University of Virginia Library

Search this document 
The Plan of St. Gall

a study of the architecture & economy of & life in a paradigmatic Carolingian monastery
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
 I. 
CONTENTS: VOLUME I
  
  
expand section 
  

expand sectionI. 
expand sectionII. 
expand sectionIII. 
expand sectionIV. 


xiii

Page xiii

CONTENTS: VOLUME I

                                       

xiv

Page xiv
                                                   

xv

Page xv
                                               

xvi

Page xvi
                                             

xvii

Page xvii
                           
page 
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS  vii 
FOREWORD by Wolfgang Braunfels  ix 
SYNOPSIS OF THE WORK a schematic outline  xviii 
of the arrangement and main divisions of this work in three volumes 
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS and CORRIGENDA & ERRATA see Volume III 
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS used in this work  xx 
PREFACE by Walter Horn  xxi 
including an illustration of the Plan with identification of buildings and other
features of the Plan, keyed to a trilingual index 
PREVIOUS LITERATURE, ORIGIN, PURPOSE & SPECIAL PROBLEMS 
I.1 
PREVIOUS LITERATURE 
INTRODUCTION I.1.1 The MIDDLE AGES TO MIDDLE 19th CENTURY I.1.2 FIRST
MONOGRAPHIC STUDIES I.1.3 ENTRY OF THE SPECIALISTS I.1.4 A NEW ERA: THE FACSIMILE EDITION
of 1952 I.1.5 THE INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM at ST. GALL, 1957 I.1.6 COUNCIL OF EUROPE EXHIBITION
KARL DER GROSSE AND ITS IMPETUS I.1.7 THE SCOPE OF THE PRESENT STUDY 
I.2 
THE DEDICATORY LEGEND 
I.2.1 WORDING & IMPLICATIONS 
I.3 
ABBOT GOZBERT, ORDERER & RECEIVER OF THE PLAN  10 
I.3.1 GOZBERT'S IDENTITY I.3.2 ST. GALL AT THE TIME OF GOZBERT'S ACCESSION
I.3.3 ADMINISTRATIVE ACCOMPLISHMENTS & DECISION TO REBUILD the MONASTERY 
I.4 
THE MAKER OF THE PLAN: BISHOP HAITO OF BASEL?  11 
I.4.1 OTHER CONTENDERS & OTHER VIEWS I.4.2 HAITO the MOST REASONABLE CHOICE 
I.5 
EXPLANATORY LEGENDS & SCRIPTORIAL HOME OF THE PLAN  13 
I.5.1 DISTINCTION BETWEEN GENERAL & SPECIFIC TITLES I.5.2 TWO HANDS
REPRESENTING TWO STAGES of DEVELOPMENT in the SCRIPTORIUM of REICHENAU I.5.3 CONCEPT OF
AUTHORSHIP & HAITO 
I.6 
ORIGINAL OR COPY?  15 
I.6.1 SOME TECHNICAL OBSERVATIONS 
I.7 
THE PLAN & ITS RELATION TO THE MONASTIC REFORM MOVEMENT  20 
I.7.1 PROTOTYPAL CHARACTER of the PLAN I.7.2 GENERAL AIM of the MONASTIC REFORM
MOVEMENT I.7.3 SPECIFIC RULINGS of the MONASTIC REFORM MOVEMENT affecting MONASTIC
ARCHITECTURE I.7.4 CONCLUSIONS 
I.8 
PRESUMABLE DATE OF THE PLAN  25 
I.9 
THE PROTOTYPE PLAN  27 
I.9.1 SOME REFLECTIONS ABOUT IT & ITS RELATION to the CATHEDRAL OF COLOGNE 
I.10 
HOW THE PLAN WAS DRAWN AND ASSEMBLED  35 
I.10.1 NUMBER OF SHEETS & SEQUENCE IN WHICH THEY WERE SEWN TOGETHER
I.10.2 SUCCESSIVE STAGES IN TRACING THE PLAN 
I.11 
THE CONCEPTUAL HOMOGENEITY OF THE PLAN  50 
I.11.1 HOMOGENEITY IN QUESTION I.11.2 THE CAROLINGIAN CONCEPT OF UNITY
(UNITAS): A COUNTER ARGUMENT 
I.12 
METHOD OF RENDERING  53 
I.12.1 USE OF DIFFERENT COLORS FOR DRAWING & EXPLANATORY TITLES
I.12.2 COMBINATION OF VERTICAL & HORIZONTAL PROJECTION I.12.3 LACK OF DEFINITION OF WALL
THICKNESS I.12.4 DIFFERENTIATION of LEVELS in DOUBLE-STORIED STRUCTURES I.12.5 LACK of
SPECIFIC INFORMATION CONCERNING BUILDING MATERIALS I.12.6 DIFFERENTIAL ATTENTION IN
RENDERING OF DOORS I.12.7 THE PLAN IN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE 
I.13 
OMISSIONS AND OVERSIGHTS  65 
I.13.1 INTENT OR INADVERTENCY I.13.2 STAIRS I.13.3 DOORS & WINDOWS
I.13.4 FIREPLACES & LOUVERS I.13.5 WATERWAYS I.13.6 PERIPHERAL ENCLOSURE WALL I.13.7 PRIVIES
I.13.8 KITCHEN FOR SERFS & WORKMEN 
I.14 
SCALE & CONSTRUCTION METHODS USED IN DESIGNING THE PLAN  77 
I.14.1 INCONSISTENCIES BETWEEN DRAWING & EXPLANATORY TITLES I.14.2 PREVIOUS
INTERPRETATIONS I.14.3 THE SCALE used in DESIGNING the PLAN I.14.4 SCALE of the PLAN & ITS
RELATION to the CAROLINGIAN FOOT I.14.5 PURPOSEFUL MODIFICATIONS I.14.6 SUCCESSIVE STAGES
in the CONCEPTUAL GROWTH of the LAYOUT OF CHURCH and CLAUSTRUM I.14.7 DIFFICULT OR
INSOLUBLE FEATURES I.14.8 CONCLUSIONS I.14.9 CONFIRMING EVIDENCE 
I.15 
THE PROBLEM OF SCALE AND FUNCTION  112 
I.15.1 SCHEMATIC DRAWING OR BUILDING PLAN? 
I.16 
THE PLAN AND THE ROMAN CASTRUM  114 
I.17 
NUMERI SACRI 3 4 7 10 12 40  118 
II 
THE MONASTERY CHURCH 
II.1 
DESCRIPTION  127 
INTRODUCTION II.1.1 APPROACH II.1.2 ATRIUM II.1.3 TOWERS II.1.4 WESTERN APSE
II.1.5 AISLES II.1.6 NAVE II.1.7 TRANSEPT II.1.8 PRESBYTERY II.1.9 EASTERN APSE II.1.10 CRYPT
II.1.11 SACRISTY & VESTRY II.1.12 SCRIPTORIUM & LIBRARY II.1.13 EASTERN PARADISE 
II.2 
RECONSTRUCTION  159 
II.2.1 THE CHURCH AS DEFINED in the DRAWING II.2.2 THE CHURCH in light of its
CORRECTIVE TITLES 
II.3 
HISTORICAL EVALUATION  187 
II.3.1 SALIENT FEATURES OF THE CHURCH II.3.2 LENGTH OF THE CHURCH
II.3.3 EXTENDED EASTERN ALTAR SPACE (FORE CHOIR) II.3.4 DISENGAGED CROSSING II.3.5 CRYPTS
II.3.6 COUNTER APSE II.3.7 SEMICIRCULAR ATRIA II.3.8 DETACHED TOWERS II.3.9 PLURALITY OF ALTARS
II.3.10 SQUARE SCHEMATISM 
III 
THE CLOISTERS AND THE ABBOT'S HOUSE 
III.1 
THE CLOISTER OF THE MONKS  241 
III.1.1 LAYOUT III.1.2 THE "SCATTERED" PLAN of the IRISH MONASTERIES III.1.3 FIRST
APPEARANCE OF THE SQUARE CLOISTER III.1.4 CLOISTER YARD III.1.5 DORMITORY & WARMING ROOM
III.1.6 MONKS' PRIVY III.1.7 MONKS' LAUNDRY & BATHHOUSE III.1.8 REFECTORY & VESTIARY
III.1.9 MONKS' KITCHEN III.1.10 CELLAR & LARDER III.1.11 PARLOR 
III.2 
NOVITIATE AND INFIRMARY  311 
III.2.1 TWO AUTONOMOUS CLOISTERS in a SYMMETRICAL BUILDING COMPLEX
III.2.2 TWO CHAPELS in a CHURCH INTERNALLY HALVED III.2.3 NOVITIATE III.2.4 INFIRMARY
III.2.5 KITCHEN & BATHHOUSES III.2.6 SCHEME OF THE COMPLEX III.2.7 NOVITIATE & INFIRMARY
COMPLEX in the CONTEXT of the WHOLE PLAN III.2.8 RECONSTRUCTION 
III.3 
THE ABBOT'S HOUSE  321 
III.3.1 THE AULA III.3.2 OTHER BUILDINGS of the SAME TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION
III.3.3 RECONSTRUCTION III.3.4 THE ABBOT'S RIGHT TO LIVE in a SEPARATE HOUSE III.3.5 LATER
PRACTICES 
IV 
THE MONASTIC POLITY 
INTRODUCTION  327 
IV.1 
THE MONASTIC OFFICIALS  330 
IV.1.1 THE ABBOT (ABBAS) IV.1.2 THE PROVOST OR PRIOR IV.1.3 THE DEAN (DECANUS)
IV.1.4 THE CELLARER (CELLARARIUS) IV.1.5 THE CHAMBERLAIN (CAMERARIUS) IV.1.6 THE PORTER
(OSTIARIUS) IV.1.7 THE WARDEN OF THE SICK (CUSTOS INFIRMORUM) IV.1.8 THE MASTER
OF NOVICES (MAGISTER PULSANTIUM) IV.1.9 THE SACRISTAN (CUSTOS ECCLESIAE)
IV.1.10 THE CHOIRMASTER (CANTOR) IV.1.11 THE LIBRARIAN (BIBLIOTHECARIUS or ARMARIUS)
IV.1.12 THE KEEPER OF CHARTERS (CUSTOS CARTARUM
IV.2 
THE MONKS  337 
IV.2.1 ELIGIBILITY & BACKGROUND IV.2.2 NOVICES & OBLATES IV.2.3 DAILY ROUTINE 
IV.3 
LAYMEN  341 
IV.3.1 THE MONASTERY'S INDUSTRIAL & AGRICULTURAL FORCE OF LABOR 
IV.4 
NUMBER OF MONKS AND SERFS  342 
IV.4.1 MONKS (RELIGIOSI) IV.4.2 WORKMEN, SERFS, & SERVANTS (FAMILIA
IV.5 
THE MONASTERY'S MILITARY OBLIGATIONS  347 
IV.5.1 MEN & HORSES FOR BATTLE & OTHER SUPPORTIVE SERVICES 
IV.6 
THE MONASTERY AS A MANORIAL CORPORATION  349 
IV.6.1 OUTLYING ESTATES 
IV.7 
THE MONASTERY AS A CULTURAL INSTITUTION  351 
IV.7.1 SUPERIORITY IN MORAL & IN MANAGERIAL STANDARDS IV.7.2 SUPERIOR
TECHNOLOGICAL STANDARDS IV.7.3 SUPERIOR STANDARDS IN THE ART OF WINE MAKING & IN LARGE
SCALE PRODUCTION OF WINE AND BEER IV.7.4 SUPERIOR METHODS OF SANITATION
IV.7.5 CULTIVATION OF LINGUISTIC & INTELLECTUAL SKILLS IV.7.6 THE MONASTIC TIMETABLE & ITS
EFFECT UPON THE CREATION OF A MODERN CONCEPT OF TIMING IV.7.7 DEVELOPMENT OF NEW
CONCEPTS IN ARCHITECTURE 
INDEX TO THE WORK, see Volume III 
See also Synopsis of the Work, a comprehensive abstract of the plan of this work, next page 
[ILLUSTRATION]