University of Virginia Library

C. THE VARIOUS KINDS OF EXTERNAL MANIPULATION—MASSAGE AND EXPRESSION—IN THE OBSTETRIC PRACTICE OF PRIMITIVE PEOPLE.

I will endeavor to classify the various forms of external manipulations in use among primitive people, taking first, as the most simple, the different forms of (I.) Expression. These are usually practised by an assistant, most frequently (1) by the arms encircling the patient's abdomen, the hands usually clasped in front over the uterine fundus, thus forming a powerful compressor.

(2.) This living compressor may be replaced by a bandage, the ends of which are in the hands of an assistant.

Another method (3) is to draw the patient's abdomen across a rope or pole, so as to force down the uterine globe. In more difficult cases (4), the patient is suspended by a rope, and the uterus stripped down by the weight of an assistant, who hangs upon the abdomen of the sufferer. And (5) an equally uncouth method of expressing the ovum is by the feet of an assistant, or sympathizing friend, who tramps upon the back or belly of the patient, or by a weight placed upon the enlarged abdomen. In some instances, the patient herself exerts the external force (6) by the tightening of a belt; (7) by leaning with the uterine fundus against a staff firmly planted in the ground; or (8) by lying fiat upon the ground with a pillow under the abdomen.

II. Massage, or the shampooing of the abdomen, is a some what more complicated operation; in almost all cases practiced by an assistant, and usually in connection with simple expression. I will merely refer to

III. The shaking out of the ovum; and

IV. Permanent pressure.

I. EXPRESSION.—Simple expression is resorted to among primitive people in almost every labor; it is the most rude and primitive form of external manipulation, and at once suggests itself as an aid to the forces of nature when assistance seems called for. It is used both in the delivery of the child and of the placenta; and the method which first suggests itself is the one most commonly resorted to.

(1.) By the arms of an assistant encircling the patient's abdomen.

That this has been so commonly resorted to at all times and by all people is evident when we remember that in so many cases the patient is delivered seated in the lap of an assistant, be it on a chair, or stone, or upon the ground. This position was common in ancient times and modern; I will again refer to the ancient Peruvian urn with the patient seated in the lap of her husband; the method is still in use upon the South American coast, in Peru, in Chili; it was common among the ancient Hebrews, in Rome, and in medieval Italy; also in Greece, ancient and modern. We find it in Africa and India; rarely among the American Indians, where the lazy male is unwilling to undertake this laborious task; here and there among the Scotch and Welsh; in various of the backwood counties of our own States; among the Sandwich Islanders; the Bedouins; and the Kalmucks of Russia.

The same method is resorted to whether the patient is delivered in a standing posture, as among some of our Sioux tribes, or among the Crows and Comanches, where the patient kneels, the assistant kneeling behind her, clasping the abdomen firmly above the uterus, and keeping up steady pressure during the entire labor. Among the Nez-Percés and Gros-Ventres, where the patient assumes the squatting posture, the encircling arms of the assistant exercise the same steady compression. Among the Kootenais (see Fig. 19, Posture), where the parturient is upon her hands and knees, the same method is in use; whilst the woman is on her knees, the face touching the ground, the hands one above the other grasping a pole planted in the ground, and the legs apart, a man straddles her across the buttocks, and with his hands clasped around her waist exercises a steady pressure on the abdomen, pulling, however, only during a pain. The way in which the pressure is exercised is, of course, much the same among different people whatever be the position assumed.

In some rare instances, in the mountainous portions of Germany, the woman is delivered suspended, in the arms of her husband, who seizes her from behind, and raises her up so that she is bent backward, her toes barely touching the ground. In this position, of course, with his hands clasped above the uterus, a steady and very powerful pressure is exercised. In other cases, as among the Brulé Sioux, and among some of the

Iroquois of Canada, the patient hangs to the neck of an assistant, who exercises pressure by forcing his abdomen against that of the patient, his arms around her waist, his hands clasped at her back. A similar method of pressure is exercised by the Japanese obstetrician in correcting malposition during the later months of pregnancy. He, however, uses his hands rather to knead the abdomen than to compress the womb, but very much in the same way as the Sioux assistant.

In the case of a patient seated in the lap of an assistant, the description I find given of a labor among the Sandwich Islanders is characteristic: It is the duty of this assistant, upon whose lap the parturient rests, to grasp the waist above the abdomen in such a way that he or she can press down upon the uterus and its contents with a considerable force, not relaxing this grasp to allow the fetus to recede. The force of the pressure is backward and downward, increased during the pains, and kept up in a moderate steady measure during the interval to prevent a loss of the advantage gained during each pain. This method is well represented by an illustration (Fig. 32, Posture), made in accordance with the characteristic description of obstetric practice in the rural districts of Ohio some twenty years ago, given me by my friend, Dr. E. B. Stevens.

This is resorted to among many of the Mexicans and half-breed Mexicans; among the Andamanese; among such of the Hindoos in India as are delivered in the lay; and among the Burmese. In case that the patient kneels in labor, which is perhaps the most common position among the Indian squaws, the assistant either kneels behind the patient, or stands astride of or between her feet, and encircles the abdomen with her arms, exercising the same constant pressure as when other positions are assumed. This custom we find prevalent among the yellow races as well as the red, in Kamtschatka and Mongolia; less common among the black, in Ethiopia, and also in New Zealand.

(2.) A bandage passed around the body and tightened by assistants, supplants, in some cases, the encircling arms: this is not so much the usual practice in ordinary cases, but rather a severer measure adopted in retarded labor. A description of this method is found in the Medical Times and Gazette for

August, 1861, describing a labor at Monterey, California. "The patient was seated in a chair, seizing with her hands a rope pendent from the ceiling. A bandage was placed about

FIG. 58.—Bandage as used in Mexico.

[Description: Woman kneels on mattress, with bandages wrapped around her abdomen, holding onto a rope suspended overhead from a diagonal post. Black and white illustration.]

her body, the ends of which were crossed behind, each of which was grasped by an assistant, whose duty it was to make firm traction upon the sheet, and especially to draw tightly as the abdomen diminished in size. They were particularly instructed to make strong traction in the intervals between the pains, lest the abdomen during this time should resume the position it had before the pain came on.'' Similar accounts I hear from Mexico, from South America, from the north of India. The Finns, in difficult cases, when the child will not advance, force it out by tight compression of a strap placed around the abdomen; the Calmucks likewise follow this custom.

The Klatsops use a bandage only for the expression of the after-birth, and this appears to me to be a very reasonable procedure; a bandage is placed about the abdomen of the patient after the delivery of the child, thus not only aiding the expression of the placenta, but preventing the expansion of the womb; in other words, preventing post-partum hemorrhage, and furthering the necessary contractions. The Piute Indians make use of a bandage in a somewhat different way; they clasp a leather girdle around the waist above the fundus of the womb, not so tight-fitting but that it will slip up and down on the body; then, as the expulsive pains come on, three, four, or more women push the girdle down after the escaping child. They regard the descent of the child as voluntary on its part, and push the girdle down to support it in any progress it makes from time to time, that it shall not lose its foothold and slip back, and thereby lose all the distance gained by the effort for food and day-light: so as labor progresses, the child's footsteps are followed up by this girdle, until it is finally expelled; or, as they say, it has asserted its freedom and broken its fast.

(3.) Drawing the abdomen across a rope or pole. A peculiar custom, which we have not found elsewhere, exists among the Winnebagos and Chippewas. In difficult cases, more common among the more civilized Indians who have half-breed children, as is so frequently found where races mix, a cross-bar or rope stretched across the tent is always on hand, as it gives a support to the patient who kneels in labor; but when this will not advance, the woman is generally drawn over the bar, face downward, the upper part of the stomach resting upon the wood, and several persons, all women, supporting her arms, gently draw and push her over the bar or rope. This, I am told, is the only kind of expression employed among these tribes; a

instance of this kind is related to me by Surgeon W. S. King, U. S. A., in which a patient was so drawn over a rope suspended between two trees.

(4.) Stripping down the abdomen. This is only resorted to in desperate cases; but, although not common, seems to be the last resort among various people. I hear of it in Siam, among the Tartars, and among the Coyotero-Apaches; and, remarkably

enough, precisely the same method is adopted in each instance (see Fig. 25, Posture). The parturient is suspended by bands beneath the arms, and one, sometimes two, of the attendants grasp the body of the patient in their arms, and strip down the womb with considerable force; a kind of "all pull together,'' as Dr. Reed, Surgeon U. S. A., expresses it. He says that this energetic maneuvre generally suffices, as he never heard of a case that resisted this method. That is very likely, as the fetus will find an outlet somewhere, be it per vias naturales or through the abdominal walls. The child must out. Other means they have none; hence, it is the best that can be done, although we should think that the mother, if not the child also, must inevitably suffer.

(5.) Expression by means of the feet. A very effective and not very delicate method, pursued by experts among some very primitive people, is, in difficult cases where the ordinary methods have not answered, to stand upon the abdomen of the patient, with the heels upon the thorax, the toes pressing upon the uterine fundus, and thus to express the child; or, as among the Negritas of the Philippine Islands, or the Waswaheli, among the Siamese and Burmese, an old woman, who takes the place of the midwife, places her left foot upon the patient's body, pressing upon the fundus, while she drags down the baby with the right hand. A report from Siam (Samuel R. House, M.D., Archives of Med., June, 1879) states that a favorite way to expedite matters is to press with great force on the abdomen and its contents, shampooing vigorously with the thumbs and fists, and even to stand upon the poor woman's body, crowding the heels upon the front or side of the distended uterus, and without the slightest reference to or knowledge of the condition of the os uteri. In Ceram, they place the patient flat upon her stomach to force the expression of the child. The Negritas, also, are fond of placing bricks or stones, but hot, upon the abdomen of the patient to insure expression.

In some few instances, the parturient practices expression herself, either with her own hands, by the tightening of a belt, or by pressing against a fixed body. I have seen but one statement, and that is from the Indians of the Pacific slope, that the parturient uses her own hands to compress and press down the womb. How much more useful than the senseless grasping of bed-clothes or assistants by the civilized lady!

(6.) The belt. The belt, which is, of course, the same as the bandage, only that it can be used by the patient herself, is resorted to by some of the more primitive of Russian tribes, and by some of our own Indians, especially the Sioux, and

there, more particularly, for the expression of the after-birth. The belt called the squaw belt, a broad leather strap with several buckles, is commonly used; after the delivery of the child, as the patient stands up, her legs apart, she herself draws tight the belt, and thus expresses the after-birth, which readily drops out by sheer force of gravity, assisted by this forcible vis a tergo.

(7.) Pressure against the staff. The Indians of the Uintah Valley Agency are delivered in a kneeling posture, but as soon as the child is expelled, the patient, who continues to drink freely of hot water, arises to her feet, places a folded cloth on her abdomen, and leaning forward over the stake, some three feet in length, which has served her as a support during labor, she raises her body upon it, thus exerting considerable pressure over the hypochondriac region and favoring the expulsion of the placenta; and it is thus delivered without any further assistance. This practice also exists among the Crows, Creeks, and similar tribes. The Negrita woman, who is unable to allow herself the assistance of the medicine man, presses her abdomen against a bamboo, in order in some measure to replace the expression by the hands of an assistant. The squaw of the Pacific coast, who walks about during the first day after confinement, steps about slowly with a staff, frequently bending the body forward so as to bring the abdominal walls immediately over the region of the uterus against the upper end of the staff, which is protected by the hands of the woman. Thus, the flow of the lochia is facilitated and compression of the uterus furthered.

(8.) Lying prone upon the stomach upon a pillow. This peculiar method, so far as I can learn, is practiced only by the Creek Indians. The mother straps the pillow tightly to her chest with a belt, lies flat upon her face, and, as the labor proceeds, the strap is buckled tighter and tighter, until the expulsion is accomplished, the pressure being due, not so much to the tightening of the strap as to the pressure of the body upon the uterus, the pillow simply preventing the upward motion of the fundus. In Ceram, Loango, and other districts of Central Africa, the patient is also placed upon the stomach, if the labor does not progress, and the expulsion of the child is hastened by tramping upon the back of the sufferer, or placing heavy weights upon it.

II. MASSAGE. Massage, by which I understand a more complicated manipulation of the abdomen—the Shampoo of the Indies; the Cong-fou of the Chinese; the Ambouk of the Japanese—serves to correct the position of the child and to

stimulate the contractility of the uterine muscles, and is used wherever external manipulations are resorted to, almost always in connection with expression. It is used to correct malposition, to produce abortion, to stimulate labor pains, but, above all, for the expression of the after-birth and the prevention of post-partum hemorrhage. These manipulations are usually practiced very much in the same manner whatever position the patient assumes; and they serve the same purpose whatever the position of the patient may be—kneeling, squatting, resting in the lap of an assistant, or semi-recumbent—and they are best illustrated by Fig. 55, which is from a photograph taken for me amid great difficulties by my scientific friend, Prof. G. Barroeta, of San Luis Potosi, Mexico.

The patient kneels on the spread (B) prepared for her; this consists of a sheep-skin (S) covered with a cotton blanket (C) and a zarape (Z). Upon one end of this is put a cushion (H), upon which the patient places her head when she assumes the recumbent posture after delivery. The position of the parturient is upon her knees, supporting herself by the cord or lasso (L), which is suspended from the beam (W). Two assistants perform the customary manipulations. The partera, the more experienced and older of the two assistants, kneels before the sufferer; it is her business to manipulate the uterus, pressing and rubbing the fundus, at times placing one hand on the vulva, and preparing the coccyx. The younger, the tenedora, kneels behind the patient, pressing her knees upon her hips, and clasping the hands over her stomach, thus exercising pressure by the encircling arms, whilst the more experienced partera practices massage. (Dr. Kellog.) The tenedora assumes more active duties in difficult cases, either in retarded labor or retained placenta. She then raises the patient by her arms, shakes her as she would a sack, and lets her fall, partially catching her as she drops, with a shock and sudden compression of the abdomen whilst the parts are being kneaded. Although the methods are very much the same among all people and in all positions, slight differences are here and there observed; for instance, among the Papagos, one of the assistants places herself in a kneeling posture behind the patient, with one knee pressing upon the lumbar region, while she grasps the body of the sufferer with both hands immediately under the ribs in front. The other assistant places herself in a kneeling position in front of the patient, and with the palms of her hands rubs the abdomen thoroughly, the pressure being constantly exercised downwards from the spine of the ilium to the pubis. They appreciate the difference

between primipara and multipara, and with the former they do not resort to the same degree of pressure and friction as in the multipara, being evidently aware of the more firm tone of the abdominal muscles, and of the longer time needed. In Africa and in India, we find not unfrequently that warmth and oil aid in this process, as among the Gros-Ventres, where the assistant greases her hands with turtle fat and warms them over the hot embers, and quickly applying the heated hands to the patient's abdomen, rubs and presses it downward and backward. These manipulations are, of course, more readily practiced with the patient in a kneeling or squatting position, and especially when seated semi-recumbent in the lap of an assistant, whose encircling arms afford the means of compression. But with the necessary variations, it is the same whatever position the patient assumes. For instance, among the Hoopa, Klamath, or Penemone Indians, the patient lies down in a semi-recumbent position, whilst an assistant kneels at either side, rubbing and pressing the abdomen. So, also, among the Siamese, where the patient is on her back, a woman takes position on either side, and they begin by forcibly pressing the abdomen backward and down for three to five hours, and, if then they fail to expel the fetus, one tramps upon the abdomen, and, as we have learned, if this does not succeed, the more forcible method of suspension is resorted to. Instead of the hands, the thumbs and fists are used by some. For instance, as in Siam, where they shampoo the abdomen vigorously in this method, stroking and pressing it downward at the same time. Among some people I find no reference to the use of massage, but have considered this more as an omission upon the part of my informants. For instance, among the Chippewas and Blackfeet, lower and upper Yanktonais, nothing is said of the use of massage by my correspondent. So, also, among the Santees and Dakotas, the Cherokees, Choctaws, Chicasaws, Seminoles, Cheyennes, Arapahoes, Assneboines. It is, however, an almost universal agent, and, whether among our own Indians, the Mexicans, or natives of South America, the Vedas of India, the ancient Ainos, or the modern Japanese, the inhabitants of the Caucasus, or of the Himalayas, of the Australian Islands, or of Africa, we find that massage is everywhere the main and almost the only reliance in labor.

III. SHAKING UP OF THE PATIENT.—Though not strictly within the sphere of this paper, I will briefly refer to some of those peculiar and barbarous methods to which these primitive people resort in their despair. We have already observed how, in Mexico, the tenedora raises the patient up and drops her, catching her with a shock so as to shake out the uterine contents, shaking out the child from the womb as she would flour out of a sack. In Southern India, they shake her several times to promote delivery, but, if this does not answer, they roll the patient upon the ground, or suspend her by her feet and shake her several times. The object of this is, evidently, after they have seen that the child cannot be expelled in the natural way, to throw the fetus out of the pelvis proper into the roomier upper portion, so that it may change its position, and come with head or breech first. We find a precisely similar custom among the Nez-Percés Indians, who take the patient, if labor is prolonged, reverse her, and whilst the head rests upon the ground, shake the body vigorously in the air; then they lead her to a stake again and see if the condition of affairs is at all improved; if not, the process is again repeated. This they do several times, and, if finally it proves of no avail, the midwife introduces her hand, and pulls at whatever she can reach. If it happens to be a foot, well and good; if it happens to be an arm, the patient will probably be so injured that death results, as my correspondent tells me he has never heard of a woman surviving the graver accidents of parturition. The Esthonians hold the patient in the air, shaking her vigorously if labor is retarded. In Syria, the patient is rolled in a blanket if she is not confined within twenty-four hours after the commencement of labor, and four male or female friends seize the corners of the blanket and roll the poor woman about in various directions, and bounce her up and down to facilitate confinement.

IV. PERMANENT PRESSURE.—Bandages of cloth or leather, ropes or belts, are occasionally resorted to, but are not found as often as in the lying-in room of civilization. They are used here and there in pregnancy, labor, and child-bed. In pregnancy, the binder is used in Japan from about the fifth month on to prevent the growth of the child, so that it may not

become too large, and delivery may be easy. In India and in Burmah, as well as among one or two of our own lndian tribes, the bandage is used, tightly worn, after the seventh month, in order that the uterus may not ascend too high, that the child may not have so far to go when it wishes to escape. In labor, the simple binder is rarely resorted to. Usually when the binder is applied, it serves as an active means of compression; but among one of the Indian tribes, as we have seen, the simple belt is used, which is pressed down so as to follow the uterus with each pain. In child-bed, or rather in the time following delivery, as the bed is but rarely resorted to, the binder plays a very insignificant part. We have seen, especially among the Sioux, the squaw belt used, but it is worn for only, perhaps, twelve hours after labor. In Mexico, a tight bandage is sometimes used, or a rope. In Old Calabar, a simple handkerchief answers the purpose. The Kiowas, Comanches, and several other Indian tribes use it; but whether travellers or other authorities who have written upon the subject neglected to mention the binder or not, I rarely hear of it. D. THE USES OF MASSAGE AND EXPRESSION.

In speaking of the different kinds of external manipulations and the various methods of applying them, we have naturally spoken to some extent of the purposes for which they are used. But it may be well to consider these somewhat more in detail, and I will endeavor to describe the various purposes served by these external manipulations in pregnancy, labor, and in childbirth.

I. PREGNANCY.—Steady pressure, as we have seen, is used to prevent the undue growth of the ovum; but massage properly is resorted to for the purpose (1) of correcting malpositions. Thus, in Japan, the medicine-man manipulates the abdomen of the patient, who clings about his neck, pressing his shoulders against her breasts, and pressing his knees between hers, so that she is firmly supported. Then he practices a lateral massage with his hands, beginning at the seventh cervical vertebra, and rubbing downward and forward, rubbing also the nates and hips with the palms of his hands, repeating the movement from sixty to seventy times every morning after the fifth month. This, I judge, is only in case of wealthy or handsome patients, or when malpositions are expected for certain superstitious

reasons. By far more frequently is massage used for the purpose (2) of producing abortion. Among some of our own Indians, the Piutes among others, many of the natives of Australia, the inhabitants of the Sierra Leone, and of the interior of Africa, the Loango negroes, and others, produce abortion, either by firmly kneading and rubbing the abdomen with the hands, or pounding and working it with their fists. Many do it for criminal purposes, others because they dread the often fatal labor with half-breed children. This is a somewhat remarkable circumstance, but true among our own Indians upon the Pacific Coast and in the interior, in Australia, and in India, that labor following intercourse with whites is always tedious and dangerous, frequently ending in the death of both mother and child. Hence they produce abortion in preference to undergoing this ordeal. In India and in Africa, abortion is often produced when the mother is suckling one infant and finds herself pregnant with another.

II. LABOR.—Massage in (1) normal labor is almost invariably used unless the case be a very simple and rapid one, or the poor sufferer be without friends and means. It serves the purpose of improving or correcting the position of the child, of stimulating the uterine contractions, and of directly aiding by mechanical pressure the muscular action. A slight variation, ordinary flexion and pressure upon the abdomen, regular massage, combined with expression, is used in ordinary cases.

(2.) Malposition.—In cases of malposition, which are only discovered by the simple fact that the child is not expelled in proper time, more violent means are resorted to, such as forcible kneading, shaking, tossing in a blanket, and tramping upon the abdomen. Thus, by violent means, there is a possibility of forcing the child into its proper axis, with breech or head in the pelvis, and this done, of forcing it out through the natural passages. These external manipulations are, as we have seen, their only resort; and as death is the consequence of an undelivered child, every means in their power must be taken to expel it; and these very forcible means must almost inevitably force a rupture somewhere. If the child is not crowded out through the natural outlet, a place of least resistance will be found elsewhere; the womb or abdominal walls must give way. The child must out or the patient must die.

(3.) Placenta. The placenta usually follows the child, but unless this is the case, massage and expression are invariably resorted to. Frequently the patient retains the same position which she assumed during labor, and the attendants continue the same manipulations until the after-birth is expelled. Rarely does she assume a different position, as among the Sioux, where the squaw belt is used, the parturient jumps up after the delivery of the child, draws tight her belt, and thus forces out the placenta. Then, again, others press with the abdomen against a staff fast in the ground. In short, the milder means of massage and expression are used in this stage of labor by the various people. It may be again remarked that primitive people, odd as it may seem, rarely pull upon the cord, but in most instances use the vis a tergo, stimulate the activity of the womb by friction of the fundus, and press out the contents. Massage, combined with expression of various kinds, never very forcible, is used in this stage of labor.

III. CHILD-BED. I have not found any reference to the use of massage after the expulsion of the placenta. Expression, of course, does not come in question; but permanent pressure, as we have already seen, is occasionally used. I will not here again refer to it, as being really foreign to our subject. In some few instances, as among certain tribes upon the Pacific coast, some pressure is at times exercised upon the abdomen during the first day after confinement, the patient walking about, occasionally stops to lean with the abdomen upon a staff, and the compression of the uterus forces out the discharge. Among some of the Indian tribes, but especially among the natives of Africa and India, the infant is thoroughly kneaded and massaged after each bath; and this very excellent procedure undoubtedly serves to strengthen the tender muscles. E. THE DEVELOPMENT OF EXTERNAL MANIPULATION IN RECENT OBSTETRIC PRACTICE.

The use of external manipulation in child-birth is, as we have seen, a most ancient and venerable practice, forgotten by civilization for ages, and only of late years again accorded the importance which simple-minded, primitive people have always conceded to it.

Phélippeaux, in his "Etude Pratique sur les Frictions et le Massage,'' Paris, 1870, justly says: Within a few years, in

the presence of numerous well-authenticated and, we may almost say, marvellous facts, a return has been brought about to a legitimate and long-forgotten practice. To-day the most illustrious masters look kindly upon a method of treatment as old as the world, which has now been deprived of the surrounding fables and charlatanism. The use of external manipulations in obstetric practice has rapidly advanced in importance in the course of this century. In 1812, Wigand discovered the important fact that, by the aid of external pressure, malpositions could be corrected; but his views, although addressed to the academies of Berlin and Paris, were neglected and forgotten: yet he had only stated distinctly what Hippocrates had vaguely indicated, and what Jacob Rueffius and Mercurius Scipio had urged. The Hamburg obstetrician was forgotten until 1859, when the translation of his work by Belin and Hergott appeared in Strasburg. This was taken up by Stoltz and Cazeaux. Then comes Wright, of Cincinnati, and, soon after, Braxton Hicks, to whom the credit has so long been unjustly given; and in 1853 and in 1860, Credé, who so earnestly advocated delivery by means of expression, endeavoring to imitate nature as nearly as possible by provoking uterine contractions, forcing the descent by a vis a tergo, the hand never touching the genitals of the patient, the entry of air, as well as traumatism, were impossible. Credé's method was already indicated by Busch in 1803. Then, in 1867, comes Kristeller, advocating uterine expression for the delivery of the child itself; and, in 1865, Martin, of Berlin, attempted to obtain the after-coming head by means of manual expression after the delivery of the body. Although Credé's method is so perfectly natural, simple in principle, and easy in application, it has yet but slowly asserted itself. Even in Germany, among his immediate surroundings, it was a long time before the method gained ground. (L'Expression Utérine, A. T. Suchard, Paris, 1872.) In 1856, von Ritgen urged that the forceps should never be used without the accompanying aid of manual expression, and Seyfert, of Prague, pointed out the merits of these methods at every possible opportunity, on account of his great aversion to all such methods of delivery which necessitated the introduction of hand or instrument into the genital tract. He sought to obtain the delivery of the uterine contents as does nature herself, by pressure from above, not by traction from below.

Massage and expression being the only resort in the hands of primitive people for the completion of difficult labor, they intuitively, by instinct and by long practice, not by scientific reasoning, of course, have brought them to a certain state of perfection, although brute force is more relied upon than dexterous manipulation. The methods are so simple, so natural, and so thoroughly in accordance with sound mechanical principles, that they have produced good results. Deprived of the brutality of physical force and aided by science, these very means which have so long and so well served the ignorant will attain a high degree of perfection, and will serve by far better the scientific obstetrician.