University of Virginia Library

Search this document 


  

collapse section 
 1. 
 2. 
 3. 
 4. 
 5. 
  
collapse section 
 1. 
 2. 
collapse section3. 
 01. 
 02. 
 03. 
 04. 
 05. 
 06. 
 07. 
 08. 
 09. 
 10. 
 11. 
 12. 
collapse section4. 
 01. 
 02. 
  
collapse section 
  
  
  
collapse section 
 1. 
 2. 
  
collapse section 
  
  
collapse section 
 1. 
 2. 
 3. 
 4. 
  
collapse section 
 1. 
 2. 
 3. 
Appendix II: Variant readings in quires G, H, and I3.4 not noticed in Herford and Simpson (H&S format).
  
collapse section 
 1. 
  
 2. 
  
collapse section 
  
 1. 
 2. 
  
collapse section 
 1. 
collapse section2. 
 01. 
 02. 
 03. 
 04. 
 05. 
 06. 
 07. 
 08. 
 09. 
 10. 
 11. 
 12. 
 13. 
 15. 
 16. 
 17. 
 18. 
 19. 
 20. 
 21. 
 22. 
 23. 
 24. 
 25. 
 26. 
 27. 
 28. 
 29. 
  
collapse section 
 1. 
collapse section2. 
  
 02. 
 03. 
 03. 
 3. 
 4. 
 5. 
 6. 
 7. 
  
  
collapse section 
  
  
collapse section 
  
  
collapse section 
 1. 
 2. 
  

collapse section 
  
  
  
  
  
  
  

Appendix II: Variant readings in quires G, H, and I3.4 not noticed in Herford and Simpson (H&S format).

G2, p. 75

         
Original   Altered Original   Reset   Corrected Reset  
Ded. 18  use-full  use full  use-full  use-full 
19  For so  For so  For, so  For so, 
it:  it:  it.  it. 
20  gowne  gowne  gowne,  gowne, 

The Altered Original always appears with the fourth (last Original) variant of G5v (see below). The single change in it is the result of the disappearance of the hyphen from "use-full" in line 18, which must have occured during the machining of the forme, for in one copy (of nine) of this variant, the hyphen is present.

The headline from the reset G5, with the page number "81" mistakenly left in place, was used for the headline of the reset and corrected reset of G2.

Gerritsen points out (p. 53) that the largest block of italic type (the body of the Dedication) was not reset, which is almost correct. The first two lines were, in fact, reset; there were several alterations in punctuation later in the text.

G2v, p. 76

In their "Survey of the Text," for line 13 H&S fail to italicize "their servant" (IX, 53) but do get it right in the play (III, 422). For line 23 they note in the "corrected" state: "Rustici" (above "Fungoso"), which also appears in their edition of the play. I have not been able to find this variant anywhere, including in the Grenville copy at the British Library, which is cited in their notes (IX, 53). This ghostly fragment may be similar to a couple noted by Parker in his edition of Volpone (p. 358).

             
G3, p.77  Original   Reset  
Char. 10  falls  fals 
16  singularity  singualaritie 
27  de- | formity  de- | formitie 
G3v, p.78  41  Hee  He 
43  neede  need 
44  marchant  merchant 

164

Page 164
                       
63  Lady  Ladie 
CW  Sor-  Sor. 
G4, p. 79  67  Al- | manacks . . .  Al- | manackes . . . 
felicity  felicitie 
70  Fungoso  Fungosa 
75  aimes  aymes 
79  Gentleman  gentleman 
84  Souldier  souldier 
94  he. . . . He  hee. . . . Hee 
G4v, p. 80  112  discreet,  discreet 
G5, p. 81  [H&S seem to have noticed all variants.] 
G5v, p. 82  Ind. 56  friends.  friends, 

There are at least five states of G5v, four in the original and one in the reset. The stage-direction, between lines 51 and 52, "Here hee makes address to the People," appears at "the left extending into the outer margin, . . . [and at] the right, extending to the inner margin" (H&S, IX, 54). In at least one copy the stage direction at the right is broken off after the first letter of the. The page also appears without the stage-direction, both in the original and in the reset. The most likely order is this: The stage-direction at the left was thought unsightly and it was moved to the inner margin; when the stage-direction broke, it was removed and several lines of the page were re-spaced, "giving the page an irregular look" (H&S, IX, 53). When the page was reset the lines were spaced evenly.

G6, p. 83

Herford and Simpson seem to have noticed all the variants between the original and the reset page. In their assessment of the reasons for the changes, however, they are wrong, misled by their belief in the authority of "large-paper" (including "Ford") copies. They contend that "one change on pages 82 and 83 of the Folio . . . corrected a printer's error in the setting of the verse. Jonson liked his lines to be marshalled in even column, and he kept strictly to the verse-arrangement when a speech did not begin the line" (III, 416). It is much more likely that the printer was rearranging lines so that the page of the reset would end at the same place as the original.

         
G6v, p. 84  Original   Corrected   Reset  
Ind.103  Metaphore  Metaphore   Metaphore (swash M
138  Worthy  Worthy  Worthie 
139  this,  this?  this? 
145  crush . . . soules  squeeze . . . soules  squeeze . . . natures 

Herford and Simpson note: "This quire [G] shows a corrected state in lines 103, 139, 140, 142, and 145. The readings found in M1, Ford, and S3 [the copies that they consider to be large-paper] alone are a resetting." Broadly speaking, they are right, but they do not deal with the most significant implication of what they say. The corrected readings, as noted above, are always to be preferred to the reset — when the distinction can be made.


165

Page 165

                                                                                                 
H1, p. 85  Original   Reset  
151  ready  readie 
153  censors,  censors 
154  liberally  liberally. 
163  several  severall 
172  'Tis  Tis 
H1v, p. 86  [219  Arte (swash A Arte
[237  Acts (swash A Acts
H2, p. 87  240  fall  fal 
259  kinde  kind 
265  elegancie  elegancy 
268  bee  be 
273  Insula   Insula,  
278  seas  Seas 
282  countries  countreys 
286  auditorie  auditory 
291  staid a little |  stayed a lit- | tle 
H2v, p. 88  298  necessity  necessitie 
305  How?  How, 
307  did or |  did | or 
308  but 'twill not |  but | 'twill not 
310  pro- | logue  Pro- | logue 
311  poyson'd  poison'd 
312  two-penny  two-pennie 
326  him,  him 
327  well-timberd  well timbred 
330  said. . . . cup  saide. . . . cuppe 
331  diamond  Diamond 
H3, p. 89  337  mary  marie 
342  do'  do's 
344  withall  with all 
345  He  Hee 
346  Man . . . humour: Sbloud  man . . . Humour: Sblood 
347  humour hee . . . mee  Humour he . . . me 
348  Gentles  Gentiles 
[350  No   No (swash N)] 
351  be thirsty  bee thirstie 
353  play  Play 
354  Cordatus?  Cordatus. 
356  He  Hee 
363  varietie  variety 
367  he  hee 
368  Atheistical  Atheisticall 
369  hee'le ap- | peare  hee'le | 
I.i  Viri est   Viriest  
[ferre (swash e ferre
Stoique  Stoicke 
every  everie 
cor'sive  corr'sive 

There is one alteration in the original: "GREX." (following line 353) and "Act I. Scene I. | Macilente" are in some copies off center, to the left, but in other copies are centered.


166

Page 166

                                                                                                             
H3v, p. 90  Original   Corrected   Reset  
14  [My (swash M My (swash M My
minde   minde   minde  
15  hungrie . . . foode.  hungrie . . . foode.  hungry . . . food 
21  third,  third,  third 
27  eye-balls  eye-balls  eye-bals 
34  incutitq   incutitq   incutique  
I.ii  Nay . . . Carlo  Nay . . . Carlo  Nay, . . . Carlo  
(dropped)  Car. A . . .  Car. A . . . 
resolution.  resolution. 
CW  Car  Sog  Sog. 
H4, p. 91  tay- | lors  tay- | lors  Tay- | ors 
20  Sogliardo  Sogliardo  Sogliardo  
21  you | affect to be  you | affect to be  you affect | to bee 
22  qualities, |  qualities, |  qualities, hu- | mours 
24  signior  Signior  Signior 
27  me- | dicine  me- | dicine  medi- | cine 
29  you, and  you, and  you, & 
32  Macil.  Macil.  Maci. 
39  city  city  Citie 
42  trunks  trunks  trunkes 
43  conju- | rer . . . be  conju- | rer . . . be  con- | jurer . . . bee 
44  the spring |  the spring |  the | spring 
45  behaviour | in all:  behaviour | in all;  beha- | viour in all; 
[49  As   As   As (swash A)] 
49  are a are a are | a  
52  he . . . choose  he . . . choose  hee . . . chuse 
53  gentleman  gentleman  Gentleman 
H4v, p. 92  59  boot;  boot, 
60  else | as  else as | 
68  city  citie 
69  marchants  Merchants 
72  suppe  sup 
73  hire | a  hire a | 
74  be  bee 
77  kins- | man   kinsman
78  there | (while  there (while | 
79  enquiry . . . health, or | so)  enquirie . . . health, or so) one | 
80  carry . . . breakes | it  carrie . . . breakes it up | 
81  publikely  publikly 
82  you | must  you must | 
83  Mi- | stris  Mistresses | 
84  hot | grace  hot grace | 
88  this.  this: 
106  policy  policie 
111  credi- | tor  cre- | ditor 
115  pliant  plyant 
118  new-yeares  new-yeeres 
H5, p. 93  124  tragedies  Tragedies 
125  Mary  Marie 
128  feare,  feare 
130  penny  pennie 
136  lye  lie 
137  [Mercuries] . . . me  [Mercuries (swash M)] . . . mee 
138  they had | not  they | had 

167

Page 167
                                                               
146  citie  Citie 
152  Signior  signior 
153  i'faith  if'aith 
160  wild  wilde 
166  al . . . straies  all . . . strayes 
169  pitty  pittie 
H5v, p. 94  177  Sir  sir 
185  tell  tel 
193  ordinarie  ordinary 
194  beene . . . readie  been . . . ready 
198  well. . . . we  wel. . . . we 
205  that.  that: 
212  he  hee 
213  chap- | falne  chop- | falne 
219  he be  hee bee 
220  him,  him. 
223  and I, |  and | I, 
224,  citie, wee | . . . meet  citie, | we . . . meete 
H6, p. 95  225  shun  shunne 
229  devill  divell 
I.iii.  14  yeere. . . . see,  year. . . . see 
17  xxi  xxj 
19  xxvi  xxvj 
23  xxxi. . . . S'lid  xxxj. . . . Slid 
24  saies | he  sayes he | 
26  here's . . . rogue,  her's . . . rogue. 
H6v, p. 96  35  fortie  forty 
38  bee  be 
44  daies  dayes 
61  booke,  booke. 
63  me  mee 
75  skin  skinne 

In the original and corrected quire H, very often the lower case "w" is set with two "v"s, but almost always with the single "w" in the reset.

                         
I3, p. 101  II.i  Original   Reset  
70  be  bee 
80  'Fore  Fore 
85  of an- | other  of | another 
86  to your |  to | your 
91  a ha- | bit  a | habit 
96  lie  lye 
97  muske-cat  musk-cat 
100  sweetnesse  sweetnes 
106  envy | this  en- | vy this 
107  yfaith. How |  yfaith. | How 
115  bounty  bountie 
CW  exceeding 

The last line of original I3, "I have heard this knight Pvntarvolo, reported to bee a gentleman of" is shifted in the reset to the top of I3v, where "gentleman" is altered to "Gentleman."


168

Page 168

                                                                         
I3v, p. 102  Original   Corrected   Reset  
124  hobby  hobby  hobbie 
129  he  he  hee 
133  he  he  hee 
137  hee  hee  he 
139  lady  lady  Lady 
141  gentleman  gentleman  Gentleman 
145  lady  lady  Ladie 
150  as | first,  as | first,  as first, | 
151  he has | his  he has | his  hee has his | 
152  shee . . . out, | and  shee . . . out, | and  she . . . out, and | 
153  hee . . . shee  hee . . . shee  he . . . she 
154  gentle- | men.  gentle- | men.  gentlemen. | 
163  saies  saies  sayes 
166  1Saies  1saies  1saies 
I4, p. 103  180  pleasing |  pleasing |  pleasing ob- | 
object  object  ject 
II.ii  enclosed  enclosed  inclosed 
above.  above!  above! 
eye  eye  eie 
11  retire  retire  retyre 
36  studied  studied  studyed 
38  play  play  Play 
39  e'en  e'en  e'ene 
40  edifice;  edifice!  edifice! 
I4v, p. 104  46  melancholy:  melancholy. 
55  'Slud  Slud 
53  twise  twice 
62  beyond-sea  beyond-seas 
65  back  backe 
68  hee goes | to church  he goes to | Church 
71  he  hee 
72  capacity  capacitie 
74  Shee  She 
77  qua- | lified  quali- | fied 
89  he does? | Looke,  hee does? Looke, | 
90  on: | and  on: and the dogge |