21.10
The
result was that, beyond being received and heard by the Carthaginian senate,
the embassy found its mission a failure. Hanno alone, against the whole
senate, spoke in favour of observing the treaty, and his speech was listened
to in silence out of respect to his personal authority, not because his hearers
approved of his sentiments. He appealed to them in the name of the gods,
who are the witnesses and arbiters of treaties, not to provoke a war with
Rome in addition to the one with Saguntum. "I urged you," he said, "and
warned you not to send Hamilcar's son to the army. That man's spirit, that
man's offspring cannot rest; as long as any single representative of the blood
and name of Barca survives our treaty with Rome will never remain
unimperilled. You have sent to the army, as though supplying fuel to the fire,
a young man who is consumed with a passion for sovereign power, and who
recognises that the only way to it lies in passing his life surrounded by armed
legions and perpetually stirring up fresh wars. It is you, therefore, who have
fed this fire which is now scorching you. Your armies are investing
Saguntum, which by the terms of the treaty they are forbidden to approach;
before long the legions of Rome will invest Carthage, led by the same
generals under the same divine guidance under which they avenged our
breach of treaty obligations in the late war. Are you strangers to the enemy,
to yourselves, to the fortunes of each nation? That worthy commander of
yours refused to allow ambassadors who came from allies, on behalf of allies,
to enter his camp, and set at naught the law of nations. Those men, repulsed
from a place to which even an enemy's envoys are not refused access, have
come to us; they ask for the satisfaction which the treaty prescribes; they
demand the surrender of the guilty party in order that the State may clear
itself from all taint of guilt. The slower they are to take action, the longer
they are in commencing war, so much the more persistence and
determination, I fear, will they show when war has begun. Remember the
Aegates and Eryx, and all you had to go through for four-and-twenty years.
This boy was not commanding then, but his father, Hamilcar -a second Mars
as his friends would have us believe. But we broke the treaty then as we are
breaking it now; we did not keep our hands off Tarentum or, which is the
same thing, off Italy then any more than we are keeping our hands off
Saguntum now, and so gods and men combined to defeat us, and the
question in dispute, namely, which nation had broken the treaty, was settled
by the issue of the war, which, like an impartial judge, left the victory on the
side which was in the right. It is against Carthage that Hannibal is now
bringing up his vineae and towers, it is Carthage whose walls he is shaking
with his battering rams. The ruins of Saguntum -would that I might prove a
false prophet -will fall on our heads, and the war which was begun with
Saguntum will have to be carried on with Rome.
"'Shall we then surrender Hannibal?' some one will say. I am quite
aware that as regards him my advice will have little weight, owing to my
differences with his father, but whilst I was glad to hear of Hamilcar's death,
for if he were alive we should already be involved in war with Rome, I feel
nothing but loathing and detestation for this youth, the mad firebrand who is
kindling this war. Not only do I hold that he ought to be surrendered as an
atonement for the broken treaty, but even if no demand for his surrender
were made I consider that he ought to be deported to the farthest corner of
the earth, exiled to some spot from which no tidings of him, no mention of
his name, could reach us, and where it would be impossible for him to
disturb the welfare and tranquillity of our State. This then is what I propose:
'That a commission be at once despatched to Rome to inform the senate of
our compliance with their demands, and a second to Hannibal ordering him
to withdraw his army from Saguntum and then surrendering him to the
Romans in accordance with the terms of the treaty, and I also propose that a
third body of commissioners be sent to make reparation to the Saguntines.'"