privilege was revoked. The Customs
of Udalric
written about 1085, tell us that "the abbot's bed
stood in the middle of the dormitory next to the wall" and
that it was the abbot himself who struck the bell to arouse
the brothers for the divine service.[333] In the early Cistercian
monasteries likewise the abbot was at first required to sleep
in the monk's dormitory, but later on, in the thirteenth
century, he was again installed in a house of his own.[334] In
Carolingian times, I am inclined to think this was the rule
rather than the exception; and the Plan of St. Gall must
have been a primary force in solidifying that custom. It
certainly left its imprint on the monastery for which it was
drawn. Gozbert (816-836), during the last six years of his
abbacy, was too intensely preoccupied with the completion
of his new church to allow himself to get involved in the
construction of a new residence. This project was undertaken
by his second successor Grimald, abbot of St. Gall
from 841-872 (and for much of that time also chancellor
at the court of Louis the German), who built himself an
aula worthy of his high political standing. Two wall
inscriptions of the new building, recorded in Cod. 397 of
St. Gall[335] describe it as follows:

Aula palatinis perfecta est ista magistris,
Insula pictores transmiserat Augia clara.

This hall was built by masters of the palace, while
the island of Reichenau furnished its famous
painters.

A second inscription praised the splendid marble columns
of the abbot's residence and stated that it was built by
Grimaldus during the reign of Louis the Pious:

Splendida marmoreis ornata est aula columnis,
Quam Grimoldus ovans firmo fundamine struxit,
Ornavit, coluit Hludewici principis almi
Temporibus multos laetus feliciter annos.

Here is the glamorous palace, with columns of marble
augmented,

which Grimold with pious intention on solid foundation
erected,

With art ornamented and cherished, in days of Prince
Louis the Pious.

Long years thereafter he proudly oversaw the care of its
fabric.[336]

Abbot Grimald's aula stood to the north of the abbey
church—like the Abbot's House on the Plan of St. Gall,
but a little further east than the latter. In 1414 it was gutted
by fire, and subsequently rebuilt internally and re-roofed.
In this form it is portrayed on the bird's-eye-view of the
City of St. Gall, in 1596 (fig. 507), and all subsequent views

II. 318
of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries.[338]


325

Page 325

326

Page 326
[ILLUSTRATION]

TABLE I
ADMINISTRATIVE AND EXECUTIVE ORGANIZATION OF A BENEDICTINE MONASTERY
IN THE TIME OF CHARLEMAGNE AND LOUIS THE PIOUS

"The Abbot is believed to be the representative of Christ in the monastery and his order should be received as a divine command and not suffer any delay in execution."
St. Benedict, who wrote these lines, was wary of the office of Provost, preferring instead to divide power among deans rather than centralize authority in a second in
command, whose presence
"might lead to rivalries and dissention." But the growing managerial complexities of the medieval monastery, with its vast web of outlying
estates, and with serfs and workmen living within the monastic enclosure itself, made inevitable the existence of such an executive.

‡ Latin words lacking English equivalents are set in roman type, an exception to normal editorial style.

 
[333]

Cf. II, 338.

[334]

Cf. II, 349.

[335]

Versus Sangallenses, V.: Tituli, ed. Karolus Strecker, Mon. Germ.
Hist., Poetae Latini aevi Carolini,
IV:3, Berlin, 1923, 1108.

[336]

Translation by Charles W. Jones.

[338]

Discussed in more detail, II, 318, fig. 507.