University of Virginia Library

Search this document 
The Plan of St. Gall

a study of the architecture & economy of & life in a paradigmatic Carolingian monastery
  
  
  
  
 II. 
  
  
  

collapse sectionV. 
  
expand sectionV. 1. 
expand sectionV. 2. 
expand sectionV. 3. 
expand sectionV. 4. 
collapse sectionV. 5. 
 V.5.1. 
expand sectionV.5.2. 
expand sectionV. 6. 
expand sectionV. 7. 
expand sectionV. 8. 
expand sectionV. 9. 
expand sectionV. 10. 
expand sectionV. 11. 
expand sectionV. 12. 
expand sectionV. 13. 
expand sectionV. 14. 
expand sectionV. 15. 
expand sectionV. 16. 
expand sectionV. 17. 
expand sectionV. 18. 
expand sectionVI. 

CHAPTER HOUSE

Certain innovations made at Cluny became an integral part
of the later Benedictine tradition and remained in permanent
departure from the solution set forth on the Plan of
St. Gall. The most notable of these is the inclusion in the
east range of a separate chapter house.[102] Once conceived, the
separate chapter house could not be abandoned because of
its functional advantages. To place the chapter house at the
northern end of the east range, however, brought with it
certain complications. As long as it remained confined to
the ground floor, the dormitory overhead could still be
connected directly with the transept by means of night
stairs. But if the space of the chapter house extended upwards
through the entire height of the east range, arrangements
had to be made to connect the dormitory with the
church by special passageways; or the night stairs had to be
abandoned altogether.[103]

 
[102]

See above, p. 336.

[103]

Willis, 1868, 17, 18, points out that the sloping structure between
the transept and the chapter house seen on the Plan of Christchurch,
Canterbury is such an arrangement.

"At Gloucester and Reading there was, it is said, no direct communication,
the brethren having to go out into the cloister." (Hope, 1897,
Records of Gloucester Cath. III, 106.)