University of Virginia Library

Search this document 
History of the early settlement and Indian wars of Western Virginia

embracing an account of the various expeditions in the West, previous to 1795. Also, biographical sketches of Ebenezer Zane, Major Samuel M'Colloch, Lewis Wetzel, Genl. Andrew Lewis, Genl. Daniel Brodhead, Capt. Samuel Brady, Col. Wm. Crawford, other distinguished actors in our border wars
  
  
  
  
  
  
  

expand sectionI. 
expand sectionII. 
expand sectionIII. 
expand sectionIV. 
expand sectionV. 
collapse sectionVI. 
INDIAN WARS.
expand sectionI. 
 A. 
 B. 
 C. 
 C. 
 E. 
expand sectionII. 
  
expand sectionVII. 



No Page Number

VI. PART VI.

VI. INDIAN WARS.

1775-1795.

CHAPTER I.

DEPREDATIONS EAST OF THE MOUNTAINS.

Although this part of our work is designed chiefly to embrace
the operations, by and against, the western Indians
during the twenty years immediately preceding the treaty of
Greenville, still we cannot pass without some notice those
which occurred prior to the peace of November, 1774. Premising
this much, we will turn back the pages of history and
briefly glance at some of the bolder acts in the bloody drama,
performed on the then frontier of Virginia.

Allusion has already been made to the irruptions of savages
in the Valley of Virginia, during the years following Braddock's
defeat. One of their earliest acts was the captivity
of a Mrs. Neff on the south-branch of the Wappatomaca.
Having secured their prisoner and helped themselves to some
plunder, the savages (fourteen in number) left for their homes,
by way of Fort Pleasant.[1] On the second night, they reached


202

Page 202
the vicinity of the fort, and leaving Mrs. Neff in the care of
an old Indian, the warriors separated into two parties, that
they might better watch the fort.

"At a late hour in the night, Mrs. Neff discovering that
her guard was pretty soundly asleep, ran off. The old fellow
very soon awoke, fired off his gun, and raised a yell. Mrs.
N. ran between the two parties of Indians, got safe into Fort
Pleasant, and gave notice where the enemy were encamped.
A small party the same evening came from another fort a few
miles above, and joined their friends in Fort Pleasant. After
the escape of Mrs. N., the Indians collected into a deep glen,
near the fort. Early the next morning, sixteen men, well
mounted and armed, left the fort with a view to attack the
Indians. They soon discovered their encampment by the
smoke of their fire. The whites divided themselves into two
parties, intending to enclose the Indians, but unfortunately,
a small dog which followed them, starting a rabbit, alarmed
the Indians, upon which they cautiously moved off, passed
between the two parties of white men unobserved, took a position
between them and their horses, and opened a most destructive
fire. The whites returned the fire with great firmness
and bravery, and a desperate and bloody conflict ensued.
Seven of the whites fell dead, and four were wounded. The
others retreated to the fort. Three Indians fell in this battle,
and several were wounded. The victors secured the white
men's horses, and took them off. This was called the battle
of the Trough.

Just before the above action commenced, Mr. Vanmeter,
an old man, mounted his horse, rode upon a high ridge, and
witnessed the battle. He returned with all speed to the fort,
and gave notice of the defeat."

These repeated depredations of the savages, induced Gov.
Dinwiddie, early in 1756, to order an expedition against the
Indian towns on the Ohio. Maj. Andrew Lewis was appointed
to command this expedition, and directed to proceed against
the Shawanese villages near the mouth of the Great Kanawha.


203

Page 203
Major Lewis led his men through great peril and suffering
within a few miles of the Ohio, when a message ordering a
return of the expedition reached him. The whole party suffered
intensely during this march, and once were reduced to
the necessity of cutting their buffalo skins into tugs and
eating them; hence the name of Tug river.[2]

The Indians having noticed the advance and return of this
expedition, naturally supposed that it was deemed unsafe to
penetrate the Indian country with a force so inadequate to
the duty before them; and thus elated, pushed their acts of
depredation with increased fury. They struck across the
mountains by way of the Kanawha, Monongahela, Cheat, &c.,
carrying death to many a helpless family, and spreading alarm
throughout the entire valley.

In the summer of 1757, a body of Shawanese, led on by
their celebrated chief Kill-buck, crossed the Alleghanies and
committed various acts of depredation. Some thirty or forty
of this party appeared in the neighborhood of Edward's fort
and killed two men at a mill, whom they scalped, and then
made off, taking with them a quantity of meal. Information
having been conveyed to the fort, forty men, under Captain
Mercer, started in pursuit of the murderers. The Indians,
expecting this, concealed themselves beneath a bank and
awaited the approach of the whites. As a decoy, they had
strewn along the path some of the meal taken from the mill.
Mercer's party discovering this, supposed the Indians were
making a speedy retreat, and, not apprized of their strength,


204

Page 204
moved on at a brisk step, until the whole party were drawn
immediately over the line of Indians beneath the bank, when
the latter opened a most destructive fire upon them, sixteen
falling dead at the first discharge. The others attempting to
save themselves by flight, were pursued and slaughtered in
every direction, until, out of the forty, but six escaped to the
fort. One poor fellow, who ran up the side of the mountain,
was fired at by an Indian; the ball penetrated just above his
heel, ranged up his leg, shivering the bones, and lodged a
little below his knee; he slipped under the lap of a fallen
tree and there hid himself, and lay in that situation for two
days and nights before he was discovered by his friends. It
was that length of time before the people at the fort would
venture out to collect and bury the dead. This wounded man
recovered, and lived many years after.

Some time afterwards, the Indians, in much greater force,
and aided, it was believed, by several whites, determined to
carry this fort by storm. The garrison had been considerably
reinforced; among others, by the late Gen. Daniel Morgan,
then a young man. The Indians made the assault with great
boldness; but on this occasion they met with a sad reverse of
fortune. The garrison sallied out, and a desperate battle
ensued. The assailants were defeated with great slaughter,
while the whites lost comparatively but few men.[3]

These constant inroads of the savages induced the people
to erect suitable forts at convenient points. Many of
these little stockades arose along the Valley, which greatly
served to protect the inhabitants and restrain the savages.
Of these were Ashby's, on Patterson creek, near the present
town of Frankfort; Hedges, on the road from Martinsburg
to Bath; Riddel's and Wardon's, on Lost river; George's,
near Petersburg, &c.

During the following year, (1758,) the savages again re-appeared


205

Page 205
east of the mountains, and spread desolation and
terror wherever they went. These visitations, doubtless for
better security, were generally made in large parties, and
their presence could not but create alarm among the sparsely
populated settlements. The following account of one of these
marauding parties, we take from the interesting local history
of that region. A party of about fifty Indians, penetrated the
neighborhood of Mill creek, about nine miles south of Woodstock.
This was pretty thickly settled; and among other
houses, George Painter had erected a large log one, with a
good sized cellar. On the alarm being given, the neighboring
people took refuge in this house. Late in the afternoon they
were attacked. Mr. Painter, attempting to fly, had three
balls shot through his body, and fell dead, when the others
surrendered. The Indians dragged the dead body back to
the house, threw it in, plundered the house of what they
chose, and then set fire to it. While the house was in flames,
consuming the body of Mr. Painter, they forced from the
arms of their mothers four infant children, hung them up in
trees, shot them in savage sport, and left them hanging.
They then set fire to a stable containing sheep and calves.
After these atrocities they moved off with forty-eight prisoners;
among whom were Mrs. Painter, five of her daughters,
and one of her sons; a Mrs. Smith and several of her children;
a Mr. Fisher and several of his children, among them a
lad of twelve or thirteen years old, a fine well grown boy, and
remarkably fleshy. This little fellow, it will presently be seen,
was destined to be the victim of savage cruelty.

Two of Painter's sons, and a young man by the name of
Jacob Myers, escaped. One of the Painters, with Myers,
ran over that night to Powell's fort, a distance of at least
fifteen miles, and to Keller's fort, for aid. A small party of
men set out early the next morning, well mounted and armed.
They reached Mr. Painter's early in the day; but on learning
the strength of the Indians, they declined going in pursuit,
as they were too weak to follow.


206

Page 206

After six days' travel they reached their villages, and held
a council, when it was determined to sacrifice their helpless
prisoner, Jacob Fisher. They first ordered him to collect a
quantity of dry wood. The poor little fellow shuddered,
burst into tears, and told his father they intended to burn
him. His father replied, "I hope not;" and advised him to
obey. When he had collected a sufficient quantity of wood
to answer their purpose, they cleared and smoothed a ring
around a sapling, to which they tied him by one hand, then
formed a trail of wood around the tree, and set it on fire.
The poor boy was then compelled to run round in this ring of
fire until his rope wound him up to the sapling, and then back
until he came in contact with the flame, whilst his infernal
tormentors were drinking, singing, and dancing around him,
with "horrid joy." This was continued for several hours;
during which time the wretches became beastly drunk, and
as they fell to the ground, their squaws would keep up the
fire. With long sharp poles, they pierced the body of their
victim whenever he flagged, until the poor and helpless boy
fell and expired with the most excruciating torments, whilst
his father and brothers were compelled to be witnesses of the
heart-rending tragedy.

After an absence of about three years, Mrs. Painter, with
her son and two of her daughters; Mrs. Smith, who had the
honor, if it could be so deemed, of presenting her husband
with an Indian son,[4] by a distinguished chief; Fisher, and his
surviving sons, with several others, returned home. Three of
Mrs. Painter's daughters remained with the Indians; one of
whom, after many years captivity, returned. The others
married and spent their lives with their swarthy companions.

In connection with this, we may state, that a most remarkable


207

Page 207
feature of the Indian life, was the peculiar power of
fascination which it exercised over those subjected to its
influence. Other instances are upon record which show that
this attachment to the allurements of savage life, was often
astonishing. The following will serve as an illustration.

About the year 1758, a man by the name of John Stone,
near what is called the White House, in the Hawksbill settlement,
was killed by Indians. Stone's wife, with her infant
child and a son about seven or eight years old, and George
Grandstaff, a youth of sixteen years old, were taken prisoners.
On the south-branch Mountain, the Indians murdered Mrs.
Stone and her infant, but took the boy and Grandstaff to
their towns. Grandstaff remained about three years a prisoner.
The boy Stone grew up with the Indians, came home, and
after obtaining possession of his father's property, sold it, got
the money, returned to the Indians and was never heard of
again.

 
[1]

This was a substantial stockade, with block-houses at each corner. It
stood on the south-branch of the Potomac, near what is known as the trough.
This place is memorable as the scene of a desperate and bloody battle.

[2]

Withers, in speaking of this expedition, calls it the "Sandy creek
voyage," and places it in 1757. He also says, that one of its objects was to
destroy the French town of Gallipolis, and that it returned, in obedience to
the order of Governor Fauquier. Our venerable author has committed two
or three most glaring errors in these few lines, which we feel it our duty to
notice. The expedition did not take place in '57, but '56; the "hostile
town of Gallipolis," which the Virginians were going to destroy, did not have
an existence until nearly forty years afterwards; and Governor Fauquier,
whose orders it is alleged, countermanded the movement, did not arrive in
Virginia from England, until June, 1758.

[3]

This stockade was on the west side of Capon river, not far from where
the present road from Winchester to Romney crosses.

[4]

Smith received his wife, and never maltreated her on this account; but
he had a most bitter aversion to the young chief. The boy grew up to manhood,
and exhibited the appearance and disposition of his sire. Attempts
were made to educate him, but without success. He enlisted into the army
of the Revolution as a common soldier, and never returned.

MASSACRE AT SEYBERT'S FORT.

There is no accomplishment which the Indian warrior more
delights in than that of strategy. Studying from boyhood to
excel in this particular, he often becomes so skilful as to outwit
his more cautious, and frequently less sagacious antagonist.
Where, in ancient or modern history, do we find schemes
better matured and more successfully executed than those of
Pontiac? The capture of Mackinaw never has been surpassed
for ingenuity and skill; while the terrible catastrophe at fort
Massac, stands without a precedent either among civilized or
savage men. The famed wooden horse of old, from whose
capacious body issued the armed foe against the astonished
and bewildered Trojans, was but a dull idea compared with the
admirable finesse of the American savage on the lower Ohio,
or northern lake. We premise this much, to introduce a case
of fatal subtlety in our own State,—the capture of a small


208

Page 208
frontier post known as Seybert's fort, which stood on the
south-branch of the Potomac, about twelve miles west of the
present town of Franklin, in Pendleton county. It was a rude
enclosure, cut out of the heart of the forest, but sufficiently
strong to have resisted any attack from the enemy had the
inmates themselves but been strong. Our artist has given a
very correct representation of this early and memorable fortress,
the history of which fills such a dark page in the annals
of Virginia.

Seybert's fort served as a place of resort for the people of
all the adjoining settlements. Into this they gathered in times
of threatening danger, and remained during the seasons when


209

Page 209
the Indians were most troublesome. In May, 1758, a party
of Shawanese invested the fort, and demanded a surrender.
Finding neither threatening words nor bullets of any avail,
the cunning savages, after two days' trial, resorted to strategy,
and, unhappily, with most fatal success. They made
various propositions to the besieged to give up, and their
lives should be spared; if not, the siege should be continued
and every soul massacred.

The promise of safety lured the unfortunate victims from
their line of duty, and they yielded quiet possession of the fort.
There were thirty persons at the time within the enclosure,
and these the savages proceeded to secure. Instantly the
whites realized the horror of their situation, and saw the
inevitable doom which awaited them. In a moment of false
security, they trusted to the promise of savages, and now
were about to pay the folly with their lives. Of the whole
number, all were massacred but eleven. Various accounts of
the mode of massacre have been given, but the following is
doubtless most correct. Ten, whom they wished to save, were
secured and removed from the fort, the others were tied hand
and foot, and seated in a continuous line upon a log. Behind
each of the unfortunates stood a stalwart savage, who, at a
given signal, sunk his tomahawk through the skull of his
quivering victim. The work was soon finished, and the fort
destroyed. This horrible scene was witnessed by a youth
named Dyer, who was spared, although not of the number
removed from the limits of the fort. He was taken to Logstown,
on the Ohio, and thence to the Shawanee towns on the
Scioto. After nearly two years' captivity he escaped, and
made his way home. Of the other ten borne off as prisoners,
nothing satisfactory is known.

It was during this year (1758) that an incident occurred near
the present village of Petersburg, in Hardy, which stands
without a parallel in modern history. A man named Bingaman
lived with his family in a cabin, remote from any
neighbors. He had been cautioned against the Indians; but,


210

Page 210
a man of most determined resolution and herculean strength,
he laughed at the idea of fear, and said, no cut-throat savages
should ever drive him from his home. In the fall of this
year, a party of eight Indians made a descent upon his
cabin, late at night, while all the family were asleep. Before
Bingaman was aware of his danger, the savages had forced
the door, and were in the house. Mrs. Bingaman, the
younger,[5] was shot through the left breast, but not dangerously
wounded. Bingaman got his parents, wife and child
beneath the bed, and then prepared for battle. The hired man
was called down, but refused to come. The room was dark,
and having discharged his gun, he commenced beating about
at random with his heavy rifle. In this manner he fought with
the desperation of a giant, and terribly did his blows tell
upon the enemy. One after another he beat down before him,
until finally, of the eight, but one remained, and he, terror-stricken,
made from the house, and escaped to tell his tribe,
that he had met with a man who was a "perfect devil." The
intrepid Virginian had actually killed seven of his foes, which
certainly, is unexampled in the history of single-handed combat.
During the fight, the Indians frequently grappled their
powerful antagonist, but were unable to keep him down, as
early in the engagement he had pulled off his shirt. In the
morning, when he found that his wife was wounded, he became
so exasperated at the cowardice of the hired man that
he would have killed him, had not Mrs. Bingaman interposed
to save his life.

Bingaman afterwards moved to Natchez, where his son
Adam, who was a lad at the time of the fight, had previously
moved, and there he (the elder) died. Most of these facts we
have derived personally from the venerable William Darby,
of Washington city, who knew both the Bingamans at Natchez,
and heard from each of them a recital of the incidents


211

Page 211
of that terrible fight. Kercheval gives a somewhat different
version, but we have every reason to believe that our account
is in the main correct. We find in Kercheval another incident
illustrative of the energy and courage of this man, which
we give. A party of whites (of whom Bingaman was one) had
started in pursuit of some retreating Indians. They were
overtaken late at night, and the pursuing party dismounting,
the captain ordered Bingaman to remain with the horses,
whilst the rest made the attack. This he refused, and
followed after the company. "To make the destruction
of the enemy more certain, it was deemed advisable to wait
until daylight before they began the attack; but a young
man, whose zeal overcame his discretion, fired into the group,
upon which the Indians sprung to their feet and fled. Bingaman
singled out a fellow of giant-like size, whom he pursued,
throwing aside his rifle that his speed might not be retarded,
—passed several smaller Indians in the chase—came up with
him—and with a single blow of his hatchet cleft his skull.
When Bingaman returned to the battle-ground, the captain
sternly observed, `I ordered you to stay and guard the
horses.' Bingaman as sternly replied, `You are a rascal, sir;
you intended to disgrace me; and one more insolent word,
and you shall share the fate of that Indian,' pointing towards
the one he had just slain. The captain quailed under the stern
menace, and held his peace. The captain and Bingaman had,
a few days before, had a falling out. Several Indians fell in
this affair, while the whites lost none of their party."

The Indian depredations, during this and the following
years, were particularly fatal on the frontier settlements of
Virginia. Many families suffered severely and terribly. Of
these we will give a few as we find them related by the Historian
of the Valley. He gives many interesting incidents
connected with the early settlement of that part of Virginia,
which cannot but be interesting to the readers of the present
day.

In this year (1764), a party of eighteen Delawares crossed


212

Page 212
the mountains. Furman's Fort was about one mile above
hanging-rock, on the South Branch. William Furman and
Nimrod Ashby had gone out from the fort to watch a deer lick
in the Jersey mountains.[6] The Indians discovered and killed
them both, and passed on into the county of Frederick,
where they divided into two parties. One party of eight
moved on to Cedar creek settlement; the other of ten attacked
the people in the neighborhood of the present residence of
Maj. John White. On this place a stockade was erected. The
people in the neighborhood had taken the alarm, and were on
their way to this fort, when assaulted by these Indians. They
killed David Jones and his wife. Also some of Mrs. Thomas'
family, and carried off one of the daughters. An old man,
named Lloyd, and his wife, and several of his children, were
killed. Esther Lloyd, their daughter, about thirteen years
old, received three tomahawk wounds in the head, was scalped,
and left lying, supposed to be dead. Henry Clouser and two
of his sons were killed, and his wife and four of his daughters
taken. The youngest daughter was about two years old;
and as she impeded the mother's travelling, they dashed her
brains out against a tree, in the presence of the agonized
parent. Mrs. Thomas was taken to the Wappatomaka; but
the river being pretty full, and deep fording, they encamped
near Furman's fort for the night. The next morning a party
of white men fired off their guns at the fort, which alarmed
the Indians, and they hurried across the river, assisting all
their female prisoners, except Mrs. Thomas, who being quite
stout and strong, was left to struggle for herself. The current,
however, proved too strong for her, and she floated down the
river—but lodged against a rock, upon which she crawled,
and saved herself from drowning.

The other party of eight Indians committed several murders
on Cedar creek. It is probable this party killed a Mr. Lyle,
a Mr. Butler, and some others. Mr. Ellis Thomas, the husband


213

Page 213
of the woman whose story has just been given, was killed
the preceding harvest. This party of eight Indians took off
two female prisoners, but were pursued by some white men,
overtaken in the South Branch mountain, fired upon, and
one of the Indians killed. The others fled, leaving their
guns, prisoners and plunder.

The same year, (1764,) a party of eight Indians, with a
white man by the name of Abraham Mitchell, killed George
Miller, his wife and two children, within two miles of Strasburg.
They also the same day killed John Dellinger, and took his
wife, with her infant child, prisoners. In crossing Sandy
ridge, west of Capon river, this child had its brains beaten out
against a tree. A party of white men pursued them, overtook
them in the South Branch mountains, fired upon them,
and killed one, when the others fled, leaving every thing
behind.

In the latter part of this year, (1765,) the Indians made their
appearance in the neighborhood of Woodstock. They killed
an old man who, with some women and children, was making
his way to the fort at Woodstock. His name was George
Sigler.

Shortly before this, two Indians were discovered lurking
in the neighborhood of Mill creek. Matthias Painter, John
Painter, and William Moore, armed themselves, and went in
pursuit. They had not proceeded far, before they approached
a large fallen pine, with a very bushy top. As they neared
it, Matthias Painter observed, "We had better look sharp;
it is quite likely the Indians are concealed under the tops of
this tree." He had scarcely uttered the words before one of
them rose up and fired. The ball grazed the temple of John
Painter. Moore and Painter fired at the same instant; one
of their balls passed through the Indian's body, and he fell,
as they supposed, dead enough. The other fellow fled. The
white men pursued him some distance; but the fugitive was
too fleet for them. Finding they could not overhaul him, they
gave up the chase and returned to the pine tree: but to their
astonishment, the supposed dead Indian had moved off with


214

Page 214
both guns and a large pack of skins. They pursued his trail,
and when he found they were gaining upon him, he got into
a sink hole, and as soon as they approached, commenced
firing at them. He had poured out a quantity of powder on
dry leaves, filled his mouth with bullets, and using a musket
which was a self-primer, he was enabled to load and fire with
astonishing quickness. He thus fired at least thirty times
before they could get a chance to dispatch him. At last Mr.
Moore got an opportunity, and shot him through the head.
Moore and Painter had many disputes which gave the fellow
the first wound. Painter, at length, yielded, and Moore got
the premium allowed by law for Indian scalps.

The fugitive who made his escape, unfortunately met with
a young woman on horseback, named Sethon, whom he tore
from her horse, and forced off with him. This occurred near
the present town of Newmarket, and after travelling about
twenty miles, it is supposed the captive broke down from
fatigue, and the savage monster beat her to death with a
heavy pine knot. Her screams were heard by some people
who lived upwards of a mile from this scene of horror, and
who next day, on going to the place to ascertain the cause,
found her stripped and weltering in her blood.

Allusion has been made in another part of this volume to
the murder of the three Eckarlys, brothers, who, in 1755,
settled on what is now known as Dunker's bottom, Cheat
river. The circumstances were about these. Dr. Thomas
Eckarly and his two brothers, all members of that peculiar
Christian sect called Dunkers, visited the west, and erected
a cabin, soon after the murder of the unfortunate Files
family, to which reference has elsewhere been made. The
three brothers continued to occupy undisturbed, for a number
of years, their peaceful and quiet possessions. Growing short
of ammunition, &c., the elder brother went on a trading expedition
to the east. In returning, he stopped at Fort
Pleasant, and there not being a very friendly feeling entertained


215

Page 215
by many of the hardy bordermen toward this singular
sect, he was detained on a charge of being in alliance with
the Indians. At length, however, it was determined to send
a guard along with him, and if their suspicions were rightly
founded, he was to be brought back and dealt with accordingly.
In due time the escort reached the site of the humble
cabin in the forest, but, alas! the destroyer had been there,
and nothing remained but the half-consumed bodies of the
unfortunate brothers.

A few years subsequent to this, several settlers on the
Monongahela, near the mouth of Decker's creek, were cut off
by a party of Delawares. Of these, were Thomas Decker,
from whom the creek derives its name. But two or three
of the settlers escaped, and one of these, making his
way to Red-stone old fort, (Brownsville,) gave information
of the catastrophe. The commandant, Captain Paull, despatched
a message to Fort Pitt, conveying intelligence of
the visitation, and notifying Colonel Gibson of the probable
direction taken by the savages on their retreat. Colonel
Gibson, leaving the garrison in command of a subordinate
officer, passed rapidly down the river, hoping to intercept
them. In this, however, he failed; but came accidentally
upon a small party of Mingoes, encamped on Cross creek.
Little Eagle, a distinguished chief of that tribe, commanded
the party, and discovering the whites about the same time
that Gibson saw them, he gave a fearful whoop, and at the
same instant discharged his gun at the leader of the whites.
The ball passed through Gibson's coat, but without injuring
him. With the quickness of a tiger he sprang upon his foe,
and with one sweep of his sword, severed the head of Little
Eagle from his body. Two others were shot dead by the
whites, but the remainder escaped, and reported that the
white captain had cut off the head of their chief with a long
knife.
This was the origin of that celebrated and fearfully
significant term, the "long-knives." It was applied throughout


216

Page 216
the war to the Virginians, and even to this day has not
been forgotten by some of the western tribes. Captain Gibson,
himself a Virginian, acquired the soubriquet of "Long-knife
warrior," and was known by it always afterward.

In the Summer of 1761, there was an irruption of savages
into the James river settlement, attended with most fatal
results. The party embraced about fifty Shawanese warriors.
On Purgatory creek, they killed Thomas Perry, Joseph
Dennis, and a child; taking the wife of Dennis prisoner.
Thence they proceeded to the house of Robert Renick, making
prisoner of Mrs. Renick and her five children. Mr. Renick
being absent at the time, escaped, but only to fall at another
place. Proceeding to a near neighbor, where Mr. Renick happened
to be, they there killed him, and a man named Thomas
Smith, making captives of Smith's wife and a girl named Sally
Jew. At the time these murderous proceedings were going on,
three men (George Matthews, afterwards so distinguished in
the battles of Point Pleasant and Germantown, with two brothers
by the name of Maxwell,) rode up to the house, and discovering
the dead bodies of Smith and Renick lying in the
yard, made quick their retreat, but not before the Indians had
noticed their movements, and fired after them. One of the
Maxwells was slightly wounded in the arm. Mrs. Renick, on
her return to her friends, after a captivity of five years, said
the Indians saw the three men approach, and as they checked
up their horses at the fence, four of the Indians detailed for
that purpose, took aim, but the whites suddenly wheeling
their horses, saved their lives.

A party of the savages, twenty in number, were despatched
with their prisoners for the Ohio, whilst the remainder penetrated
further into the country to renew their depredations.
The alarm, however, had been sounded, and such of the
inhabitants as lived convenient, collected at Paull's fort.
Leaving five men to take care of the fort, a party of twenty-two,
headed by Matthews, went in pursuit. They were soon


217

Page 217
overhauled, and after a severe fight, compelled to give
way. In consequence of the intense darkness of the night,
it was found impossible to pursue the enemy further, and
the Indians rejoining their companions, made good their
escape with prisoners and booty. Nine Indians and three
whites were killed in the engagement, all of whom were decently
buried.

Of the prisoners, Mrs. Renick and two of her sons were
ransomed in 1766; one died in captivity; another intermarried
with the Indians and became a chief; and a third settled
on the Scioto, near Chillicothe, from whom has sprung an
extensive and highly respectable family. Hannah Dennis
made her escape after two years' captivity.

It was during this year (1763) that two of the Greenbriar
settlements, (Muddy creek, and Big Levels,) were entirely
cut off. A party of some fifty or sixty Shawanese, supposed
to have been headed by Cornstalk, penetrated the country
under the garb of friendship, and as no recent hostilities had
taken place in that region, the inhabitants fondly believed
there was no danger. With this fatal security, they received
the savages warmly and extended them every reasonable
hospitality. Suddenly, they fell upon the men, butchering
every one of them, and then made captives of the women and
children. They next visited the Levels, where Archibald
Clendenin had erected a rude block house, and where were
gathered quite a number of families. Here the Indians were
again entertained with hospitality. Mr. Clendenin had just
brought in three fine elk, upon which the savages feasted
sumptuously. One of the inmates was a decrepid old woman,
with an ulcerated limb; she undressed the member, and
asked an Indian if he could cure it. "Yes," he replied, and
immediately sunk his tomahawk into her head. This was the
signal, and instantly every man in the house was put to
death.


218

Page 218

The cries of the women and children alarmed a man in the
yard, who escaped and reported the circumstances to the
settlement at Jackson's river. The people were loth to believe
him, as the character of the Indians had been so peaceable.
Soon, however, they were convinced, for the savages appeared
and many of the fleeing families were massacred without
mercy. The prisoners were then marched off in direction
of the Ohio. Mrs. Clendenin proved herself in that trying
moment a woman fit to be one of the mothers of the west.
Indignant at the treachery and cowardly conduct of the
wretches, she did not fail to abuse them from the chief down,
in the most unmeasured manner. The savages, to intimidate
her, would flap the bloody scalp of her dead husband against
her face, and significantly twirl their tomahawks above her
head, but still the courageous woman talked to them like one
who felt her injuries, and feeling, resolved to express them.
On the day after her captivity, she saw an opportunity to
escape, and giving her infant to a woman, slipped unobserved
into a thicket. The child soon beginning to cry, one of the
Indians inquired concerning the mother, but getting no satisfactory
reply, swore he would "bring the cow to the calf,"
and taking the infant by the heels dashed out its brains
against a tree. Mrs. C. returned to her desolate home, and
secured the remains of her husband from the rapacious jaws
of the wild animals with which the woods abounded.

It is stated that a black woman in escaping from Mr.
Clendenin's house, killed her own child to prevent its cries
attracting the attention of the savages.

Such were some of the horrid realities felt and endured by
the first settlers of Western Virginia.

In October of this year, (1764,) a party of forty or fifty
Mingo and Delaware Indians crossed the Ohio, and ascending
Great Sandy came over on New river, where they
separated, and forming two parties, directed their steps


219

Page 219
toward different settlements—one party going towards Roanoke
and Catawba, the other in the direction of Jackson's
river. They had not long passed, when their trail was discovered
by three men, (Swope, Pack and Pitman,) who were
trapping on New river. These men followed the trail till they
came to where the Indian party divided; and judging from
the routes taken, that their object was to visit the Roanoke
and Jackson's river settlements, they determined to apprize
the inhabitants of their danger. Swope and Pack started for
Roanoke and Pitman for Jackson's river. But before they
could accomplish their object, the Indians had reached the
settlements on the latter river, and on Catawba.

The party which came to Jackson's river, travelled down
Dunlap's creek and crossed James river, above Fort Young,
in the night and unnoticed; and going down this river to
William Carpenter's, where was a stockade fort under the
care of a Mr. Brown, they met Carpenter just above his
house and killed him. They immediately proceeded to the
house, and made prisoners of a son of Mr. Carpenter, two
sons of Mr. Brown, (all small) and one woman—the others
belonging to the house were in the field at work. The
Indians then despoiled the house and taking off some
horses, commenced a precipitate retreat—fearing discovery
and pursuit.

When Carpenter was shot, the report of the gun was heard
by those at work in the field; and Brown carried the alarm
to Fort Young and Fort Dinwiddie. Captain Paul, commanding
the latter, immediately started with twenty men in
pursuit. On Indian creek they met Pitman almost exhausted.
The pursuit was kept up, but the savages escaped.

As Captain Paul and his men were returning, they accidentally
met with the other party of Indians, who had been
to Catawba, and committed some depredations and murders
there. They were discovered about midnight, encamped on
the north bank of New river, opposite an island at the mouth
of Indian creek. Excepting some few who were watching


220

Page 220
three prisoners, (whom they had taken on Catawba, and who
were sitting in the midst of them,) they were lying around a
small fire, wrapped in skins and blankets. Paul's men not
knowing that there were captives among them, fired in the
midst, killed three Indians, and wounded several others, one
of whom drowned himself to preserve his scalp—the rest of
the party fled hastily down the river and escaped.

Several captives were released, and considerable plunder
recovered. To show the deadening effect of these terrible
scenes upon the human mind, we will copy the reply of a
prisoner rescued at this time. She was a Mrs. Gunn, an
English woman, and had known Captain Paul years before.
Recognizing his voice, she called him by name, just as one of
his men, who supposed her to be a squaw, was in the act of
tomahawking her. She made no resistance, and when asked the
reason replied, "I had as soon be killed as not—my husband
is murdered—my children are slain—my parents are dead. I
have not a relation in America—everything dear to me here
is gone—I have no wishes—no hopes—no fears—I would not
have risen to my feet to save my life."

Such were some of the horrors experienced on the frontier
in the early settlement of the country. The above facts we
derive chiefly from Withers.

 
[5]

The family consisted of Bingaman, his wife, child, and parents, who slept
down stairs, and a hired man who slept above.

[6]

So called from its being first settled by an immigration from New Jersey.

1777.

This, the far-famed bloody-year, and the "year of the three
sevens," as the old pioneers were accustomed to call it, is full
of painful incidents to hundreds of families in North-Western
Virginia. It was, indeed, the most terrible year the early
settlers ever experienced. Dark, mysterious clouds of malignant
spirits hung upon the horizon, threatening every moment
to overwhelm and exterminate the half-protected pioneer
in his wilderness home. At length the storm broke over
them, and scarcely a settlement in the great Valley of the


221

Page 221
West that did not experience its fatal and terrible effect. The
fury of the savages during this year seemed to have no bounds.
The wretched inhabitants were massacred with every conceivable
cruelty. Men, women, and children were chosen objects
of their revenge, and scarcely a settlement west of the Alleghanies
that escaped their visits and their fury. The alarm
became great, and terror seemed to seize upon the entire
population. Block-houses were hastily thrown up, and many
who could, moved their families to Red-stone, and other points
on the Monongahela; but still, there were hundreds left to
endure all the anticipated horrors of an Indian invasion.

The Indians separated into what were termed "scalping
parties," and penetrated the country at various points. One
of their first acts along the Monongahela was to visit the
house of a Mr. Grigsly, on West Fork, and carry off his wife
and two children. Mr. Grigsby was absent at the time; but
returning soon after, and missing his family, suspected the
true cause, although no injury had been done to either the
house or furniture. Securing the services of some of his
neighbors, pursuit was immediately given. Keeping the trail
about six miles, the horror-stricken husband came suddenly
upon the ghastly forms of his murdered wife and child. The
savages, finding Mrs. Grigsby unable to travel on account
of her delicate situation, most inhumanly tomahawked her,
together with her youngest child.

The almost frantic husband and parent, burning for revenge,
rushed on with a few select men, but the savages
suspecting a pursuit, divided into small parties, and so
effectually covered their trail, that all efforts to trace them
were unsuccessful, and the pursuit had to be given up.

This was but the commencement of such scenes of blood
along the Monongahela. A short time after this occurrence,
a Miss Coons, whose father erected Coons' fort, went into the
field to turn some hemp which lay near the fort. While there
engaged, two young men, Thomas Cunningham and Enoch
James, approached, and after a short conversation, went on.
They had not gone far before the report of a gun was heard,


222

Page 222
and on looking round saw two Indians standing near Miss
Coons, one of whom was in the act of scalping his unfortunate
victim. Pursuit was immediately given, but the savages
eluded every effort to trace them. One of the young men
fired at the retreating murderer, but without success.

Western Pennsylvania suffered in common this year with
Western Virginia. Scalping parties overran the settlements
along the lower Monongahela and its tributaries. The
settlements within the region now embraced in Washington,
Alleghany, and Westmoreland counties suffered
severely. As it was known that the Indians who committed
these depredations crossed the Alleghany river, it was determined
to erect a fort at some convenient point on that stream,
supposing that the presence of a small garrison would have
the effect to check the movements of the enemy in that quarter.
Accordingly, Colonel William Crawford, whose melancholy
fate a few years later thrilled the whole country with
horror, visited the Alleghany for the purpose of selecting a
proper location for the proposed fort. He decided to place it
near the mouth of Puckety creek, about seventeen miles above
Fort Pitt. The fort was immediately built, and called Crawford,
in honor of its projector. Several others were erected
about this time along the Loyalhanna, Kiskeminitas, Cheat,
Ten-mile, Pidgeon creek, &c. &c. The effect of the erection
of this fort may have been to force the Indians lower down,
and such was doubtless the fact. Large parties of them
found their way into Virginia at points below, and their
operations in this quarter were more extensive, particularly
in the neighborhood of Wheeling, (which we shall presently
notice) than was ever before undertaken. The whole combined
force of the western confederated tribes seemed directed against
this particular section.

Early in April, a man named Rodger McBride, was killed
and scalped, about ten miles up Wheeling creek, which caused
considerable excitement, and induced Colonel Morgan, United



No Page Number


No Page Number
illustration

FORT HENRY—WHEELING—1777.


223

Page 223
States Indian Agent for the middle department, to communicate
the fact by letter to Colonel Crawford, under date April
10. About the same time, another murder was committed
near where Bridgeport now stands, (opposite Wheeling).

SIEGE OF FORT HENRY.[7]

The fall of 1777, so memorable in the annals of the West,
was remarkable for nothing more than the united and determined
attack, by the combined arms of British and Indians,
against the stockade at Wheeling, Virginia.

The eloquent Chatham was never more right, than when
he denounced the alliance between Britain and the American
savages as a "disgrace,—a deep and deadly sin." That
act, connected as it was with the execrable scalp bounty, will
stand a living stigma upon her name and history as long as
time lasts.

Early in the month of August, fears began to be felt by
the settlers, as flying reports occasionally reached them, that
the Indians were gathering in great numbers, and it seemed
certain they meditated an attack during the approaching
autumn. Every precaution was taken to guard against an
insidious attack. Scouting parties were kept out, who, with
the sleepless vigilance of well trained spies, watched all the
movements of the enemy. Information had been conveyed
to General Hand, commanding at Fort Pitt, by some friendly
Moravian Indians, who received it from Isaac Zane, brother
of Colonel Ebenezer Zane,[8] that a large army of Indians,
composed chiefly of warriors from the great North-Western
confederacy, were making vigorous preparations to strike an
effective and terrible blow upon some of the settlements on
the Ohio. It was further stated, that this chosen body of


224

Page 224
savages would be under the command of Simon Girty, a man
whose known relentless ferocity toward his foresworn countrymen,
could not but add to the fearful prospect before them.

General Hand lost no time in widely disseminating the
information thus obtained.

As it was uncertain where the expected blow would fall, all
was activity, fear and alarm at the several little half-finished
fortresses stretching at distances from one to two hundred
miles, between Fort Pitt and the Great Kanawha. But it
soon became manifest at what point the enemy designed to
strike. With apprehensions of dread, the settlers at the
mouth of Wheeling, (numbering about thirty families,) betook
themselves to their fort, and with calm resolution awaited the
issue.

Early in the evening of the 31st of August, Capt. Joseph
Ogle, who had been sent out some days before, at the head of
ten or fifteen men, to scout along the different routes usually
followed by the Indians, returned to Wheeling, and reported
no immediate cause of danger.

The Indians, with their accustomed sagacity, suspecting
that their movements might be watched, abandoned all the
paths usually trodden, and dividing as they approached the
river, into small distinct parties, struck out along new lines
for the Ohio. Without discovery, they reached the vicinity
of Bogg's island, (two miles below Wheeling creek,) and there
consolidating their force, crossed the river and proceeded
directly to the creek bottom, under cover of night, and completed
their plans for movement in the morning.

The Indian army consisted of over three hundred and fifty
Mingoes, Shawanese and Wyandotts. It was commanded by
the notorious renegade, Simon Girty, and well furnished with
arms, ammunition, &c., by the infamous Hamilton, governor of
Canada. Girty disposed of his men in two lines across the
bottom,[9] stretching from the river to the creek. They were


225

Page 225
arranged at convenient distances, and effectually concealed
by the high weeds and corn.

Posted near the centre of these lines, and close to a path
leading from the fort (which they supposed some of the whites
would pass along in the morning,) were six Indians.

Shortly after day-break of the 1st of September, (see note
B., end Chap. I.,) Dr. McMechen, who was about returning
east of the mountains, sent out a white man named Boyd, and
a negro, to catch the horses. The two men had not proceeded
far before they discovered the six Indians already referred to.
Hoping to escape, they made a hurried retreat, but Boyd was
killed. The negro was permitted to return, doubtless to
mislead the whites as to the actual number of the foe.

The commandant immediately ordered Captain Samuel
Mason, who had brought his company to the fort on the previous
evening, to go out and dislodge the enemy. With
fourteen of his men, the gallant Captain at once sallied forth,
and after proceeding partly across the bottom, discovered the
six Indians and fired upon them. Almost simultaneously
with this discharge, the entire Indian army arose, and with
horrid yells rushed upon the little band of whites. Finding
that to stand were madness, Mason ordered a retreat, and in
person commenced cutting his way through the Indian line.
This he succeeded in doing, but most of his gallant little
party perished in the attempt. Out of the fourteen, but two
escaped, and they, like Captain Mason, eluded the pursuing
savages by concealing themselves beneath brush and fallen
timber. The names of those who escaped this general slaughter,
were Hugh McConnell and Thomas Glenn. William Shepherd,
son of Colonel David Shepherd, had gained the spring
near where the market-house now stands, when one of his
feet caught in a vine, and falling, the pursuing savage was
instantly upon him, and with a war club dispatched him on
the spot.

So soon as the disaster to Mason had been ascertained at the


226

Page 226
fort,[10] Captain Joseph Ogle, with his dozen experienced scouts,
advanced to his relief, but not without forebodings of imminent
danger, as the yells of the savages, and shrieks of the
whites, told too plainly that a terrible massacre was taking
place.

With fearless steps Captain Ogle moved on to the scene of
conflict, determined to cover the retreat of his unfortunate
countrymen, or perish in the attempt. An excited and bloody
foe rushed upon them with the fury of demons, and all but
two or three shared the fate of the first detachment.

Captain Ogle,[11] Sergeant Jacob Ogle, Martin Wetzel, and
perhaps one other, were all who escaped.

The loss of so many brave men at such a time, was a sad
blow to this part of the country. Those who fell were the
pride of that little fortress. They were heroes in every sense
of the word;—men of iron nerve, indomitable courage and
devoted patriotism. The valor of either would have done
honor to the victors of Marathon. Scarcely had the shrieks
of the wounded and dying been quieted, than the army of
savages, with reeking scalps just torn from the heads of the
ill-fated soldiery, presented themselves in front of the fort,
and demanded a surrender.

The appearance of the enemy, as they approached, was


227

Page 227
most formidable. They advanced in two separate columns,
with drum, fife, and British colors.

The morning was calm, warm, and bright, and the sun just
rising over the high hill which overlooked the fort, was gently
dissipating the heavy fog which covered the bloody scene on
the bottom.

As the Indians advanced, a few scattering shots were fired
at them from the fort, without, however, doing much execution.
Girty, having brought up his forces, proceeded to dispose
of them as follows. The right flank, was brought around
the base of the hill, and distributed among the several cabins
convenient to the fort. The left were ordered to defile beneath
the river bank, close under the fort.

Thus disposed, Girty presented himself at the window of a
cabin, holding forth a white flag, and offering conditions of
peace. He read the proclamation of Hamilton, Governor of
Canada, and in a stentorian voice demanded the surrender of
the fort, offering, in case they complied, protection; but if
they refused, immediate and indiscriminate massacre.

Girty referred, in a very boasting manner, to the great
force at his command; and called upon them, as loyal subjects,
to give up in obedience to the demand of the king's
agent, and that not one of them should be injured.

Although the whole number of men then in the fort did
not exceed ten or a dozen, still there was no disposition to
yield; but, on the contrary, a fixed determination to defy the
renegade, and all the power of King George.

Girty having finished his harangue, Colonel David Shepherd,
the commandant, promptly and in the most gallant and
effective manner, replied, "Sir, we have consulted our wives
and children, and all have resolved—men, women, and children,
sooner to perish at their posts than place themselves
under the protection of a savage army with you at the head;
or abjure the cause of liberty and the colonies." The outlaw
attempted to reply, but a shot from the fort put a stop to any
further harangue.


228

Page 228

A darker hour had scarcely ever obscured the hopes of the
west. Death was all around that little fortress, and hopeless
despair seemed to press upon its inmates; but still they could
not and would not give up. Duty, patriotism, pride, independence,
safety, all required they should not surrender, and
forswear the cause of freedom.

Unable to intimidate them, and finding the besieged proof
against his vile promises, the chagrined and discomfited
Girty disappeared from the cabin, but in a few minutes was
seen approaching with a large body of Indians, and instantly
a tremendous rush was made upon the fort. They attempted
to force the gates, and test the strength of the pickets by
muscular effort. Failing to make any impression, Girty
drew off his men a few yards, and commenced a general fire
upon the port-holes.

Thus continued the attack during most of the day and part
of the night, but without any sensible effect. About noon,
a temporary withdrawal of the enemy took place. During
the cessation, active preparations were carried on within the
fort to resist a further attack. Each person was assigned
some particular duty. Of the women, some were required to
run bullets, while others were to cool the guns, load and hand
them to the men, &c. Some of them, indeed, insisted upon
doing duty by the side of the men, and two actually took
their position at the port-holes, dealing death to many a
dusky warrior.

About three o'clock, the Indians returned to the attack
with redoubled fury. They distributed themselves among
the cabins, behind fallen trees, &c. The number thus disposed
of, amounted to perhaps one-half the actual force of
the enemy. The remainder advanced along the base of the
hill south of the fort, and commenced a vigorous fire upon
that part of the stockade. This was a cunningly devised
scheme, as it drew most of the inmates to that quarter. Immediately
a rush was made from the cabins, lead on by Girty
in person, and a most determined effort made to force the


229

Page 229
entrance. The attempt was made with heavy timber, but
failed, with the loss of many of their boldest warriors.

Several similar attempts were made during the afternoon,
but all alike failed. Maddened and chagrined by repeated
disappointment and ill-success, the savages withdrew to their
covert until night-fall.[12] Day at length closed; darkness
deepened over the waters, and almost the stillness of death
reigned around. About nine o'clock, the savages re-appeared,
making night hideous with their yells, and the heavens lurid
with their discharge of musketry.

The lights in the fort having been extinguished, the inmates
had the advantage of those without, and many a stalwart
savage fell before the steady aim of experienced frontiermen.

Repeated attempts were made during the night to storm
the fort, and to fire it, but all failed through the vigilance and
activity of those within.

At length that night of horror passed, and day dawned
upon the scene, but to bring a renewal of the attack. This,
however, did not last long, and despairing of success, the
savages prepared to leave. They fired most of the buildings,
killed the cattle, and were about departing, when a relief
party of fourteen men, under Colonel Andrew Swearengen,
from Holliday's fort, twenty-four miles above, landed in a
pirogue, and undiscovered by the Indians, gained entrance to
the fort.

Shortly afterwards, Major Samuel McColloch, at the head
of forty mounted men, from Short creek, made their appearance


230

Page 230
in front of the fort, the gates of which were joyfully
thrown open. Simultaneously with the appearance of
McColloch's men, re-appeared the enemy, and a rush was
made to cut off the entrance of some of the party. All,
however, succeeded in getting in except the gallant Major,
who, anxious for the safety of his men, held back until his
own chance was entirely cut off. Finding himself surrounded
by savages, he rode at full speed in direction of the hill.

The enemy, with exulting yells, followed close in pursuit,
not doubting they would capture one whom of all other men
they preferred to wreak their vengeance upon. (For a full
account of the sequel, the reader is referred to the biographical
sketch of Major McColloch, to be found in its appropriate
place in this volume.) Greatly disappointed at the escape of
the gallant Major, and knowing the hopelessness of attempting
to maintain a siege against such increased numbers, the
Indians fired a few additional shot at the fort, and then
moved rapidly off in a body for their own country.

It has been conjectured that the enemy lost on this occasion
from forty to fifty in killed and wounded. The loss of the
whites has been already stated. Not a single person was
killed within the fort, and but one slightly wounded.

 
[7]

See Note A. end of Chap. I.

[8]

Am. State Papers, xvi. 93-121.

[9]

The bottom at that time was cleared, and mostly in corn.

[10]

Those at the fort could not see the effect of the conflict, or the number
of the enemy, on account of the dense fog which hung over the bottom.
This will explain why so small a party as Ogle's should venture against so
large a body of Indians.

[11]

An incident was related by Captain Ogle, which it may not be uninteresting
to give. In making good his escape, Captain Ogle at one time secreted himself
amidst a cluster of tall weeds, in the corner of a fence. Whilst there
concealed, two plumed warriors seated themselves on the fence above him.
One of these seemed severely wounded, and cried piteously with pain.
Captain Ogle saw the blood run in streams down his leg.

Fearing discovery, Captain Ogle kept his finger on the trigger of his rifle,
so that he could fire the moment he should be discovered. The Indians soon
moved off.

[12]

Just before the withdrawal of the enemy, Francis Duke, son-in-law of
Colonel Shepherd, rode up to the fort and had almost gained the gate, when
an Indian shot him. His death was greatly regretted, as he was a brave
and generous man, and of much service on the frontier. He had been stationed
at Beach bottom Block-house, as Assistant Commissary, and getting
information of the attack, mounted his horse, and rode with all speed to the
scene of operation, there, alas, to meet an untimely death.

His remains, with those of his brother-in-law, William Shepherd, were interred
near where the North-Western Bank now stands.

DEPLORABLE AMBUSCADE.

By far the most disastrous ambuscade in the settlement of
the west, was that at the head of Grave creek narrows, now
Marshall county, Virginia, September 27th, 1777.

Captain William Foreman, a brave and meritorious officer,
organized a volunteer company in Hampshire county, Virginia,
and marched to Wheeling in the fall of 1777. It was known
that Patrick Henry, Governor of Virginia, had determined
early in the spring of that year, to send an expedition against
the Indian towns at the head of the Scioto, and with this


231

Page 231
view ordered three hundred men to be raised in the counties
of Youghioghany, Monongalia and Ohio. Some of the most
patriotic of the citizens east of the mountains, thinking the
west in this emergency might stand in need of aid, determined
to go to her assistance. Of this number was Capt.
Foreman, who soon raised a company, and by the middle of
September was at Wheeling. A gallant soldier, but wholly
unfamiliar with Indian warfare, he proved himself unfit for
the service, and in his very first expedition suffered the
deplorable ambuscade an account of which we will now give.

After the withdrawal of the Indians from Wheeling,
nothing more was seen of them, or heard of their movements
up to the time of which we now speak; and the impression
became general that they had retired to their towns.

On Sunday morning, September 26th, (1777,) a smoke was
noticed by some persons at Wheeling, in the direction of
Grave creek, which caused an apprehension that the Indians
might be burning the stockade and houses of Mr. Tomlinson.
In order to ascertain this fact, and afford protection if any
were necessary, Captain Foreman, with his company, and a
few experienced scouts, were despatched by Colonel Shepherd
for the purpose.

The party proceeded without interruption to Grave creek,
and found all safe. Remaining over night, they started early
on the following morning to return. When they had reached
the lower end of Grave creek narrows, some of the more
experienced frontiermen suggested the expediency of leaving
the river bottom, and returning by way of the ridge. The
commander, however, hooted at the idea of so much caution,
and ordered the party to proceed. The order was obeyed by
his own men, including several of the volunteer scouts; but
some declined to go with him, and of these was a man named
Lynn, whose great experience as a spy, added to his sagacity
and judgment, should at least have rendered his opinions
valuable, and entitled to weight. His apprehensions were,
that the Indians, if lurking about, had watched the movements


232

Page 232
of the party, and would most likely attack them at
some point on the river. He said, that in all probability,
they had been on the opposite side of the river and noticed
the party go down; that they had crossed during the night
and most probably were at that time lying in ambush for their
return. How fearfully were his apprehensions realized.

During the interchange of opinions between Foreman and
Lynn, a man named Robert Harkness, a relative of Mr.
Tomlinson, sat on a log near the parties, and often said that
the controversy at times ran high. Foreman, who prided
himself on being a thoroughly disciplined officer, was not
disposed to yield to the suggestions of a rough backwoodman.
Lynn, on the other hand, convinced of the fatal error which
the other seemed determined to commit, could not but remonstrate
with all the power of persuasion at his command.
Finally, when the order to march was given, Lynn with some
six or eight others struck up the hill side, while Foreman with
his company pursued the path along the base.

Nothing of importance occurred until the party reached
the extreme upper end of the narrows. Just where the
bottom begins to widen, those in front had their attention
drawn to a display of Indian trinkets, beads, bands, &c.,
strewn in profusion along the path. With a natural curiosity,
but a great lack of perception, the entire party gathered
about those who picked up the articles of decoy, and whilst
thus standing in a compact group, looking at the beads, &c.,
two lines of Indians stretched across the path, one above, the
other below, and a large body of them simultaneously arose
from beneath the bank, and opened upon the devoted party a
most deadly and destructive fire. The river hill rises at this
point with great boldness, presenting an almost insurmountable
barrier. Still, those of the party who escaped the first discharge,
attempted to rush up the acclivity, and some with
success. But the savages pursued and killed several.

At the first fire, Captain Foreman and most of his
party, including his two sons, fell dead. The exact loss


233

Page 233
cannot with certainty be ascertained, but is supposed to have
been about twenty, including the Captain. We give, (Note
C., end Chap. I.,) a list of losses, &c., sustained by members
of Captain Foreman's company, but there is nothing to indicate
who were killed. The presumption is, however, that most
of those whose names are mentioned suffered on the occasion
referred to.

When Lynn and his party heard the guns, they rushed
down the side of the hill, hallooing as though they were five
times as numerous. This had the effect of restraining the
savages in pursuit, and perhaps saved the lives of many.

Of those who escaped up the hill were Robert Harkness and
John Collins. The former, in pulling himself up by a sapling,
had the bark knocked into his face with a ball from an Indian's
gun. Collins was shot through the left thigh, breaking the
bone, and completely disabling him. Lynn and his companions
carried him to a spring said to have been just over
the hill, and throwing together their supply of provisions, left
him in a sheltered position, promising to send a messenger
on the following day with a horse.

Those who were so fortunate as to escape this terrible affair,
made their way in safety to Wheeling.

On the second day, a party went down and buried the dead.
Col. Shepherd, Col. Zane, Andrew Poe, and Martin Wetzel
were of this number. They were thrown into one common
grave, and the place of their interment is still pointed out to
the passer-by.[13]

Collins, the wounded man, was taken off on horseback, the
second night. They carried him to Shepherd's Fort, and the
present Mrs. Cruger remembers to have seen him when


234

Page 234
brought in. He suffered greatly with his wounded limb in
riding; but finally recovered, and lived for many years.

The number of Indians engaged in this affair was never
known. Some supposed it was the same body that attacked
the fort at Wheeling, three weeks previous; but this is all
conjecture.

About the last of September, two men (Leonard Petro and
William White), who were watching a path that led up the
Little Kanawha, killed an elk, and after a hearty supper laid
down to sleep. "About midnight, White awakening, discovered
by the light of the moon, that there were several Indians near,
who had doubtless been drawn by the report of their gun in the
evening. He saw at a glance, the impossibility of escape, by
flight; and preferring captivity to death, he whispered to
Petro to lie still, lest any movement of his might lead to this
result. In a few minutes the Indians sprang on them; and
White raising himself as one lay hold of him, aimed a furious
blow, with his tomahawk, hoping to wound the Indian by
whom he was beset, and then make his escape. Missing his
aim, he affected to be ignorant of the fact, that he had
encountered Indians; professed great joy at meeting with
them, and declared that he was then on his way to their
towns. They were not deceived by the artifice; for although
he assumed an air of pleasantness and gaiety, calculated to
win upon their confidence, yet the woful countenance of Petro,

1 In 1835, a few gentlemen, chiefly members, we believe, of a Light-horse
company, raised a small fund, and had placed near the spot of their interment,
a plain stone, bearing in simple, but expressive language, this inscription,
"This humble stone is erected to the memory of Captain Foreman, and
twenty-one of his men, who were slain by a band of ruthless savages,—the
allies of a civilized nation of Europe—on the 26th of September, 1777.

`So sleep the brave, who sink to rest,
By all their country's wishes blest.' "

235

Page 235

convinced them that White's conduct was feigned, that he
might lull them into inattention, and thus be enabled to escape.
They were both tied for the night; and in the morning, White
being painted red, and Petro black, they were forced to proceed
to the Indian towns. When approaching their village,
the whoop of success brought several to meet them; and on
their arrival at it, they found every preparation made for
running the gauntlet. White did not, however, remain long
in captivity. Eluding their vigilance, he took one of their
guns and began his flight homeward. Before he had travelled
far, he met an Indian on horseback, whom he succeeded in
shooting; and mounting his horse, made his way home.
Petro was never heard of afterwards. The painting of him
black, had indicated their intention to kill him; and the
escape of White probably hastened it."

The inhabitants of the Upper Monongahela continued to
observe their usual vigilance until toward the close of November,
when a fall of snow occurring, they relaxed somewhat their
watchfulness. As a general thing, the Indians withdrew from
the settlements on the commencement of winter, and did not
reappear until the coming spring. Instances were very rare,
in which they disturbed the settlements during winter. The
readiness by which they could be tracked, together with the
severity of the weather, compelled them to such a course.

The snow to which we have referred, lulled the inhabitants
into false security. About twenty Indians had penetrated
the settlement in Tygart Valley, and were waiting to make
an attack when the snow fell. Not liking to return without
some trophy of their valor, the savages concealed themselves
until the snow disappeared. On the 15th day of December
they came to the house of Darby Connoly, at the upper extremity
of the Valley, and killed his wife, himself, and several
of their children, taking three others prisoners. Proceeding


236

Page 236
to the next house, they killed John Stewart, wife and child,
and took Miss Hamilton (sister of Mrs. Stewart) captive.
Then changing their direction, with great dispatch, they
entered upon their journey homeward, with the captives and
plunder.

In the course of the evening, after these outrages were
committed, John Hadden passing by the house of Connoly,
saw an elk which the family raised, lying dead in the yard,
and suspecting that all was not right, entered the house, and
with horror saw what had been done. Knowing that the
work of blood had been recently committed, he hastened to
alarm the neighborhood, and sent an express to Captain
Benjamin Wilson, who lived about twenty miles down the
Valley. With great promptitude, Capt. Wilson went through
the settlement, exerting himself to procure as many volunteers,
as would justify going in pursuit of the murderers; and so
indefatigable was he in accomplishing this purpose, that, on
the day after, he appeared with thirty men, prepared to take
the trail, and push forward in pursuit of the savages. For
five days they followed through cold and wet, often wading
and swimming streams, and then traveling many miles before
the icicles could be thawed off. Still there was no appearance
of the enemy; and at length, the men positively refusing
to go farther, the party returned from its fruitless chase, and
the savages escaped with their prisoners and booty.

These were perhaps, the last murders committed in North-Western
Virginia, during this fatal and bloody year.

 
[13]

This spring is supposed to be the one near the present residence of Col.
Samuel P. Baker. The author, in company with Col. Baker, examined the
locality, particularly in reference to this spring, and the conclusion arrived
at, was as indicated above. It answers very well the description given of it
by the old settlers.

DEATH OF GRANDSTAFF.

Of those who followed the Wetzels, Bonnetts, Messers and
others, to the west and settled on Wheeling creek, was a man
named Grandstaff. He improved the farm now owned by Mr.
Buchanan, about three miles above the forks.


237

Page 237

On the renewal of Indian hostilities, Grandstaff removed
his family to Shepherd's fort. He was in the habit, however,
of visiting his improvements almost daily, but returning to
the fort in the evening.

In March of this year, Mr. G. went up to his farm, when
a party of Indians, who had been lying in wait, shot and
scalped him.

1778.

Early in the commencement of this year, it became manifest
that the confederated tribes were preparing to renew their
attack upon the frontier settlements of the west. On the 8th
of February, Gov. Schuyler wrote to Congress,—"There is
too much reason to believe that an expedition will be formed
against the western frontiers of this state, Virginia and
Pennsylvania." The apprehensions of Gen. Schuyler were
too well founded. It was in this year the terrible drama of
Wyoming took place. Of the savage operations in this section,
we shall now proceed to notice. The success of the enemy
in the fall previous, seemed to madden them for blood, and at
a very early day they moved upon the frontier, spreading
alarm and death in almost every direction. The erection of
Fort Crawford on the Alleghany, and the contemplated military
operations of Gen. McIntosh on the Ohio, had the effect
of restraining the movements of the savages in each of these
directions, and forcing them to cross at points farther down.
Their failure to take Fort Henry in the previous September,
and thinking perhaps that the garrison had been strengthened,
they struck the frontier at points below and thence proceeded
against the settlements on the Monongahela. At that time,
the entire frontier from Wheeling to Point Pleasant (one hundred
and seventy miles) was unprotected, if we except the
small and wholly inefficient stations at Grave creek, Baker's,
etc. These offered no impediment to the progress of the


238

Page 238
enemy, and unmolested they struck back to the heart of the
mountain settlements.

The inhabitants of the upper Monongahela, not unmindful
of the indications which had reached them, commenced busily
preparing for the anticipated attack. Harbert's block-house
on Ten-mile, was a safe and convenient resort, and thither
those living in that quarter took shelter. Notwithstanding
these prudential steps, they unhappily suffered themselves to
be lulled into false security. The weather being fine, the
children were allowed to play outside of the block-house.
Suddenly, one of them discovered Indians, and, running in,
gave the alarm. "John Murphy stepped to the door to see
if danger had really approached, when one of the Indians,
turning the corner of the house, fired at him. The ball took
effect, and Murphy fell into the house. The Indian springing
in, was grappled by Harbert, and thrown on the floor. A
shot from without, wounded Harbert, yet he continued to
maintain his advantage over the prostrate savage, striking
him effectually as he could with his tomahawk, when another
gun was fired from without, the ball passing through his
head. His antagonist then slipped out at the door, badly
wounded in the encounter.

"Just after the first Indian entered, an active young warrior,
holding a tomahawk with a long spike at the end, came
in. Edward Cunningham instantly drew up his gun, but it
flashed, and they closed in doubtful strife. Both were active
and athletic; and sensible of the high prize for which they
contended, each put forth his strength, and strained every
nerve to gain the ascendancy. For awhile, the issue seemed
doubtful. At length, by great exertion, Cunningham wrenched
the tomahawk from the hand of the Indian, and buried the
spike end to the handle, in his back. Mrs. Cunningham closed
the contest. Seeing her husband struggling with the savage,
she struck at him with an axe. The edge wounding his face
severely, he loosened his hold, and made his way out of the
house.


239

Page 239

"The third Indian, who had entered before the door was
closed, presented an appearance almost as frightful as the
object he had in view. He wore a cap made of the unshorn
front of a buffalo, with the ears and horns still attached, and
hanging loosely about his head, gave a most hideous appearance,
and on entering the room, this frightful monster, aimed a
blow with his tomahawk at Miss Reece, which alighting on her
head, inflicted a severe wound. The mother, seeing the uplifted
weapon about to descend on her daughter, seized the monster
by the horns; but his false head coming off, she did not succeed
in changing the direction of the weapon. The father
then caught hold of him; but far inferior in strength, he was
thrown on the floor, and would have been killed, but for the
interference of Cunningham, who, having succeeded in clearing
the house of one Indian, wheeled and struck his tomahawk
into the head of the other.

"During all this time the door was kept secured by the
women. The Indians from without endeavored several times to
force it and would at one time have succeeded; but just as it
was yielding, the Indian, who had been wounded by Cunningham
and his wife, squeezed out, causing a momentary relaxation
of their efforts, and enabled the women again to close it."

The savages on the outside, in the meantime, were busily
engaged in securing such of the children as could travel, and
murdering in the most inhuman and revolting manner all who
could not. Despairing of being able to do further mischief,
they moved off.

One white adult only was killed, and four or five wounded.
Of the children, eight or ten were killed and carried off. The
Indians lost one killed, and had two badly wounded.

Many other depredations of a similar character occurred
in that part of Virginia, during the spring of the present
year. Our crowded limits will not allow us to give them in
detail. We will notice a few as we find them chronicled by
the local historian.


240

Page 240

"On the eleventh of April, some Indians visited the house of
William Morgan, on Dunker's bottom. They there killed a
young man by the name of Brain, Mrs. Morgan, (the mother
of William) and her grand-daughter, and Mrs. Dillon and her
two children; and took Mrs. Morgan (the wife) and her child
prisoners. When on their way home, coming near Pricket's
fort, they bound Mrs. Morgan to a bush, and went in quest of
a horse to have her ride, leaving the child with her. She
succeeded in untying with her teeth, the bands which confined
her, and wandered the balance of that day and part of the
next, before she came in sight of the fort. Here she was
kindly treated, and in a few days sent home.

Toward the latter part of the same month, a party of about
twenty Indians visited Hacker's creek settlement. The families
were generally fortified; but as it was necessary to put in
a crop, the men while thus employed carried their rifles with
them, and often went in bodies, so as to afford better security
against surprise or attack from the Indians.

A company of men, thus engaged about the last week in
May, on Hacker's creek, and being a good deal dispersed
in various occupations, some fencing, others clearing, and a
few ploughing, they were unexpectedly fired upon, and Thos.
Hughes and Jonathan Lowther shot down: the others being
incautiously without arms, fled for safety. Two of the company,
having the Indians rather between them and West's fort,
ran directly to Richards',[14] as well for their own security as to
give the alarm. They had already been apprized that the
enemy were at hand. Isaac Washburn, who had been to mill
on Hacker's creek, on his return and near where Clement's
now stands, was shot from his horse, tomahawked and scalped.
The alarm of this murder had been given before the men
arrived. The Indians escaped without pursuit.

Early in June, a few Indians made their appearance in the
neighborhood of Fort Randolph (Point Pleasant), and after


241

Page 241
vainly manœuvring to draw out an attacking party from the
garrison, disappeared, when suddenly a large body of savages
arose from their covert and demanded a surrender of the fort,
on pain of instant destruction.

Captain McKee, the commandant, asked until morning for
consideration. During the night, the besieged made good use
of the darkness by carrying water into the fort, and putting
all things in readiness for a regular siege.

In the morning, Captain McKee replied, that the demand
for a surrender could not be complied with. The Indians
(they were mostly Shawanese) then said, they had come expressly
for the purpose of avenging the death of their great
chief, Cornstalk; that the fort should be reduced, and every
soul massacred. The attack was commenced with great fury,
and continued, with but little intermission, for several days.
Finding they could make no sensible impression, the enemy
withdrew and proceeded up the Kanawha, evidently with the
intention of attacking the Greenbriar settlements. No recent
demonstration of hostility having been made in that quarter,
Captain McKee justly became alarmed for the issue, unless
information of their approach could be conveyed to the settlements.
Two soldiers were immediately sent in pursuit,
but being discovered, were fired upon, and they returned to
the fort. Two others then volunteered, Philip Hammon and
John Pryor. An Indian squaw present, decorated them in
true savage style, so that the native warriors could scarcely
have told them from genuine Shawanese. Thus equipped,
the intrepid hunters left Fort Randolph, and over hill and
dale they sped onward, until finally they reached the settlements.
The people were alarmed, and ere night closed in
the whole neighborhood were collected at the residence of
Colonel Andrew Donally.[15] Everything was put in readiness
for an attack. Dr. Campbell, in his Narrative, says, a strict


242

Page 242
watch was kept through the night, but no enemy appeared.
The second day passed off in like manner. That night, most
of the men went to the second story, having slept none for
nearly forty-eight hours. In the latter part of the night they
became drowsy, and when daylight appeared, all were in a
profound sleep. Only three men were on the lower floor,—
Hammon, and the white and black servants of Colonel Donally.
At daybreak the white servant opened the door, that
he might bring in some firewood, and had gone but a few
steps from the house when he was shot down. The Indians
now sprang from their concealment on the edge of the rye-field
near the house, and rushing in a body, attempted to
enter the door. Hammon and the black servant Dick, made
an effort to secure it, but the Indians commenced chopping
with their tomahawks, and had actually cut through the door,
when Dick, fearing that they might succeed in gaining their
purpose, left Hammon at his post, and seizing a musket which
stood near, loaded with heavy slugs, discharged it through
the opening among the crowd. The Indians now fell back,
and the door was secured. Some of the savages crawled
under the floor, and were endeavoring to force their way up;
Hammon and Dick, with one or two men from the loft, who
had been aroused by the firing, quietly awaited the Indians
in their effort. Presently, one of them showing his head
through the opening, Hammon aimed a blow with his tomahawk,
which placed him beyond the power of doing further
injury. A second was killed in the same way, and the rest
escaped. In the meantime, all the men in the loft were up,
and pouring upon the enemy a most destructive fire, drove
them off under cover of the woods. The attack was kept up
during most of the day, but at such a distance as to do but
little harm. One man was killed by a ball passing through
an interstice in the wall. On the alarm being given by
Hammon and his companion, a messenger was sent to the
station at Lewisburg, (this messenger was John Pritchett, and
was killed on the morning of the attack). By the activity of
Colonel Samuel Lewis and Colonel John Stuart, a force of

243

Page 243
sixty-six armed men was ready to march on the third morning.
To avoid an ambush, they left the direct road, and
taking a circuitous route, arrived opposite the fort, turned
across, and passing through a rye-field, entered in safety.
Giving up all hope after the accession of so large a force,
the savages withdrew, and moved off in direction of the Ohio.
Seventeen of them were found dead in the yard.

About the middle of June, as Captain James Booth and
Nathaniel Cochran, were at work in a field on Booth's creek,
a party of Indians came upon them, and killing Booth, took
the other prisoner. Captain Booth was a brave and meritorious
citizen, and his loss was greatly regretted.

A few days subsequent to these transactions, William
Grundy,[16] Benjamin Shinn, and Benjamin Washburn, in returning
from a lick, were fired upon, and Grundy killed.
About the same time Thomas Ryan, brother of the boy
killed at the spring, during the meditated attack on Wheeling,
in 1781, was murdered on Short creek, on the farm
lately owned by R. Hardesty, Esq. Ryan was a man of
much energy of character, and had been useful in border
service. His death was greatly regretted.

His widow married Silas Zane, and was a second time
widowed by savage hands. Zane was killed while crossing
the Scioto, a few years after, in company with George Green
and one or two other men.

 
[14]

West's fort stood on Hacker's creek, and Richards' on the Monongahela.

[15]

This was a large, substantial, hewn log dwelling, protected by pickets,
and answered admirably for a place of defence. It stood about ten miles
north of the present town of Lewisburg.

[16]

Mr. G. was brother to Hon. Felix Grundy, of Tennessee.

DEATH OF MRS. FREEMAN.

Although the Indians disappeared for a brief period after
their attack upon the men at Hacker's, still they lingered
through the country, closely watching every opportunity to
commit mischief. Had the force been sufficient at any one


244

Page 244
post, to have gone in pursuit, the savages could have been
driven from the country; but, as it was, the settlers could
only remain at home and protect their women and children.
Notwithstanding the great danger there was known to be in
leaving the fort, still persons would occasionally venture out,
and unhappily, in many instances, at the sacrifice of their
lives. Such are the facts in the case we are now about to
give. Three women ventured forth from West's fort to
gather greens in an adjacent field. One of these was Mrs.
Freeman, another Mrs. Hacker, but the name of the third we
have not been able to ascertain. While thus busily engaged,
they were furiously attacked by four Indians, and all would
undoubtedly have been killed, had not their screams brought
the men to their rescue. Three of the savages immediately
retreated, but the fourth, who carried a long staff with a
spear on its end, ran up and thrust it through the body of
the unfortunate Mrs. Freeman. The savage then scalped his
victim before the men could drive him off.

Some persons at a distance from the fort, hearing the
screams, rushed forward. Of this number were Jesse Hughes
and John Schoolcraft, who ran for the fort together, and as
they approached, Hughes discovered two Indians standing
with their faces towards the fort, and looking very attentively
at the movements of the whites. Changing their course they
reached the fort in safety. Hughes immediately grasped
his rifle and bounded out in pursuit, followed by some half
dozen others. Before reaching the place where the two Indians
had been seen, a signal resembling the howl of a wolf was
heard, which Hughes immediately answered, and moved
rapidly on in the direction whence it proceeded. In a short
time, the howl was again given and a second time answered.
Running to the brow of a hill and cautiously looking around,
Hughes and his companions saw two Indians coming towards
them. Hughes instantly fired, and one of them fell. The
other sought safety in flight, and by running through the
thickets, finally escaped.


245

Page 245

In the fall of this year, a party of Indians came upon
the house of Gilbert Hustead, living on Bartlett's run, and
made him prisoner. Hearing a noise in the yard, Hustead
opened the door to ascertain the cause, and finding it
surrounded by Indians, put on an air of the utmost nonchalance,
and walking out, extended his hand, welcoming
them to his house and manifesting every degree of pleasure
on seeing them. The wild men, not accustomed to so much
deception, greeted their new found friend, and stepped in to
share his proffered hospitality. Hustead could not be too
kind and attentive; and finally, by handsomely abusing the
"rebels," as he called his neighbors, and showing them (the
Indians) every civility, won their favor and saved his scalp.
Inquiring whether they were hungry and would not be glad
to have something to eat, he asked one of them to shoot a
fat hog in the yard, that they might regale on it that night,
and have some on which to subsist whilst travelling to their
towns. In the morning, still further to maintain the deception,
he broke his furniture to pieces, saying "the rebels shall
never have the good of this." He then accompanied them to
their towns, acting in the same, apparently contented and
cheerful manner, till his sincerity was believed by all, and he
obtained leave to return for his family. He succeeded in
making his way home, where he remained, sore at the destruction
of his property, but exulting in the success of his
artifice.

At the time of the above occurrence, a much larger party
of Indians made their way to Coburn's creek, and attacked a
company of whites returning from a field in the neighborhood
of Coburn's fort. John Woodfin and Jacob Miller were both
killed and scalped.

They next made their appearance on Dunker creek, near
to Stradler's fort. Here, as on Coburn creek, they lay in
ambush on the road side, awaiting the return of the men who


246

Page 246
were engaged at work in some of the neighboring fields.
Towards evening the men came, carrying with them some
hogs which they had killed for the use of the fort people, and
on approaching where the Indians lay concealed, were fired
upon and several fell. Those who escaped injury from the first
fire, returned the shot, and a severe action ensued. But so
many of the whites had been killed before the savages exposed
themselves to view, that the remainder were unable
long to sustain the unequal contest. Overpowered by numbers,
the few who were still unhurt, fled precipitately to the
fort, leaving eighteen of their companions dead in the road.
These were scalped and mangled by the Indians in a most
shocking manner, and lay some time before the men in the
fort, assured of the departure of the enemy, went out and
buried them.

Weakened by the severe loss sustained in this bloody
skirmish, had the Indians pushed forward to attack the fort,
in all human probability, it would have fallen before them.[17]

One of the last murders committed in the Monongahela
country during this year, was that on the person of David
Edwards, a worthy and industrious settler. He had been to
Winchester for a supply of salt, and while on his return, near
Valley river, was shot, tomahawked and scalped. His remains
were not discovered for several days, and were so
mutilated by wild beasts that they were with difficulty recognized.

 
[17]

Withers.

1779.

The surrender to Clark of the British "hair-buyer," as
Hamilton was very appropriately called, put it out of that
functionary's power to purge the west of the "Long-knives,"
as he had so bravely threatened to do. It also had the effect
to restrain the activity of the savages on the Virginia frontier,


247

Page 247
especially as the trade in scalps had become dull since
the bounty patron had gone to Williamsburg, loaded with
irons. But the savages were not long quiet; they had injuries
of their own which they burned to avenge; and although
more prisoners were made and fewer scalps taken, than when
Hamilton was abroad, still their depredations were as great,
and the terror which their presence inspired just as all-pervading,
as during the previous years. In Virginia, they did
not appear by a month so early as usual, but when commenced
their operations were quite as extensive. Anticipating increased
danger, the settlers on Hacker's creek all removed
with their families to the neighboring forts, and placed themselves
in proper condition for meeting and resisting the
enemy in any number that might come. Several new forts
had, in the meantime, arisen; and therefore, when the campaign
fairly opened, the settlers were better prepared to
encounter their fierce adversaries than ever before. The
extreme frontier people had also been busy. Many new stockades
were erected, and the old ones repaired. Tomlinson's,
at Grave creek, which had been abandoned in 1777, was
re-fitted and occupied; Shepherd's, at the forks of Wheeling,
which the Indians had burned, was re-built, with many others
along the populated vallies in the neighborhood of Wheeling.

MORGAN'S RENCONTRE.

One of the most remarkable instances of personal heroism
in the history of the West, is that of the celebrated combat
between David Morgan and two Indians. Other instances,
exhibiting equal success with even greater disparity of numbers,
are upon record; but in none do we find more of true
courage, energy, and intrepidity, than in this unequal contest
between a man of advanced years and feeble health,
struggling with, and finally vanquishing both his powerful
adversaries. The settlements along the upper Monongahela,


248

Page 248
which had suffered so severely during the preceding fall, had
not as yet been disturbed by the enemy, and many imagined
that there was to be no repetition of them, at least during the
present season. They however, still remained shut up in
their block-houses, and rarely ventured far without appropriate
means of defence. Of those who removed with their
families to Prickett's fort,[18] was David Morgan, one of the
earliest settlers on the frontier, and a man of great energy of
character, and of sterling worth. He was a near relative of
General Morgan of Revolutionary memory, and like that distinguished
officer, possessed, in a remarkable degree, courage
and capacity for almost any emergency.

At the time of which we speak, Mr. Morgan was upwards
of sixty years of age, and for some days had been slightly
indisposed. Early in April, he desired two of his children,
Stephen,[19] sixteen years of age, and Sarah, about fourteen, to
feed the stock at his farm, distant about one mile, and on the
opposite side of the river. This he did, in consequence of
feeling worse that morning than usual. No Indians had yet
been seen in the neighborhood, and of course he considered
all perfectly safe.

As the weather was fine, the brother and sister concluded
to remain and prepare a piece of ground for melons. Soon
after they left the fort, Mr. Morgan lay down, and shortly
falling to sleep, dreamed that he saw the children walking
before him, scalped. This vision awoke him, and finding,
upon inquiry, that the children had not returned, he became
uneasy, and started immediately in hunt of them. Approaching
the premises, he beheld his children busily engaged in the
manner already indicated.

Seating himself upon a log close at hand, Morgan watched


249

Page 249
his children for some time, when suddenly he saw emerge
from the house two Indians, who moved rapidly up toward
Stephen and his sister. Fearing to alarm the children, Morgan
cautiously warned them of their danger, and told them
to go at once to the fort. They instantly obeyed, and the
Indians, discovering their movements, gave their accustomed
whoop, and started in pursuit. Morgan, having hitherto
escaped their attention, now arose, and returning their shout,
caused the savages to seek behind trees instant protection.

Knowing that the chances of a fair fight were almost hopeless,
Morgan thought to escape by running, and so manage as
to keep the trees between himself and the enemy. In this,
however, he was mistaken; impaired health, and the infirmities
of age disabled him from keeping long beyond the reach
of the fleet and athletic warriors. Finding, after a run of
some two hundred yards, that the savages were rapidly gaining
on him, he determined to shoot one, and take his chance
with the other. Turning to fire, both Indians sprung behind
trees, and Morgan did the same; but finding the one he first
gained too small to protect his person, he quitted it and made
for another, which was reached in safety.

One of the Indians, hoping to get nearer his intended victim,
ran to the tree which Morgan had left, but finding it too
small, threw himself behind a log close at hand. This, however,
did not conceal him entirely, which Morgan noticing,
instantly fired, and shot the savage through the part exposed.
Feeling himself mortally wounded, with more than Spartan
fortitude, he drew his knife, and inflicted two deep stabs upon
his breast. To him death had no fears, save as dealt by the
hand of his white antagonist.

The heroic old man, having thus effectually disposed of one
of his pursuers, again resorted to flight. The chances were
now desperate, as the Indian had the double advantage of
tomahawk and rifle. Running fifty or sixty yards, he glanced
hurriedly over his shoulder, just in time to see the savage
ready to fire. Jumping to one side, the ball passed harmlessly


250

Page 250
by, and the two now felt that the combat must be brought to
close quarters. With all the fury of his nature, the savage
rushed upon his adversary with loud yells and uplifted tomahawk.
Morgan prepared to meet him with his gun, but the
savage aimed a blow with his tomahawk, with such force and
effect as to knock the rifle from Morgan's grasp, and cut
two of the fingers from his left hand. They now clinched,
and the combat became equal, except the savage was the
younger and much more powerful of the two. Frantic at the
loss of his companion, and his own ill-success, he fought with
a desperation rarely known in single combat; Morgan, on
the other part, inspirited by the success which had thus far
attended him, nerved his arm, and strung every muscle to the
conflict, resolved to kill his combatant, or sell his own life as
dearly as possible. Our hero, in his younger days, had been
a most expert wrestler, and was thus enabled with ease to
throw the Indian; but the latter, more active and powerful,
readily turned him. With a yell of exultation, the savage
now held his adversary down, and began to feel for his knife.
Morgan saw the movement, and well knew all would be over
if the savage got possession of it.

The Indian was prevented getting the knife by a woman's
apron, which he had wrapped around his body in such a manner
as to confine the handle. Whilst endeavoring to extricate it,
Morgan got one of the Indian's thumbs between his teeth, and so
firmly did he hold it, and effectually grind it, that the poor wretch
was sadly disconcerted, and more than once screamed with
pain. Finally, he grasped his knife, but so close to the blade,
that Morgan noticing it, caught the end of the handle, and
drew it quickly through the Indian's hand, cutting it severely.
The savage was now literally hors de combat, and springing to
his feet, endeavored to get away; but the resolute Morgan, not
yet having done with him, held on to the thumb, until he had
inflicted a mortal thrust in the side of his enemy. Letting go,
the Indian sank almost lifeless to the ground, and Morgan
made his way to the fort. Before reaching the river, he overtook


251

Page 251
his children. After hearing his adventure, a party of
men left the fort, and proceeded to the place of conflict. On
reaching the spot, nothing was to be seen of the wounded
Indian; but his trail of blood indicated the place of his
concealment. The poor creature had taken the knife from
his side, bound up the wound with the apron already alluded
to, and as the whites approached him, he feelingly accosted
them, with "How do do, broder?" What followed, we would,
for the sake of our common humanity, fain screen; but, as the
facts have often been published, and the whole affair has
become matter of history, we can see no propriety in withholding
any part now.

"How do do, broder?" met with no fraternal response from
the party who discovered his retreat. He was immediately
dispatched; and not satisfied with that, himself and companion
were both scalped, and then flayed. Their skins were afterwards
tanned and made into shot-pouches, belts, razor-straps,
&c. Human nature revolts at the contemplation of such acts
of wanton barbarity. The impression has hitherto prevailed
that Morgan was one of this party. This, we are assured, is
not the fact. He was too much exhausted from loss of blood,
and the severe personal conflict, to go out with the men, and
of course could not have participated.

 
[18]

This stockade stood about twelve miles above Morgantown, and close to
the Monongahela river.

[19]

This was the father of Hon. Wm. S. Morgan, who formerly represented
the Wheeling district in Congress, and of Charles S. Morgan, Esq., of Richmond.
He died in November 1850, at the age of 90.

AFFAIR AT MARTIN'S FORT.

In June of this year, the humble structure known as Martin's
fort, which stood on Crooked run, was the scene of a
painful and bloody affair.

On the morning of the attack, most of the men went, as
usual, to their respective improvements in the neighborhood.
Those who remained, not apprehending an attack, were
leisurely engaged outside of the fort, while the women were
occupied in milking the cows. A party of Shawanese, who
had lain in wait, embraced the favorable opportunity, and


252

Page 252
rushing upon the whites, killed three men, and made prisoners
of seven others. Peter Croase, James Stuart, and James
Smalley were the men killed.

Soon after this occurrence, a small party of Indians appeared
on Pike run, a tributary to the Monongahela, below Brownsville,
and surprised two daughters of Capt. David Scott, who
were carrying dinner to some men mowing a meadow, not far
from their father's house. The younger, an interesting and
beautiful girl, was killed on the spot, as she made some
resistance, but her sister was carried into captivity. The
murdered sister was not found for several days, and when
discovered, presented a most horrible spectacle. Voracious
birds had so preyed upon her that she was but with difficulty
recognized.

About the last of September, Nathaniel Davisson and his
younger brother, living in the vicinity of Clarksburgh, started
upon a hunting expedition on the waters of Ten-mile. Hunting
separately, as was the custom, Josiah returned to camp
at an hour designated for meeting there, but not finding his
brother, and after waiting some time, feeling uneasy about
his safety, determined to search for him. Unable to see or
hear any thing, the other returned home, and prevailed upon
several of his neighbors to aid in endeavoring to ascertain
his fate. Their search was alike unavailing. In the following
March, his remains were found by John Read, while hunting.
He had been shot and scalped; and notwithstanding he had
lain out nearly six months, yet he was but little torn by wild
beasts, and easily recognized.

Tygart's Valley settlement, which had escaped a savage
visitation in 1778, was not to be so exempt during the present
year. In October, a party of Indians lying in ambush near the
road, fired at Lieut. John White, who was riding by, but with
no other effect than wounding his horse, and causing him to
throw his rider. This was fatal to White, as the ground was
open, and he was soon shot, tomahawked and scalped.


253

Page 253

So soon as this event was made known, Capt. Benjamin
Wilson raised a company, and proceeding by forced marches
to the Indian crossing at the mouth of the Sandy fork of
Little Kanhawa, he remained there nearly three days with a
view to intercept the retreat of the savages. They, however,
returned by another rout, and thus his scheme of cutting them
off failed.

Some time after this, several families in the Buchanan
settlement, left the fort and returned to their homes, under
the belief that the season had advanced too far, for the
Indians again to come among them. But in this they were
deceived. The men being all assembled at the fort, for
the purpose of electing a captain, some Indians fell upon the
family of John Schoolcraft, and killed the women and eight
children,—two little boys only were taken prisoners. A small
girl, who had been scalped and tomahawked, a portion of her
brains coming from her head, was found the next day alive.

The last mischief done this fall, was perpetrated at the
house of Samuel Cottrial, near the present town of Clarksburgh.
During the night, considerable fear was excited, both
at Cottrial's and at Sotha Hickman's, on the opposite side
of Elk creek, by the continued barking of dogs. Cottrial,
on going to bed, secured well the doors, and directed that no
one should stir out in the morning until it was ascertained
that no danger threatened. Just before day, Cottrial being
asleep, Moses Coleman, who lived with him, got up, shelled
some corn, and giving a few ears to Cottrial's nephew, with
directions to feed the pigs around the yard, went himself
to an adjoining building and commenced grinding. A single
Indian, one of a party who had lain secreted during the night,
made his appearance, and first catching the boy, fired and
killed Coleman. Running to scalp his victim, the little fellow
made good his escape. The other Indians went off without
doing further injury.

The above, for which we are indebted to the interesting
local history of that region, was followed by numerous other


254

Page 254
cases of savage cruelty, occurring towards the close of the
season of 1779. We regret that our want of room will not
allow more copious extracts at the present time.

1781.

Many depredations were committed during this year on the
frontiers of Virginia and Pennsylvania, and it was perhaps
mainly to these circumstances that the unfortunate Moravian
Indians owe their destruction.

Early in February, a party of Delawares entered the settlement
on the waters of Raccoon creek, Washington county,
near the present town of Florence, and after committing
several acts of violence, made an attack upon the house of
Robert Wallace, during his absence from home, making prisoners
of Mrs. W., her little son Robert, two-and-a-half years
old, another son ten years old, and an infant daughter, also
a man named John Carpenter. With their prisoners, and
what plunder they could carry off, the savages made their way
toward the Ohio; but finding Mrs. Wallace and her infant
somewhat troublesome, they were tomahawked and scalped.
The two boys were carried to Sandusky, where the elder died.
Robert was then sold to the Wyandotts, by whom he was held
in captivity about two and a half years. His father hearing
of him, sent a man to the Wyandott towns, giving him a
certain mark by which the boy could be recognized, and in
this way he was rescued, and restored to his friends. He is
now living on Raccoon creek, a stout, hearty old man, and
bears in distinct recollection the trials, hardships, and privations
of his captivity. He thinks his mother and little sister
were killed near where Georgetown now stands. About three
years subsequent to their captivity, the husband was informed
that the remains of a woman and child had been discovered
near the place designated. He repaired to the spot, and upon
examination recognized the remains as those of his murdered


255

Page 255
wife and child. They were collected and buried at King's
creek Meeting-house.

The clothing of Mrs. Wallace, which were found at the
Moravian towns, called down the vengeance of Colonel Williamson's
men upon that devoted people.

MURDER OF CAPTAIN THOMAS AND FAMILY.

On the night of the 5th of March, a party of Indians came
to the house of Capt. John Thomas, on Booth's creek, one of
the branches of the Monongahela. Capt. Thomas was a man
of much piety, and what was perhaps unusual in the early
days of our Republic, had regular family devotion. It was
whilst thus engaged, surrounded by his wife and seven children,
that the Indians approached his cabin. The settlement
had felt no apprehension as yet of Indian depredation, as the
season had not sufficiently advanced to cause alarm. Anticipating
no attack, Capt. Thomas was therefore not prepared,
and his house not so well secured as was his custom. He had
just repeated the line of the hymn,

"Go worship at Immanuel's feet,"

as the Indians approached and fired. The christian father
fell dead at the moment, and a band of savages forcing the
door, entered and commenced the work of death. Mrs. Thomas
implored their mercy for herself and children; but, alas! the
savage knows no mercy for feeble woman or helpless infancy.
The tomahawk did its work, until the mother and six children
lay weltering in blood, by the side of the slaughtered father.
They then proceeded to scalp the fallen, and plunder the
house, and then departed, taking with them one little boy, a
prisoner.

"Elizabeth Juggins, (daughter of John Juggins, who had
been murdered in that neighborhood, the preceding year) was
at the house of Capt. Thomas, when the Indians came, but as


256

Page 256
soon as she heard the report of the gun and saw Capt. Thomas
fall, she threw herself under the bed, and escaped observation
of the savages. After they had completed the work
of blood and left the house, fearing that they might be lingering
near, she remained in that situation until the house
was found on fire. When she crawled forth from her asylum,
Mrs. Thomas was still alive, though unable to move; and
casting a pitying glance towards her murdered infant, asked
that it might be handed to her. Upon seeing Miss Juggins
about to leave the house, she exclaimed, "Oh, Betsey, do not
leave us!" Still anxious for her own safety, the girl rushed
out, and taking refuge for the night between two logs, in the
morning early, spread the alarm.

"When the scene of these enormities was visited, Mrs.
Thomas was found in the yard, much managled by the tomahawk
and considerably torn by hogs—she had, perhaps in
the struggle of death, thrown herself out at the door. The
house, together with Captain Thomas and the children, was a
heap of ashes."

The fate of this pious family is but one in the long catalogue
of bloody doings which mark the pages of our western
history. It required a christian's heart, and the christian's
hope, to live amid such scenes unmoved and unawed. Who
can contemplate the fate of that unfortunate family without
emotions of poignant sorrow. How happy was the morning
which dawned upon them, but, alas, how terrible the evening!

In April of this year, three brothers, Mathias, Simon and
Michael Schoolcraft, left Buchanan's Fort, and went to the
head of Stone-coal creek, for the purpose of hunting. On
their way back, a party of Indians fired upon them, killing
the first-named brother, and taking the others prisoners.
These, with other members of the family previously taken
never returned. A singular fatality seemed to attend this
family. The three brothers whose names we have just given,


257

Page 257
constituted the last of fifteen, who either fell before the rifle
or tomahawk, or suffered, perhaps, a more dreadful fate in
the hands of their captors.

The founder of this Virginia branch of the Schoolcraft
family, was one of the earliest settlers on the upper Monongahela.
He emigrated from central New York, mainly
induced by the prospect of acquiring for a large family,
suitable landed properties. Unfortunately, his family early
fell a prey to the relentless and ever vigilant savage. The
founder of the Virginia family was, we believe, distantly
connected with the distinguished author, Henry R. School-craft,
whose magnificent work just issued[20] (1851) is alike
creditable to himself, the government (by whose munificence
it has been published,) and the cause of American literature.
It seems not a little remarkable, that while one member of the
family branch should have been devoting almost his whole
life to studying means for bettering and promoting the condition
of the Indians, members of another branch, and they
constituting a numerous family, should have been totally
exterminated by the same savage hands.

 
[20]

Historical and Statistical Information respecting the History, Condition
and Prospects of the Indian Tribes of the United States.

MEDITATED ATTACK ON WHEELING.

In September of this year, occurred what may be called
the second attempt upon Wheeling.

Fortunately, the purpose of the Indians was frustrated by
the timely information communicated by Colonel Brodhead,
then commanding the western division of the army. The
despatch of Colonel B. was as follows:—

Sir:

I have this moment received certain intelligence that the


258

Page 258
enemy are coming in great force against us, and particularly
against Wheeling. You will immediately put your garrison
in the best posture of defence, and lay in as great a quantity
of water as circumstances will admit, and receive them coolly.
They intend to decoy your garrison, but you are to guard
against stratagem, and defend the post to the last extremity.

You may rely upon every aid in my power to frustrate the
designs of the enemy; but you must not fail to give the alarm
to the inhabitants in your reach, and make it as general as
possible, in order that every man may be prepared at this
crisis.

I am, sir, your most obedient servant,
(Signed) Daniel Brodhead,
Col. Commanding W. D.
To the Commanding Officer at Fort Henry, Wheeling."

This information, as may well be supposed, startled the
inhabitants at Wheeling; but, not unmindful of the notice,
they put themselves in readiness to meet and resist any attack
the enemy might make. The fort was immediately placed in
proper condition for defence, and nothing left undone to
ensure their safety.

About ten days after the reception of the despatch of Col.
Brodhead, a party of over one hundred Indians suddenly
appeared in the vicinity of the fort. The first intimation
those within the stockade had of the presence of the enemy,
was by a boy named George Reikart, reaching the fort almost
exhausted, who stated that a large party of Indians were at
the spring, (near the hill,) and that they had killed his companion,
John Ryan, and taken David Glenn prisoner.

The approach of the Indians had been so sudden and noiseless,
that Ryan was shot down, and Glenn taken prisoner, but
Reikart, who was some distance off, gathering walnuts, escaped.
Just as he entered the fort-gate, a rifle-ball struck him on the
wrist.

In a moment, those within were ready to receive them; but,
it is supposed, that the savages, from information of Glenn,
anticipated a warm reception, and deemed it better valor to
make off at once. This they did, after demanding in a pompous


259

Page 259
manner, the surrender of the fort, which request the inmates
very politely declined acceding to.

Thus, owing to the timely information of Col. Brodhead,
the settlement at Wheeling was, doubtless, saved from what
might have been a bloody visitation.

MURDER AT LINK'S BLOCK-HOUSE.

Of the many primitive places of defence which sprung up
at an early day in the forests of North-western Virginia, was
that of Link's block-house, on middle Wheeling creek. It
was built by Jonathan Link, in 1780, and served to shelter
the defenceless settlers of the neighborhood. This rude
structure stood a few miles from the present town of Triadelphia,
and early became the scene of a bloody occurrence.

In the fall of 1781, a party of fifteen or twenty Indians,
returning from an excursion to the interior, made an attack
upon this block-house so suddenly, that Link and two of his
men were instantly killed, and several taken prisoners. The
men had been at a shooting match, and it is supposed may
have indulged rather too freely to present a vigorous defence.

Of those taken prisoner, was William Hawkins, who lived
within a few miles,[21] but who had gone to attend the shooting
match. Hawkins told the Indians, if they did not kill him
he would go quietly to his house. This they agreed to, but
his family hearing their approach, (Hawkins spoke loud so as
to give the alarm,) secreted themselves in time. A daughter,
however, was discovered and taken prisoner, and another
member of the family killed.

The savages, after plundering the house, marched their
prisoners in front, and proceeding a mile or two, ordered the


260

Page 260
daughter on ahead. They then took Hawkins and another
prisoner, named Presly Peak, to the summit of a ridge, tied
them to separate trees, and tomahawked them.

 
[21]

The families of the neighborhood had temporarily withdrawn to gather
their crops, &c. The Indians had not been very troublesome for some time,
and it was supposed there would be no danger in returning to their homes.

1782.

This was a fatal and trying year to the frontier settlements
of Virginia. The enemy were early in the field, and almost
ceaseless in their attacks upon the comparatively defenceless
inhabitants. The expeditions of Williamson, Crawford, &c.,
seemed but to arouse the savages to increased acts of barbarity.
They penetrated some distance to the interior, and
waged their ruthless and indiscriminating warfare with an
energy and ferocity rarely equalled.

Family after family fell before their approach, until the
whole country became aroused to the extent of their depredations.
Their blows fell with particular severity upon the
settlements along the upper Monongahela.

In the neighborhood of Clarksburgh many acts of hostility
were committed, which greatly alarmed the adjacent settlements.

The following, which we extract from Mr. Withers' sketches,
cannot but be interesting to most readers of western history.
We much regret the instance of human depravity which it
details; but for the credit of our nature, we can say, such
instances were very rare in the early days of the west.

"On the 8th of March, as William White, Timothy Dorman
and his wife, were going to, and within sight of Buchanan
fort, some guns were discharged at them, and White being
shot through the hips, fell from his horse, and was then tomahawked,
scalped and mutilated in the most frightful manner.
Dorman and his wife were taken prisoners. The people in
the fort heard the firing, and flew to arms; but the river intervening,
the savages cleared themselves before the whites
crossed over.

"After the death of White (one of their most active, cautious,


261

Page 261
and vigilant spies) and the capture of Dorman, it was
resolved to abandon the fort, and seek elsewhere security
from the greater ills which it was found would befall them if
they remained. This apprehension arose from the fact, that
Dorman was then with the savages, and that to gratify his
enmity to particular individuals in the settlement, he would
unite with the Indians, and from his knowledge of the country,
be enabled to
conduct them the more securely to blood
and plunder. He was a man of a sanguinary and revengeful
disposition, prone to quarrelling, and had been known to say
that if he caught particular individuals with whom he was at
variance, in the woods alone, he would murder them and attribute
it to the savages. The fearful apprehensions of increased
and aggravated injuries after taking him prisoner, were well
founded. Subsequent events fully proved, that but for the
evacuation of the fort, and the removal of the inhabitants,
all would have fallen before the fury of savage warriors, with
this white miscreant at their head.

"While some of the inhabitants of that settlement were engaged
in moving their property to a fort in Tygart's valley
(the others moving to Nutter's fort and Clarksburg), they were
fired upon by a party of savages, and two of them, Michael
Hagle and Elias Paynter, fell. The horse which a man named
Bush rode, was shot through; yet Bush succeeded in extricating
himself, and escaped, though closely pursued by one of
the savages. Several times the Indian following him, called
out, "Stop, and you shall not be hurt. If you do not, I will
shoot you!
" and once, Bush, nearly exhausted and in despair
of getting off, actually relaxed his pace for the purpose of
yielding himself a prisoner, when turning round he saw the
savage stop, and commence loading his gun. This inspired
Bush with fear for the consequences, and renewing his
flight, finally escaped. Edward Tanner, a youth, was taken
prisoner, and in going to their towns, met between twenty and
thirty savages, headed by Timothy Dorman, proceeding to
attack Buchanan fort. Learning from him that the inhabitants


262

Page 262
were moving from it, and that it would be abandoned in a few
days, the Indians pursued their journey with so much haste,
that Dorman had well nigh failed from fatigue. They arrived,
however, too late for the accomplishment of their bloody
purpose; the settlement had been deserted, and the inhabitants
were safe within the walls of other forts.

"A few days after the evacuation of Buchanan fort, some of
its former inmates went from Clarksburg for grain which had
been left at Buchanan. They found a heap of ashes where
the fort had stood, and other signs convinced them that the
savages were yet lurking about. They, however, continued
to go from farm to farm collecting the grain, but with the
utmost vigilance, and at night went to an out-house, near
where the fort had stood. Here they found a paper, with the
name of Timothy Dorman attached to it, dated at the Indian
towns, and containing information of those who had been
taken captive in that part of Virginia.

"Early in the morning, as some of the men went from
the house to mill, they saw the savages crossing the river,
Dorman being with them. Thinking it best to impress them
with a belief that they were able to encounter them in open
conflict, the men advanced towards the foe, calling to their
companions in the house, to come on. The Indians fled hastily
to the woods, and the whites, not so rash as to pursue them,
returned to the house, and secured themselves in it, as well as
they could. At night, Capt. George Jackson went privately
from the house, and at great hazard of being discovered,
proceeded to Clarksburg, and obtained such aid as enabled
him to escort his companions in safety to that place.

"Disappointed in their hopes of involving the inhabitants of
Buchanan settlement in destruction, the savages went on to
the Valley. Between Westfall's and Wilson's forts, they came
upon John Bush and his wife, Jacob Stalnaker and his son
Adam. The latter were riding in the rear of Bush and his
wife; Adam was killed. The old gentleman rode briskly on,
but some of the savages were before, and endeavored to catch


263

Page 263
his bridle-reins. He, however, escaped in safety. The horse
from which Adam Stalnaker had fallen, was caught by Bush,
and both he and Mrs. Bush got safely away on him."

SECOND SIEGE OF FORT HENRY.

The last beleaguerment of the fort at Wheeling, was
certainly one of the most important events in the settlement
of the north-west,—one, upon which it may emphatically be
said, the very existence of the frontier of Virginia depended.

On the eleventh day of September, 1782, a body of three
hundred and fifty Indians and whites; the former, Shawanese
and Delawares, under the command of George Girty,[22]
and the latter, a company known as the "Queen's Rangers,"
commanded by Captain Pratt, made their appearance in
front of the little stockade at Wheeling, and peremptorily
demanded a surrender. The besiegers marched up in regular
file, headed by a fife and drum,[23] with the British flag flying
over them.

Girty, upon whom the whole command devolved, defiled his
men by the spring near where the market-house now stands,
and in the name of the British Governor demanded a surrender.
He promised to all who would give up, "the best protection
King George could afford." To this, the brave and
dauntless inmates of the fort returned contemptuous answers,
and defied the savages, both white and red, to do their worst.

Girty, deeming it imprudent to commence the attack in
daylight, kept his men at a convenient distance until nightfall.


264

Page 264
The conversation, however, was continued between the
besieged and besiegers, the former delighting to load the
renegade with the most opprobrious epithets. Shots were
occasionally fired at him, but the distance was too great for
effect.

Fortunately for the inmates, that the attack had not commenced
half an hour earlier. For some days previous to the
appearance of the savages, scouts had been across the Ohio,
but discovering no traces of the enemy, returned on the
afternoon of Saturday, and reported accordingly. This news
had the effect of lulling the inmates into a feeling of security,
so that it was scarcely deemed necessary to fasten the gates
at night.

A day or two previous to the time of which we write,
Andrew Zane had gone to Catfish, for a supply of liquor.
Returning with two kegs, (one in each end of a bag,) he discovered,
as he supposed, when near the present site of Mount
Wood Cemetery, indications of Indians. Concealing his kegs,
he hurried to the fort with all haste, and gave the alarm. Those
who had just returned from the Indian country, laughed at
his fears, but most of the men said they would go along, and
have a "spree."

Nearly the whole efficient force of the garrison accompanied
Zane, and finding no Indians, repaired to the spring already
alluded to, and there treated themselves to a glorious "blow
out." Before starting with Zane, it was deemed advisable,
with the characteristic caution of experienced frontiermen, to
send across the river two spies, who might give the alarm in
case of danger.[24] As the party at the spring were busy with
their "grog," the alarm guns of the scouts were fired on the
island, and at the same moment, a large body of Indians were
crossing the creek, just above back-water. A simultaneous
rush was made for the fort; and scarcely had the last man


265

Page 265
entered, when the Indians appeared in large numbers crossing
the bottom.

All at once became activity and bustle within the fort.
The men prepared for an energetic defence, each arming
himself with a rifle, tomahawk, scalping knife and spear.
The women were busy in running bullets, securing the children,
etc. The whole number of fighting men within the
stockade did not exceed eighteen, while the number of women
and children was about forty. (See Note D., end Chap. I.)

Shortly before the enemy appeared, a pirogue loaded with
cannon-balls, designed for Gen. Clark, at Louisville, in charge
of a man named Sullivan, and two others, landed at Wheeling,
to remain over night. Sullivan was a shrewd and experienced
soldier, well versed in Indian cunning; and on this account
was selected to manage the affairs of the fort during the
siege, as the commandant, Captain Boggs, had gone for
succor immediately on the alarm of the enemy's approach.
Sullivan was a man of discrimination and courage, and well
qualified for the post of commander. His shrill voice could
be heard at all hours, urging on the men, and consoling the
women. But at length he was wounded, and for a time had to
give way.

About sundown, Girty made a second demand for surrender,
declaring that should be his last summons, and swearing, if
they refused, that the fort would be stormed, and every soul
massacred. He was answered by taunts of defiance; said
they remembered too well the fate of Col. Crawford, to give
up, and be butchered like dogs. Girty replied, that their
doom was sealed—he had taken their express, and all hope
of safety might be given up. Sullivan inquired what kind of
looking man the messenger was? "A fine, smart, active young
fellow," answered the outlaw chief. "That's a d—d lie,"
said Sullivan, "he is an old gray-headed man."

Finding all attempts to intimidate in vain, Girty led on his
white and red army of savages, and attempted to carry out
his threat of storming the fort.


266

Page 266

Near the centre of the stockade, and at a point sufficiently
elevated to clear the pickets, was a small French cannon,[25]
which the enemy could at times see, but which they tauntingly
said was "wood,"[26] and dared them to "shoot." Having approached
within a convenient distance, and just as the whole
party was pressing up in deep columns, the "bull-dog" was
let off, cutting a wide passage through the ranks of wondering
and affrighted savages. Captain Pratt, who had heard guns,
and knew how they sounded, cried out to his swarthy comrades,
"Stand back; by G—, there's no wood about that!"

The Indians and the "Rangers" gave way at the first
discharge, but soon rallied and returned. Girty divided his
force into small parties, and attacked the fort at different
points; now attempting to storm it; and again to fire it.
In this manner the siege was kept up during the whole
night; and but few such nights were ever passed upon the
frontier.

One of the bastions having given way, but two were of
use, and these the men occupied in turn. The women, during
the whole of that long and perilous night, proved themselves
heroines of no ordinary type. They stood at their posts like
soldiers of a dozen campaigns, cooling and loading the rifles
of their husbands, brothers, and lovers. Such women were
worthy the love and devotion of men like these. No timid
shrieks escaped them; no maidenly fears caused them to
shrink from their self-imposed and most onerous task. Such
were the pioneer mothers of the west—women whose souls
and bodies were so sorely tried in the fierce fire of our Indian
wars. Through the whole of that long and terrible night,
without food and without rest, did these brave and noble


267

Page 267
women stand to their duty, regardless of fatigue, but nerving
their hearts to the contest, and animating the men with hope
and courage. The Greek matron, who urged her son to the
conflict, charging him to return with his shield or upon it,
displayed no more zeal, devotion, and true courage, than these
hero-women of the west. History is full of examples of female
heroism. Israel had her Judith and Deborah; France glories
in her Joan and Lavalette;—two of them unsexed themselves
in the excitement of battle; one ingloriously stained her
hands in human gore, and the other had nothing to lose by
her successful efforts; but the western heroines, without the
eclat of female warriors, displayed more true courage throughout
the long and stormy days of our Indian warfare, and exhibited
more of the true spirit of heroism, than any example
in ancient or modern history.

At an early hour in the evening, the Indians descried the
pirogue already referred to, and at once resolved to try the
sport of cannonading. Procuring a stout log of sufficient size
and length, these simple-minded men split it open, and having
cut out the centre with their tomahawks, fastened the parts
together with iron bands, and chains, found in a smith-shop
belonging to a man named Reikart. They then charged it
heavily with powder and ball, and first announcing that their
artillery had arrived, applied the torch, when instantaneously
a half-dozen of the gaping savages, who had clustered around
to witness the discharge, were blown into eternity. Their
frail gun had bursted, scattering death and consternation all
around.

During the night, a large number of Indians posted themselves
in the loft of a house which stood thirty or forty yards
north of the fort. These amused themselves by dancing,
shouting, and yelling, making night hideous with their horrid
noise. Thinking to dislodge them, several ineffectual attempts
were made to do so with grape shot; but failing, a full-sized
ball was fired, which cut off a sleeper, and let the whole


268

Page 268
mass down together. This disaster frightened the assailants
off for a time.

The cannon was fired sixteen times during the first night,
doing more or less execution at each discharge. It was managed
by a man named John Tait, shortly afterwards killed
and partly eaten by the savages, on Dillie's bottom, opposite
Grave creek.[27]

At the time of the Indian visitation in 1777, it will be
remembered, they burned all the houses, killed the cattle,
etc. Similar outrages were again attempted in 1781, and
then Colonel Ebenezer Zane resolved, that should the savages
again visit the settlement, he would remain in his house and
perish, sooner than abandon it to the torch of the enemy. On
the re-appearance of the Indians, Colonel Zane continued at
his house, and declared his fixed determination to defend it
to the last. In the house with him were several members of
his family, including his brother Silas. There were also two
brothers by the name of Green, and a black servant, by the
name of Sam. So constantly did these four keep up the fire
against the enemy, that they were slow to approach within
range of the guns.[28]


269

Page 269

The fortunes of the night were often variable. The enemy
at one time appeared to have the vantage, but again, their
schemes were frustrated by the energy and skill of those
within the fort. More than twenty times did they attempt to
fire the stockade, by heaping bundles of hemp against the
walls, and kindling them at different points. Most fortunately,
however, the hemp was wet, and could not be made to burn.
Dry wood and other combustibles were tried, but all in vain.
Day at length dawned upon the hopes of that almost despairing
people; and never did Aurora display her beauties to a
more admiring or a more rejoicing group. The night had
been long, and full of gloomy terror. They knew not at what
moment the formidable enemy would crush the walls of their
frail enclosure;[29] but come what might, they resolved to stand
firm to the last.

Immediately after day-break the Indians and British withdrew
to the spring, and a cessation of hostilities for several
hours ensued.

It was about noon of this day that an incident occurred
which has been the theme of history, poetry and romance.
We allude to the "gunpowder exploit," as it is familiarly
known in border story.

As we have already stated, Colonel Zane remained in his
cabin near the fort,[30] during the whole siege. Finding that
his supply of powder was likely to run out, he proposed to
those present, that some one of them would have to visit the
fort and renew the stock. It was known to be a hazardous
undertaking, and unwilling to order either of the white men
to so perilous an enterprise, Colonel Zane submitted the


270

Page 270
matter to their own devotion and courage. One of them
instantly proffered his services, but a female member of Col.
Zane's family came forward and said, "No! I will go;
should I be killed, I can be better spared than one of these
men.
" That woman, according to the traditionary accounts
of the country, was Elizabeth Zane, sister to Colonel Zane.[31]
She is represented to have been a young woman of great
resolution and much energy of character, and those who
knew her intimately say unhesitatingly, that she was just the
person for such an exploit. Preparing herself for the feat,
the intrepid girl stepped from the cabin and bounded to the
fort with the speed of a deer. A number of Indians concealed
in the neighborhood, saw her emerge from the cabin,
but did not attempt to shoot, only exclaiming with contemptuous
epithets, "Squaw, squaw." She reached the fort,
and tying about her person eight or ten pounds of powder,
again ventured forth and moved rapidly towards the cabin of
Colonel Zane. Suspecting all was not right, the savages
opened upon her a volley of rifle balls, but unscathed, the
courageous girl bounded into the arms of those who stood
ready to receive her.


271

Page 271

That act of the heroic and single-hearted female saved the
inmates of Colonel Zane's house from certain destruction.
Their ammunition had been exhausted, and every soul would
have fallen a sure prey to the fury of the savages, had not
a supply been obtained.

Night closing in, the enemy renewed the attack, and
maintained it without intermission until daybreak.

Shortly after sunrise, the enemy despairing of success,
commenced killing the cattle, burning the vacant cabins, &c.

About ten o'clock A.M., an Indian spy, who had been sent
out to watch the approach of a relief, returned, and when
within sight of the fort, gave a long, deep, peculiar whoop,
which the well-trained Indian hunters fully understood as a
signal to be off. Scarcely had the echoes of his shout ceased
reverberating along the valley than the entire hostile army
moved rapidly toward the river, which they crossed near
where the North-Western Bank now stands. In less than
half an hour after their retreat, Captain Williamson with
seventy mounted men rode up to the fort, and great was the
rejoicing at the appearance of his gallant band. Thus ended
the final investment of Fort Henry. The Indians never
again attempted to molest it, but gave the place as wide a
latitude as convenient in their expeditions against the back
settlements.

 
[22]

This was a brother of Simon Girty, and said by many to have been more
ruthless than his brother. It is believed that much of the obloquy which
fell upon Simon, justly belonged to the other. According to Stover, George
was conspicuous at the burning of Colonel Crawford, and acted in the most
heartless manner towards that unfortunate officer, as well as towards
himself (Stover).

[23]

Stephen Burkam, lately deceased, was in the fort at the time, and says
the "music" was the best he ever heard.

[24]

These men were Peter Neiswanger and Hambleton Kerr, both experienced
scouts.

[25]

This cannon was found in the Monongahela, at Pittsburg, by a man
named Neeley, while swimming. It had been spiked and thrown into the
river by the French, when they abandoned Fort Du Quesne.

[26]

A year or two previous to this occurrence, some of the men about Fort
Henry attempted to make a wooden cannon. This fact the Indians learned
from a prisoner, then in their possession.

[27]

Just before daylight, one of the sentinels discovered a person approaching
the sally-port gate, and supposing him to be an enemy, fired upon him at the
moment of discovery. It proved to be a negro who was making his escape.
His piteous cries from the wound and fright, (he was shot through the right
breast,) induced the inmates to open the gate, and let him in. He gave
much information of the condition and resources of the enemy.

The fellow was handcuffed, and a rope placed about his neck, by which
his guard led him around the fort, wherever duty or occasion might call.
He was committed to the care and keeping of Miss Lydia Boggs, now Mrs.
Cruger, who has frequently told the author that she was ready at any time
to tomahawk him if he attempted to molest her, or escape. He was believed
to be a spy.

[28]

An incident occurred, in connection with this, which it may not be
unimportant to relate. On making the discovery that the house was tenanted,
Girty inquired who were the occupants. He was answered, "Some sick
children." "Ain't you afraid we will kill them?" asked the outlaw. "No
matter," rejoined those in the fort, "they will die any how."

[29]

Mrs. Cruger, as we have before stated, was an inmate of the fort, and
says the pickets were so much decayed in places, that they could not have
withstood a united pressure from the enemy. During the night, several at
the north-west corner, from which the hottest fire had been kept up, gave
way and fell, but owing to a heavy growth of peach trees on the outside,
the fact was not discovered by the enemy. They were immediately replaced.

[30]

This house stood near the same spot now occupied by the stone mansion
of Mrs. Dorsey, late Mrs. Noah Zane.

[31]

Within recent years, a most unfortunate difficulty has arisen as to the
real heroine on this occasion. We have for months prosecuted a most
searching inquiry into all the facts and circumstances connected with this
affair, but the further we seemed to push our inquiries, the more the mystery
appeared to thicken. Despairing of being able to establish the fact satisfactorily,
we have concluded to submit the testimony to our readers; giving
the credit to Elizabeth Zane, but exhibiting the counter-claim in behalf of
Molly Scott, as will be found in the letter of the venerable Mrs. Cruger, at
the close of this chapter (Note E). This seems the only course we could
rightly pursue. Mrs. Cruger is a most important and reliable witness, and
to discard her testimony, would be to go further than we are willing to do.
Her statement too, has been sustained by other cotemporary witnesses. The
proof in favor of Elizabeth Zane is most abundant; so that at best, the whole
matter as to who performed the exploit, is still in doubt and mystery. It is
barely possible that there may have been two "gunpowder" incidents; one
in September 1781, and the other in the following fall. One of the parties
may have carried powder at the first, and the other, at the second. This
seems the only way in which the conflicting claims can be reconciled.

RICE'S FORT ATTACKED.

After raising the siege at Wheeling, a division of the
enemy visited the settlements on Short and Buffalo creeks,
but the people had all taken the precaution to shut themselves
up in block-houses. Determined, however, to effect a massacre
somewhere, out of revenge for their failure at Fort
Wheeling, the party made a descent upon Rice's Fort.[32] Information


272

Page 272
had luckily reached the inmates of the Indians'
design, and they were prepared for them. The Indians
surrounded the fort and demanded a surrender, saying,
"Give up, give up; too many Injun—Injun too big; no
kill.
" But the sturdy frontiermen thought differently, and
answered with shouts of defiance: "Come on, cowards, we
are ready for you; show us your yellow skins, and we'll make
holes in them for you!" This was what may be considered
brag, however, as the fort was but illy defended, many of
their men having gone to Hagerstown, Md., to exchange
their peltries for ammunition, salt, &c. The savages finding
they could make no impression upon the inmates, withdrew
until nine or ten o'clock at night, when they fired a large and
well filled barn which stood within thirty yards of the fort.
The position of the building and the course of the wind saved
the fort from destruction, and its inmates from massacre.

After the barn was set on fire, the Indians collected on
the side of the fort opposite, so as to have the advantage of
the light, and kept up a pretty constant fire, which was as
steadily answered by those in the fort, until about two o'clock,
when the Indians left the place and made a hasty retreat.

The names of those who defended this little fortress were
Jacob Miller, George Lefler, Peter Fullenweider, Daniel Rice,
George Felebaum and Jacob Lefler, Jr. George Felebaum
was shot in the forehead, through a port-hole, at the second
fire of the Indians, and instantly expired, so that in reality
the defence of the place was made by only five men.

The ascertained loss of the Indians was four, three of
whom were killed at the first fire from the fort, the other
was killed about sundown. There can be no doubt but that
a number more were killed and wounded in the engagement,
but concealed or carried off.

 
[32]

Rice's fort stood on Buffalo creek, about fourteen miles from the river.


273

Page 273

FATE OF THE PIATT FAMILY.

In the year 1782, rumor having reached Dillie's blockhouse,
a small stockade opposite Grave creek, on the farm now
owned by Col. John Thompson, that an attack was meditated
upon Ryerston's station, which was near the line between
Virginia and Pennsylvania, it was deemed expedient to
send a detachment to the relief of the station. During the
absence of the men, a party of Indians took possession of a
corn field near the block-house. The night being extremely
warm, one of the inmates, named Piatt, said he would go and
sleep in the cabin, as he could not endure the fleas. His wife
and five children, went along. The cabin stood about three
hundred yards from the block-house. At the break of day,
the Indians attacked, and murdered every member of that ill-fated
family. A woman at the block-house heard the guns,
and expressed fears that the Indians were attacking the cabin,
but others said it was the men returning from Ryerston's.

The savages soon presented themselves before the blockhouse,
brandishing the bloody scalps of their victims, and
demanded a surrender. Old Mr. Winter tauntingly replied,
they had plenty of men, and would give them cold lead in
abundance if they remained any longer. Fearing they might
meet with warm work, the savages made off without further
delay. There were not six fighting men in the house at that
time.

Early in the fall, a party of Indians came upon the premises
of a man named Yates, living not far from the residence
of the late Colonel Woods, and succeeded in getting between a
young man named Peter Starnator and Yates' house. Starnator
was a few hundred yards in advance when he discovered
the Indians, and finding it unsafe to attempt to
return, started at full speed down the bottom. The savages,
however, proved too fleet for him, as he was overtaken and


274

Page 274
shot in the Narrows, near where Mr. Steenrod now lives. The
Indian who killed him was so close that the shot made a hole
in the skull large enough to admit a man's hand.

He was taken to Wheeling, and interred in the old burial
ground, upon which the North-Western Bank now stands.

MURDER OF THE TAIT FAMILY.

During the same fall, another family, named Tait, living
about half a mile below the block-house, was attacked by a
party of Indians, and four of them killed. A son, fifteen
years of age, in attempting to bar the savages out, was
severely wounded by a ball in the mouth. His father at
length was shot down, and the youth secreted himself behind
a barrel. The door was then forced open, and the savages
entered. The father and two small children were immediately
tomahawked and scalped. Mrs. Tait had concealed herself
on the "log pole," but was soon discovered and dispatched.
The cannibals then commenced the revolting work of cutting
pieces from the old man's breasts and thighs, which were
roasted and eaten! During the time they were thus engaged,
the boy managed to drag his mother off the fire without being
noticed.

As many writers have denied the existence of American
cannibalism, it may not be inopportune to cite here some
authority in proof of it. At a recent meeting of the American
Academy of Arts and Sciences, Professor Shepherd, who has
lately spent some time in exploring the mining regions on the
shores of Lake Superior, related an instance of the most
horrible cannibalism among the Ojibbeway tribe of Indians,
on the north shore of the Lake. "He frequently passed on
foot, alone and unarmed, by the hut of an Indian, who had
killed and eaten his wife and two children. The personal
appearance of this savage monster, as might naturally be
supposed, was horrible beyond description."


275

Page 275

Another important witness is Hon. Lewis Cass, of Michigan.
In his oration, delivered at Fort Wayne, Indiana, July 4,
1843, on the occasion of celebrating the opening of the Wabash
and Erie canal, the distinguished orator said:

"The line of your canal was a bloody war-path, which has
seen many a deed of horror. And this peaceful town has
had its Moloch, and the records of human depravity furnish
no more horrible examples of cruelty than were offered at his
shrine.

The Miami Indians, our predecessors in the occupation of
this district, had a fearful institution, whose origin and objects
have been lost in the darkness of aboriginal history, but
which continued to a late period, and whose orgies were held
upon the very spot where we now are. It was called the Man-eating
Society, and its was the duty of its associates to eat
such prisoners as were preserved and delivered to them for
that purpose. The members of this society belonged to a
particular family, and the dreadful inheritance descended to
all the children, male and female. The duties it imposed
could not be avoided, and the sanctions of religion were added
to the obligations of immemorable usage. The feast was a
solemn ceremony, at which the whole tribe was collected, as
actors or spectators. The miserable victim was bound to a
stake, and burned at a slow fire, with all the refinements of
cruelty which savage ingenuity could invent. There was a
traditionary ritual, which regulated, with revolting precision,
the whole course of procedure at these ceremonies. Latterly
the authority and obligations of the institution had declined,
and I presume it has now wholly disappeared. But I have
seen and conversed with the head of the family, the chief of
the society, whose name was White Skin. With what feelings
of disgust, I need not attempt to describe. I well knew an
intelligent Canadian, who was present at one of the last sacrifices
made to this horrible institution. The victim was a
young American, captured in Kentucky, during the revolutionary
war. Here, we are now assembled in peace and


276

Page 276
security, celebrating the triumph of art and industry. Within
the memory of the present generation, our countrymen have
been thus tortured, and murdered, and devoured. But, thank
God, that council fire is extinguished. The impious feast is
over."

DEATH OF HUGH CAMERON.

In February of this year, a man named Hugh Cameron,
in company with another person, both of whom had been
employed by Captain Boggs, (living at that time on his farm
near the mouth of Boggs' run,) went out to the camp, which
was a short distance from the house, to boil sugar. Although
so early in the season, the Indians had commenced their
depredations, and Captain B., a few days previously, removed
his family to the fort at Wheeling. Cameron and his companion
had been cautioned by Captain B. and others to be
on their guard, and that one should watch while the other
slept. The men, however, as was too often the case in those
days, disregarded the admonition, and one of them at least
paid for the temerity with his life.

At night, the savages stole upon their tent and killed
Cameron, but in the darkness his companion escaped. The
remains of the unfortunate man were found some years after,
those of the body lying near the mouth of Boggs' run, and
the skull half a mile up that stream, carried there, it was
supposed, by some wild animal: they were identified by a
peculiar tooth.


277

Page 277

NOTE A.

The stockade at Wheeling, of which a most perfect representation is given
in our drawing, was one of the earliest built in the west, and is memorable
for having undergone two distinct sieges which, for duration, severity, and
manly resistance, are unequalled in the annals of the west. It was built in
1774, and stood upon the spot now occupied by "Zane's row," and the
present residence of Colonel Charles D. Knox. It was considered one of the
most substantial structures of the kind, in the valley of the Ohio, and is
said to have been planned by no less a personage than George Rogers Clark,
certainly one of the first military genius in the land. (The reader will
notice elsewhere, that Clark was at Wheeling in the spring of 1774, at
which time the fort was projected, and it is not therefore improbable, his
master mind may have suggested the plan of this celebrated stockade.)
Fort Henry[33] was a parallelogram, having its greatest length along the river.
The pickets were of white oak, and about seventeen feet in height; it was
supported by bastions, and thus well adapted for resisting a savage force,
however powerful. It contained several cabins, arranged along the western
wall. The commandant's house, store-house, etc., were in the centre; the
captain's house was two stories high, and the top so adapted as to be used
for firing a small cannon from: this, the artist has caught, and shown in his
drawing. The store-house was but one story, and very strong, so as to
answer for a lock-up. No regular garrison was maintained at this post, or
at least, only for a very brief period. When Lord Dunmore returned from
Camp Charlotte, he left some twenty or thirty men at the fort, who remained
during most of the following year. Towards the close of 1776, the Virginia
Convention, apprehending renewed outbreak on the part of the Indians, since
the repudiation of Dunmore's government, ordered the post at Wheeling to
be garrisoned by fifty men; this order, however, was not fulfilled.

In the fall of the same year, (1776), three new counties having been
created in the west, (Ohio, Youghiogheny, and Monongahela,) the authorities
of the first named lost no time in preparing to meet any force
that might be sent against them. Their militia were organized, and other
steps taken for a vigorous and successful resistance.

 
[33]

This stockade was originally called Fort Fincastle, after the then most
western county. In 1776, it was refitted, and named Fort Henry, in honor
of Virginia's patriotic and eloquent governor.


278

Page 278

NOTE B.

There seems to be a wide-spread error, as to the date of this occurrence.
Within recent years, several writers have sprung up who pertinaciously
insist that the "first battle of Wheeling," was on the twenty-sixth of September,
1777. Another gentleman, delving among the old records of Ohio
county, thought he had discovered the true and unquestionable date in one
of the early order books of said county, and says that the siege commenced
on the 27th of September. Convinced, from information in our possession,
that these were both wrong, we determined to right the matter, and establish
the truth. This we have found a most difficult task. To upset an
authenticated record, we knew would be a troublesome matter; but feeling not
unlike Sir Walter Raleigh when he burned his history, because a fact which he
was personally cognizant of had been contradicted, we resolved to go no
further until we had investigated the case most thoroughly, and could satisfy
ourselves most fully. All the evidence at hand tended most conclusively to
prove that the first, and not the twenty-sixth or twenty-seventh of September
was the day upon which the siege commenced. But how would this evidence
weigh against the order referred to,[34] was the question? With much labor
and investigation, we are at length able to reconcile the apparent discrepancy.
Sergeant Jacob Ogle was not killed at Wheeling, as the record would
seem to imply, although it does not say so; but was one of the two who
escaped with his kinsman, Captain Ogle. Here then, the mystery ceases,
and the record and the facts perfectly agree. Sergeant Jacob Ogle, we
repeat, escaped the terrible massacre in front of the fort at Wheeling, on the
first day of September, only to fall in the deplorable ambuscade at Grave
creek narrows, September twenty-seventh, 1777!

These facts we have derived from an undoubted source. The late Mr.
Hedges of this county frequently stated that Sergeant Ogle was one of the
party who fell with Foreman.

 
[34]

Extract from Order Book No. 3, p. 144—Sept. 1789. On application
of Mary Ogle to this court,

"Ordered, that it be certified to the executive of the Commonwealth, that
due proof hath been made before us, that Jacob Ogle, husband of said Mary,
was a sergeant in Captain Joseph Ogle's company of Ohio county militia,
and that the said Jacob Ogle was killed on the 27th day of September,
1777, in actual service; and that the said Mary Ogle still remains a widow,
endeavoring to support a family of six children, and that it is the opinion of
this court, that the said Mary Ogle ought to draw pay as the law directs."


279

Page 279

NOTE C.

"A list of the effects lost, of sundry soldiers of Captain William Foreman's
company of Hampshire county volunteers, appraised by Lieutenant Anthony
Miller, and Ensign David Wilson, officers of said company, being duly qualified
for that purpose.

                                         
£  s.  d. 
1.  Captain William Foreman—A rifle-gun, £11 5s. shot pouch
and horn, 10s. pocket compass, 5s. a blanket, £1 17s. 6d., 
13  17 
2.  Edward Peterson—A rifle-gun, £11 5s. shot pouch and
horn, 10s. blanket, 30s., 
13 
3.  Benjamin Powell—A rifle-gun, £12 10s. a blanket, £1 17s.
6d., shot pouch and horn, 12s. 6d., 
15  10 
4.  Hambleton Foreman—A rifle-gun, £11 5s., a blanket, 30s.,
shot pouch and horn, 10s. 
13 
5.  James Greene—A rifle-gun, £10, a blanket, 37s. 6d.,  11  17 
6.  John Wilson—A rifle-gun, £10, shot pouch and horn, 7s. 6d.
blanket, 22s. 6d. 
11  10 
7.  Jacob Pew—A rifle-gun, £8 15s. shot pouch and horn, 10s.
blanket, 18s. 9d. 
10 
8.  Isaac Harris—A rifle-gun, £12 10s. shot pouch and horn, 10s.
blanket, 37s. 6d. 
14  17 
9.  Robert M'Grew—A blanket, 22s. 6d. 
10.  Elisha Shivers—A blanket, 22s. 6d. 
11.  Henry Riser—A blanket, 37s. 6d. 
12.  Bartholomew Viney—A blanket, 22s. 6d. 
13.  Anthony Miller—A blanket, 22s. 6d. 
14.  John Vincent—A blanket, 30s.  10 
15.  Solomon Jones—A blanket, 30s.  10 
16.  William Ingle—A blanket, 22s. 6d. 
17.  Nathan Foreman—A blanket, 22s. 6d. 
18.  Abraham Powell—A blanket, 37s. 6d.  17 
19.  Samuel Lowry—A blanket, 30s.  10 
20.  Samuel Johnston—A rifle-gun, £7 10s. shot pouch and
horn, 10s. blanket, 22s. 6d. 

We, the subscribers, do hereby certify that the within specified appraisements
are just and true, to the best of our judgments; and that the several
articles were lost in the late unhappy defeat near M'Mechen's narrows, on
the 27th of September, 1777—as witness our hands, this 3d of October, 1777.

(Signed), Anthony Miller, Lieutenant.
David Wilson, Ensign.
Sworn before me, David Shepherd."

280

Page 280

NOTE C.

"The undersigned, having been applied to for a statement of facts
respecting the memorable achievement at the attack on Fort Henry,
(Wheeling,) in September, 1782, known as the `Gunpowder exploit,' would
state as follows, viz.:

On Monday afternoon, September 11, 1782, a body of about 300 Indians,
and 50 British soldiers, composing part of a company known as the `Queen's
Rangers,' appeared in front of the fort, and demanded a surrender. These
forces were commanded respectively by the white renegade Girty, and a
Captain Pratt.

The demand for a surrender was of course uncomplied with, and the
attack then commenced.

During the forenoon of Tuesday, September 12th, the enemy having temporarily
withdrawn from the attack, but occupying a position within gunshot
of the fort, those within the stockade observed a female leave the
residence of Colonel Zane, and advance with rapid movements towards the
fort. She made for the southern gate, as it was less exposed to the fire of
the enemy. The gate was opened immediately, and she entered in safety
That person was none other than Molly Scott, and the object of her mission,
was to procure powder for those who defended the dwelling of Colonel Zane!
The undersigned was at that time in her 17th year, and remembers with
perfect distinctness every circumstance connected with the incident. She
saw Molly Scott enter the fort, assisted her in getting the powder, and
saw her leave, and avers most positively that she, and she alone, accomplished
the feat referred to, and deserves all the credit there may be attached
to it.

The ammunition at that time was kept in the `store-house,' adjoining
the residence of my father, known as the `Captain's house.' My father
having left for help on the commencement of the attack, and I being the
oldest child under the paternal roof, was directed by my mother to go with
the messenger (Molly Scott), to the store-house, and give her whatever
ammunition she needed. This the undersigned did, and will now state without
the fear of contradiction, that the powder was given to Molly Scott, and not
to Elizabeth Zane.

The undersigned assisted said Molly Scott in placing the powder in her apron,
and to this she is willing to be qualified at any time. * *

Elizabeth Zane, for whom has long been claimed the credit of this heroic
feat, was at that time at the residence of her father, near the present town
of Washington, Pa. * * * * * *

At the time of its occurrence, the achievement was not considered very


281

Page 281
extraordinary. Those were emphatically times when woman's heart was
nerved to deeds of no ordinary kind;—we all felt it was then `to do or die;'
and the undersigned does not hesitate to say, that more than one within the
little stockade at Wheeling, would have accomplished the feat with as much
credit as the one whose name seems destined to an immortality in border
warfare.

But undersigned does not wish to detract any from the heroism of that
feat, she only desires to correct a gross error—to give honor to whom honor
is due. This she deems imperative, that the truth and justice of history
may be maintained.

The undersigned disclaims all unkind feelings towards any one, in relation
to this statement. Elizabeth Zane was one of her earliest acquaintances,
whom she knew to be a woman brave, generous and single-hearted.

Given under my hand and seal, this 28th day of November, 1849.

Lydia S. Cruger.
[SEAL.]

NOTE E.

The names of those who were known to have been in the fort at the time,
we have with great pains collected, and give below. The list comprises
twenty-seven men and six boys. Of the men, not more than eighteen were
able to do efficient service; the balance were either disabled by injuries
sustained in warfare, or labored under autumnal fevers. Stephen Burkam,
Silas, Jonathan, and Andrew Zane; Copeland Sullivan, Jacob and George
Reikart; James Smith and his two sons, Henry and Thomas; Conrad Stroop,
John Tait,—Wright, old Mr. Mills, Edward Mills, and Thomas Mills,
Hamilton Kerr, Alexander M'Dowell, Harry Clark, James Saltar, James
Clark, Casper French, Conrad Wheat and four sons, James Boggs, (son of
Captain Boggs), Martin and George Kerr, Peter Nisewanger, and two men,
companions of Sullivan.

Two-thirds of the above persons had families in the fort. We cannot name
all the female soldiers of that little stockade, but trust we may not be considered
invidious for particularizing a few. There was Mrs. Ebenezer
Zane, a skilful nurse and courageous woman; the fort would have suffered
without her ministering and tender care to the sick and wounded. Next
was Betsy Wheat, an Amazon in strength, and a Lucretia in ferocity. Her
loud voice, and stern word of command, to those whom she thought laggard,
could be heard all over the fort. We have heard it said that the courage,
energy, and devotion of this woman, did more to encourage and revive the
drooping spirits of the despondent, than that of any other person. Next,
and not least, was Miss Lydia Boggs, now Mrs. Cruger.


282

Page 282

CHAPTER II.

1783.

MIRACULOUS ESCAPE.

One of the most remarkable escapes upon record, is that of
Thomas Mills. The circumstancese were these. On the 30th
day of July, Mills and two other men, Henry Smith and
Hambleton Kerr,[35] started on a fishing excursion up the river
from Wheeling. When near Glenn's run, a party of Indians,
who had watched the movements of the whites, fired upon
them, killing Smith, and wounding Mills in fourteen places.
He had that many distinct bullet-holes in him, and yet not
one of them was mortal. Kerr escaped. Just before the
attack, Mills and his companions had caught an enormous
cat-fish, (weighing 87 pounds,) and when the men were taken
from the canoe at Wheeling, their appearance was truly
frightful; they were literally covered with blood and sand.
Mills recovered from his wounds, and was recently living on
the Ohio, near Shade river. He was in his time, a most useful
man on the frontier, possessing great experience as a hunter
and scout.


283

Page 283

The men were gigging by torchlight, and thus became fair
objects for the aim of the savages.

In the summer of this year, John Nieswanger and Joseph
Heffler, two very efficient spies, started on a hunting expedition
down the Ohio. They were dressed in Indian fashion,
as was often the custom on such occasions, so as the better to
elude detection. They descended the river in a canoe, and
on the evening of the day they left, put into Little Grave
creek. A party of Indians had watched their movements,
and during the night attacked them with fury. Nieswanger
was killed, but his companion succeeded in getting off, with
the loss of two fingers. He escaped to Wheeling, and thence
went to Pittsburgh, to have an operation performed upon his
maimed hand. Returning, and when near the present residence
of Hamilton Woods, he was attacked and killed by the
Indians. While in pursuit of Heffler, at Grave creek, the
canoe floated off, and thus the savages lost the chance of
scalping the unfortunate Nieswanger. Some months afterwards
the canoe was found lodged at the head of Captina
Island, with the remains of the hunter and his gun still in it.

1784 was a year of comparative quiet on the frontier. The
teeaty of peace between the United States and Great Britain
had the effect to restrain the western Indians for the time
being.

 
[35]

Kerr was one of the most efficient spies west of the Ohio river. His
father was killed near the mouth of Duck creek, in the summer of 1791.
Two of his neighbors, who were passing down the river in a canoe, on the
Virginia side of the island, hearing the report of a gun, landed, and passed
over the island, where they saw two Indians going from the canoe, in which
Kerr lay, with the struggles of death still upon him. This murder of his
father greatly exasperated Hambleton, and thenceforward no Indian was
safe who crossed his path, whether in time of war or peace.

He settled at the mouth of a small stream, now known as Kerr's run, at
the upper end of the flourishing town of Pomeroy, Ohio.

1785.

CAPTIVITY OF MRS. CUNNINGHAM.

In the latter part of June, a small party of Indians visited
the house of Edward Cunningham, an enterprising settler on
Bingamon, a branch of West Fork. Thomas Cunningham, a
brother of Edward, lived in a house almost adjoining. The
two families affording thus protection one to the other. At
the time spoken of, Edward and his family were in one cabin,


284

Page 284
and the wife of Thomas, with her four children, (her husband
having gone east on a trading expedition) were in the other,
both families eating their dinners, when in stepped before the
astonished mother and children, a huge savage, with drawn
knife and uplifted tomahawk. Conscious of his security with
the mother and children, but fearing danger from Edward
Cunningham, who had seen him enter, the savage quickly
glanced around for some means of escape in an opposite
direction. Edward watched the movements of the savage
through an opening in the wall. In the other house was a
similar hole, (made to introduce light), and through it the
Indian fired, shouting the yell of victory. It was answered
by Edward, who had seen the aim of the savage just in time
to escape,—the bark from the log close to his head was
knocked off by the Indian's ball, and flew in his face. The
Indian seeing that he had missed his object, and observing
an adze in the room, deliberately commenced cutting an
aperture in the back wall, through which he might pass out,
without being exposed to a shot from the other building.

Another of the Indians came into the yard just after the
firing of his companion, but observing Edward's gun pointing
through the port hole, endeavored to retreat out of its range.
Just as he went to spring the fence, a ball struck him, and he
fell forward. It had, however, only fractured his thigh bone,
and he was yet able to get over the fence, and take shelter
behind a quilt suspended on it, before Edward could again load
his gun. Meantime the Indian in the house was engaged in
cutting a hole through the wall, during which Mrs. Cunningham
made no attempt to get out, well aware it would only
draw upon her head the fury of the savage; and that if she
escaped this one, she would most probably be killed by some
of those who were watching outside. She knew, too, it would
be impossible to take the children with her. She trusted to
hope that the one inside would withdraw without molesting
any of them. A few minutes served to convince her of the
hopeless folly of trusting to an Indian's mercy. When the


285

Page 285
opening had been made sufficiently large, the savage raised
his tomahawk, sunk it deep into the brains of one of the
children, and throwing the scarcely lifeless body into the back
yard, ordered the mother to follow him. There was no
alternative but death, and she obeyed his order, stepping over
the dead body of one of her children, with an infant in her
arms, and two others screaming by her side. When all were
out he scalped the murdered boy, and setting fire to the house,
retired to an eminence, where two of the savages were with
their wounded companion,—leaving the other two to watch
the opening of Edward Cunningham's door, when the burning
of the house should force the family from their shelter. They
were disappointed in their expectation of that event by the
exertions of Cunningham and his son. When the flame from
the one house communicated to the roof of the other, they
ascended to the loft, threw off the loose boards which covered
it, and extinguished the fire;—the savages shooting at them
all the while; their balls frequently striking close by.

Unable to force out the family of Edward Cunningham,
and despairing of doing further injury, they beat a speedy
retreat. Before leaving, however, the eldest son of Mrs.
Thomas Cunningham was tomahawked and scalped in presence
of the shuddering mother. Her little daughter was next
served in the same way; but, to make the scene still more
tragical, the child was dashed against a tree, and its brains
scattered about. The mother, during the whole of these
bloody acts, stood motionless in grief, and in momentary awe
of meeting a similar fate. But, alas, she was reserved for a
different, and, to a sensitive woman, a far more dreadful fate.
With her helpless babe she was led from this scene of carnage.
The savages carried their wounded companion upon a litter.
Crossing the ridge, they found a cave near Bingamon creek,
in which they secreted themselves until after night, when
some of the party returned to Edward Cunningham's, but not
finding any one at home, fired the house, and made a hasty
retreat towards their own country.


286

Page 286

Mrs. Cunningham suffered untold mental and physical
agony during her march to the Indian towns. For ten days
her only nourishment was the head of a wild turkey and a few
paw-paws. After a long absence she was returned to her
husband, through the intercession of Simon Girty, who ransomed
her, and sent her home. This one single act should
redeem his memory from a multitude of sins.

After the savages had withdrawn, Cunningham went with
his family into the woods, where they remained all night, there
being no settlement nearer than ten miles. In the morning the
alarm was given, and a company of men soon collected to go
in pursuit of the Indians. When they came to Cunningham's,
and found both houses heaps of ashes, they buried the bones
of the boy who was murdered in the house, with the bodies of
his brother and little sister, who were killed in the field; but
so cautiously had the savages conducted their retreat, that no
traces of them could be discovered, and the men returned to
their homes.

Subsequently, a second party started in pursuit, and traced
them to the cave; but it was found the enemy had left the
night previous, and all hope of effecting a successful pursuit
was given over. After her return from captivity, Mrs. Cunningham
stated, that at the time of the search on the first day,
the Indians were in the cave, and that several times the whites
approached so near, that she could distinctly hear their voices;
the savages standing with their guns ready to fire, in the
event of being discovered, and forcing her to keep the infant
to her breast, lest its cry might indicate their place of concealment.

CAPTIVITY OF TWO BOYS.

In the spring of this year, the Indians early re-appeared
in the neighborhood of Wheeling. One of their first acts on
Wheeling creek, was the captivity of two boys, John Wetzel,


287

Page 287
Jr., and Frederick Erlewyne, the former about sixteen years
of age, and the latter a year or two younger. The boys had
gone from the fort at Shepherd's, for the purpose of catching
horses. One of the stray animals was a mare, with a
young colt, belonging to Wetzel's sister, and she had offered
the foal to John, says the account which we follow, as a
reward for finding the mare. While on this service, they
were captured by a party of four Indians, who, having come
across the horses, had seized and secured them in a thicket,
expecting the bells would attract the notice of their owners,
as they could kill them. The horse was ever a favorite object
of plunder with the savages; as not only facilitating his own
escape from pursuit, but also assisting him in carrying off the
spoil. The boys, hearing the well-known tinkle of the bells,
approached the spot where the Indians lay concealed, congratulating
themselves on their good luck in so readily finding
the strays, when they were immediately seized by the savages.
John, in attempting to escape, was shot through the wrist.
His companion hesitating to go with the Indians, and beginning
to cry, they dispatched him with the tomahawk. John,
who had once before been taken prisoner and escaped, made
light of it, and went along cheerfully with his wounded arm.

The party struck the Ohio river early the following morning,
at a point near the mouth of Grave creek, and just below
the clearing of Mr. Tomlinson.[36] Here they found some hogs,
and killing one of them, put it into a canoe they had stolen.
Three of the Indians took possession of the canoe with
their prisoner, while the other was busied in swimming the
horses across the river. It so happened that Isaac Williams,[37]
Hambleton Kerr, and Jacob, a Dutchman, had come
down that morning from Wheeling, to look after the cattle,
etc., left at the deserted settlement. When near the mouth


288

Page 288
of Little Grave creek, a mile above, they heard the report of
a rifle. "Dod rot 'em," exclaimed Mr. Williams, "a Kentuck
boat has landed at the creck, and they are shooting my
hogs." Quickening their pace, in a few minutes they were
within a short distance of the creek, when they heard the loud
snort of a horse. Kerr being in the prime of life, and younger
than Mr. Williams, was several rods ahead, and reached the
bank first. As he looked into the creek, he saw three Indians
standing in a canoe; one was in the stern, one in the bow,
and the other in the middle. At the feet of the latter, lay
four rifles and a dead hog; while a fourth Indian was swimming
a horse, a few rods from shore. The one in the stern
had his paddle in the edge of the water in the act of turning
and shoving the canoe from the mouth of the creek into the
river. Before they were aware of his presence, Kerr drew up
and shot the Indian in the stern, who instantly fell into the
water. The crack of his rifle had scarcely ceased, when Mr.
Williams came up and shot the one in the bow, who also fell
overboard. Kerr dropped his own rifle, and seizing that of
the Dutchman, shot the remaining Indian. He fell over into
the water, but still held on to the side of the canoe with one
hand. So amazed was the last Indian at the fall of his companions,
that he never offered to lift one of the rifles which
lay at his feet in self-defence, but acted like one bereft of his
senses. By this time the canoe, impelled by the impetus
given to it by the first Indian, had reached the current of the
river, and was some rods below the mouth of the creek. Kerr
instantly reloaded his gun, and seeing another man lying in
the bottom of the canoe, raised it to his face as in the act of
firing, when he cried out, "Don't shoot, I am a white man!"
Kerr told him to knock loose the Indian's hand from the side
of the canoe, and paddle to the shore. In reply he said his
arm was broken and he could not. The current, however,
set it near some rocks not far from land, on which he jumped
and waded out. Kerr now aimed his rifle at the Indian on horseback,
who by this time had reached the middle of the river.

289

Page 289
The shot struck near him, splashing the water on his naked
skin. The Indian seeing the fate of his companions, with the
utmost bravery, slipped from the horse, and swam for the
canoe, in which were the rifles of the four warriors. This
was an act of necessity, as well of daring, for he well knew
he could not reach home without the means of killing game.
He soon gained possession of the canoe, unmolested, crossed
with the arms to his own side of the Ohio, mounted the captive
horse, which had swam to the Indian shore, and with a
yell of defiance escaped into the woods. The canoe was
turned adrift to spite his enemies, and was taken up near
Maysville with the dead hog still in it, the cause of all their
misfortunes.

 
[36]

Mr. Tomlinson and family were at that time in the fort at Wheeling.

[37]

Isaac Williams was the son-in-law of Mr. Tomlinson, and afterwards
settled opposite Marietta.

THE DOOLIN MURDER.

Edward Doolin was one of the earliest settlers near the
mouth of Fishing creek. He improved the farm now partly
owned by Samuel McEldowney, about one mile above New
Martinsville, Virginia.[38] Most of the settlers on Fishing creek
had, on the opening of spring, moved into Tomlinson's fort;
but Doolin, not apprehending danger, refused to go. The
circumstances of this murder are thus given by General Butler,
who was one of the Commissioners appointed to hold
treaties with the northern and western Indians. His Journal,
from which we extract, was kept during his visit to the
Miami, in 1785:

"I saw one Irvine, who had come from Cumberland river
in a boat; he arrived at Fort McIntosh just the evening before
I set out. He says he met General Clark below Sciota
a small distance, the 13th inst., on his way to the falls of the
Ohio. He says he met with the wife of one Doolin, whose
husband and two children were murdered by the Indians on
Fish creek, on the 20th instant. Their conduct was very


290

Page 290
extraordinary. They came to the door and knocked, very
early in the morning; the man rose out of bed and was shot
through the door, which broke his thigh; on his falling, the
door was broke in by the Indians, who tomahawked him and
two children; the woman in fright lay still. They told her
not to be uneasy, that they would not hurt her or the child
she had in her arms, and desired she would not leave the
house, as they would soon be back again, but did not intend
to injure her; that they were Cherokees, and would never
make peace. She asked why they troubled her, that the
Indians had made peace with General Clark last fall; they
said, not they; that if they could meet General Clark they
would kill him also. He says he does not think the Indians
mean to do any mischief generally, that it is a few banditti,
who are a collection of Cherokees, Shawanese, etc."

Mrs. Doolin afterwards married Edmund Martin, and
moved with her husband to Kentucky.

 
[38]

The place is still discernible where this cabin stood, also the spring near
at hand, which is still called Doolin's spring.

CAPTIVITY OF MRS. FRANCES SCOTT.

Mr. Scott, a citizen of Washington county, Virginia, had
his house attacked on Wednesday night, June 29th, 1785,
and himself, with four children, butchered upon the spot.

Early in the evening, a considerable body of Indians passed
his house and encamped within a couple of miles. Himself
and family had retired, with the exception of Mrs. Scott,
who was in the act of undressing, when the painted savages
rushed in, and commenced the work of death. "Mr. Scott,
being awake, jumped up, but was immediately fired at: he
forced his way through the midst of the enemy and got out
of the door, but fell. An Indian seized Mrs. Scott, and
ordered her to a particular spot, and not to move: others
stabbed and cut the throats of the three younger children
in their bed, and afterwards lifting them up, dashed them
upon the floor, near the mother; the eldest, a beautiful


291

Page 291
girl of eight years old, awoke, escaped out of the bed, ran to
her parent, and, with the most plaintive accents, cried, `O
mamma! mamma! save me!' The mother, in the deepest
anguish of spirit, and with a flood of tears, entreated the
savages to spare her child; but with a brutal fierceness, they
tomahawked and stabbed her in the mother's arms. Adjacent
to Mr. Scott's dwelling house another family lived, of the
name of Ball. The Indians attacked them at the same time;
but the door being shut, the enemy fired into the house
through an opening between two logs, and killed a young
lad; they then tried to force the door, but a surviving brother
fired through and drove them off; the remaining part of the
family ran out of the house and escaped. In Mr. Scott's
house were four good rifles, well loaded, and a good deal of
clothing and furniture, part of which belonged to people
that had left it on their way to Kentucky. The Indians,
being thirteen in number, loaded themselves with the plunder,
then speedily made off, and continued travelling all night.
Next morning their chief allotted to each man his share; and
detached nine of the party to steal horses from the inhabitants
on Clinch river. The eleventh day after Mrs. Scott's
captivity, the four Indians who had her in charge, stopped at
a place of rendezvous to hunt. Three went out, and the
chief, being an old man, was left to take care of the prisoner,
who, by this time, expressed a willingness to proceed to the
Indian towns, which seemed to have the desired effect of
lessening her keeper's vigilance. In the day time, as the old
man was graning a deer skin, the captive, pondering on her
situation, and anxiously looking for an opportunity to make
her escape, took the resolution, and went to the Indian carelessly,
asked liberty to go a small distance to a stream of
water, to wash the blood off her apron, that had remained
besmeared since the fatal night of the murder of her little
daughter. He told her, in the English tongue `Go along!'
she then passed by him, his face being in a contrary direction
from that she was going, and he very busy. After getting to

292

Page 292
the water, she went on without delay towards a high, barren
mountain, and travelled until late in the evening, when she
came down into the valley, in search of the track she had
been taken along; hoping thereby to find the way back,
without the risk of being lost, and perishing with hunger in
uninhabited parts.1

"That night she made herself a bed with leaves, and the
next day resumed her wanderings. Thus did that poor woman
continue from day to day, and week to week, wandering
in the trackless wilderness. Finally, on the 11th of August,
she reached a settlement on Clinch river, known as New
Garden.

"Mrs. Scott related, that during her wandering from the
tenth of July to the eleventh of August, she had no other
subsistence but chewing and swallowing the juice of young
cane, sassafras, and some plants she did not know the names
of; that, on her journey, she saw buffaloes, elk, deer, and
frequently bears and wolves, not one of which, although some
passed very near, offered to do her the least harm. One
day a bear came near her, with a young fawn in his mouth,
and, on discovering her, he dropped his prey and ran off.
Hunger prompted her to try and eat the flesh; but, on reflection,
she desisted, thinking that the bear might return
and devour her: besides, she had an aversion to raw meat.

"Mrs. Scott long continued in a low state of health, and
remained inconsolable at the loss of her family, particularly
bewailing the cruel death of her little daughter."

MURDER OF TWO SISTERS.

Next to the Tush murder, perhaps the most melancholy
occurrence on Wheeling creek, was that of two sisters—the
Misses Crow. The parents of these girls lived about one mile
above the mouth of Dunkard, or lower fork of the creek.


293

Page 293
According to the statement of a third sister,[39] who was an eyewitness
to the horrid tragedy, and herself almost a victim,
the three left their parents' house for an evening walk along
the deeply shaded banks of that beautiful stream. Their walk
extended over a mile, and they were just turning back, when
suddenly, several Indians sprung from behind a ledge of rock,
and seized all three of the sisters. With scarcely a moment's
interruption, the savages led the captives a short distance up
a small bank, when a halt was called, and a parley took place.
It seems that some of the Indians were in favor of immediate
slaughter, while others were disposed to carry them into
permanent captivity. Unfortunately, the arm of mercy was
powerless. Without a moment's warning, a fierce-looking
savage stepped from the group with elevated tomahawk, and
commenced the work of death. This Indian, in the language
of the surviving sister, "Began to tomahawk one of my
sisters—Susan by name. Susan dodged her head to one
side, the tomahawk taking effect in her neck, cutting the
large neck vein, [jugular] the blood gushing out a yard's
length. The Indian who had her by the hand, jumped back
to avoid the blood. The other Indian then began the work
of death on my sister Mary. I gave a sudden jerk and got
loose from the one that held me, and ran with all speed, and
took up a steep bank, gained the top safe—(but just as I
caught hold of a bush to help myself up, the Indian fired, and
the ball passed through the clump of hair on my head, slightly
breaking the skin;) the Indian taking round, in order to meet
me as I would strike the path that led homeward. But I ran
right from home, and hid myself in the bushes, near the top
of the hill. Presently I saw an Indian passing along the
hill below me; I lay still until he was out of sight; I then
made for home."[40]

 
[39]

Christina, now Mrs. John McBride, of Carlisle, Monroe Co., Ohio.

[40]

MSS. letter of Colonel Bonnett, who visited this lady in the fall of '46.


294

Page 294

1786.

In the autumn of this year, James Snodgrass and John
Ice were killed while looking for their horses, which had
strayed from their owners when on a buffalo hunt on Fishing
creek.

A few days subsequent to this occurrence, a party of Indians
came to Buffalo creek, and meeting Mrs. Dragoo and her son
in a field gathering beans, took them prisoners, and supposing
that their detention would induce others to look for them,
waylaid the path leading from the house. "According to
expectation, uneasy at their continued absence, Jacob Strait
and Nicholas Wood went to ascertain the cause. As they
approached, the Indians fired, and Wood fell. Strait taking
to flight, was soon overtaken. Mrs. Strait and her daughter,
hearing the firing and seeing the savages in pursuit of Mr.
Strait, betook themselves also to flight, but were discovered
by some of the Indians, who immediately ran after them.
The daughter concealed herself in a thicket and escaped.
Her mother sought concealment under a large shelving rock,
and was not afterwards discovered, although those in pursuit
of her husband, passed near and overtook him not far off.
Indeed she was at that time so close as to hear Mr. Strait
say, when overtaken, `Don't kill me, and I will go with you;'
and the savage replying, `Will you go with me?' she heard
the fatal blow which deprived her husband of life.

"Mrs. Dragoo being infirm and unable to travel to their
towns, was murdered on the way. Her son (a lad of seven)
remained with the Indians upwards of twenty years,—he
married a squaw, by whom he had four children, two of whom
he brought home with him, when he forsook the Indians."


295

Page 295

1787.

THE BEVANS' MURDER.

Clark's block-house[41] was, in July of this year, the scene
of a painful occurrence. Of those who had resorted there,
was a family by the name of Bevans, embracing six members
in all, two sons and two daughters. Not apprehending danger,
these four visited, on the occasion referred to, their farm,
which was within a mile of the fort, for the purpose of pulling
flax. Reaching the field, they all seated themselves upon the
fence and were looking at the flax, when the Indians fired
upon them. John, one of the sons, received a ball through his
body, but not so as to disable him from running for the blockhouse.
An Indian followed close in pursuit, but the unfortunate
young man kept ahead until within sight of the blockhouse,
when he sunk down dead. The Indian had just given
up the chase, as he saw him fall. Cornelius, the other brother,
ran a different direction, with an Indian after him, tomahawk
in hand. The little fellow ran down a steep hill, leaping over
a large prostrate tree, in the top of which he hid himself. The
two girls were tomahawked and scalped, and both found lying
together. They were buried on the spot and in the same grave.

Clark told Rodefer that he saw John Bevans fall over the
fence a short distance below the fort. One of the daughters
was married, and an additional account says, that her husband,
James Anderson, was with her and was killed.

 
[41]

This structure occupied a commanding position on the farm now owned
by John Allen, Esq., near Pleasant Hill church, Marshall county, Va. Mr.
Rodefer, from whom we have derived many interesting facts, says he was
frequently at the block-house referred to, and was intimately acquainted
with Harry Clark, the founder. He describes this rude frontier post, as
composed of four cabins, placed close together, and defended by a row of
pickets ten feet in height.


296

Page 296

FEMALE HEROISM.

The women of the west were Spartans in every sense of
the word. They possessed in a remarkable degree a union of
strength, courage, love, devotion, simplicity and shrewdness
which well fitted them for the severe and often terrible trials
through which they had to pass. These noble qualities, called
forth, perhaps, by the circumstances with which they were
surrounded, distinguished the women of the heroic age of the
west. Disregarding danger, and alone devoted to the safety of
her little household, the western mother nerved her arm and
steeled her heart to the severe duties which surrounded her.

A young girl braves the danger of an Indian army, and
rushes forth from a place of safety to procure the means of
defending those whom she loves more tenderly than life.
Another bares her breast to the knife of the savage rather
than disclose the hiding place of her friends; while yet another
throws herself upon the person of her father, to receive the
impending blow of the uplifted tomahawk.

Again, the fond wife, who has seen her husband shot dead
by a rifle levelled over her own shoulders, watches over his
blood-stained corpse, in her desolate home, surrounded by
fierce savages, rather than attempt to escape and leave his
precious remains subject to farther outrage. Such were the
women of the west—the hero-mothers of the Revolution.

The case of our Virginia matron, which should have been
noticed in its appropriate chronological order, will now be given.

On Dunkard creek, now within the limits of Monongalia
county, lived a Mr. Bozarth, his wife, and three children.

The alarm which had caused the settlers to resort to Prickett's
fort, (elsewhere noticed), induced two or three families
living convenient to Mr. Bozarth, to collect at his house.


297

Page 297
About the 1st of April, (1789), when but two men were in the
house, with Mrs. Bozarth, the children, who had been out
playing, ran suddenly in, crying that "Indians were coming!"

In order to ascertain the true cause of this alarm, one of
the men stepped to the door and was struck upon the breast
with a rifle ball, which knocked him back into the house. A
savage sprung in after him and attacked the other white man
with all the fury of his nature. The man being unarmed,
called for a knife, but Mrs. Bozarth not seeing one at the
instant, picked up an axe, and killed the savage on the spot.
While the courageous woman was thus engaged, a second
Indian presented himself at the door, and firing, killed the
man who had been struggling with his companion. Quick as
thought, the intrepid matron turned upon this new comer, and
at one blow ripped open his abdomen, causing the savage to
yell most lustily for help. Immediately, several of his companions
rushed to the rescue, but the invincible woman was
ready for them. The first who attempted to enter was struck
upon the head, and his skull cleft, making the third victim to
the axe of this Virginia Amazon. The others having drawn
out the wounded savage, and learning the strength of the
house, attempted to force the door, but Mrs. Bozarth had so
securely fastened it, as to defy all their efforts. The savages
then killed the children in the yard and made off.

In connection with this, and as illustrative of our subject,
we will give one more case, which, although not occurring
within the present limits of our state, was, at the time the
transaction took place, strictly a part of Virginia.

"During the summer of this year, the house of Mr. John
Merrill, of Nelson county, Ky., was attacked by Indians,
and defended with singular address and good fortune. Merril
was alarmed by the barking of a dog about midnight, and
upon opening the door in order to ascertain the cause of the
disturbance, received the fire of six or seven Indians, by
which his arm and thigh were both broken. He instantly
sunk upon the floor and called upon his wife to close the door.


298

Page 298
This had scarcely been done, when it was violently assailed
by the tomahawks of the enemy, and a large breach soon
effected. Mrs. Merrill, being a large woman, possessing both
strength and courage, guarded the door with an axe, and
successively killed or badly wounded four of the enemy as
they attempted to force their way into the cabin.

"The Indians then ascended the roof and attempted to enter
by way of the chimney, but here again they were met by the
same determined enemy. Mrs. Merrill seized the only feather
bed which the cabin afforded, and hastily ripping it open,
poured its contents upon the fire. A furious blaze and stifling
smoke instantly ascended the chimney, and brought down two
of the enemy, who in a few moments were at the mercy of the
woman. Seizing the axe, she quickly dispatched them, and
was instantly afterwards summoned to the door, where the
only remaining savage now appeared, endeavoring to effect an
entrance, while Mrs. Merrill was engaged at the chimney. He
soon received a gash on the cheek, which compelled him, with
a loud yell, to relinquish his purpose, and return hastily to
Chillicothe, where, from the report of a prisoner, he gave an
exaggerated account of the fierceness, strength, and courage
of the "Long-knife squaw!' "

THE BECHAM MURDER.

Of those who settled on Little Wheeling, after the cessation
of hostilities in 1783, was a family named Becham. They
lived near what is now known as the Scotch ridge. In
October, 1787,[42] two of the sons of Mr. Becham left home to
hunt their horses, and look for bee trees. They had not gone
far before a small party of Indians fell upon them, and took


299

Page 299
them prisoners. The Indians had caught one of the horses
and tied him to a tree, and when the boys approached they
were made captives without any resistance. The Indians
then caught another horse, and placing a boy each before
them, rode off. They made for the Ohio at Grave creek.
That night they encamped about four miles from the river,
and after securing their prisoners, fell asleep. During the
night, something caused them to believe they were pursued;
and without a moment's hesitation tomahawked and scalped
the unfortunate prisoners, and then made off as speedily as
possible. Happily, in the hurry and confusion of the moment,
they did not do up the work of death in an effective
manner, as neither boy was killed, and the eldest but slightly
injured, saving the loss of his scalp. Thomas sat by the side
of his brother for some time, but finding his head bleeding
freely, took from the Indian's plunder a check apron,[43] and
tied it around his head. Deeming it imprudent to remain
there, Thomas took some of the plunder, among which were
a few pewter spoons, and mounting one of the horses,
rode off for help. He travelled about three miles down
Grave creek, where he left the horse, and proceeded on foot
to the Flats. He went directly to the house of Mr. Masters,

300

Page 300
father of Dr. Z. Masters, living at that time on the farm now
owned by Mr. Lewis D. Purdy, where his wound was dressed,
and himself taken care of. A party went out on the morning
to look for the other boy, but the savages had been back and
made fatal work. It was supposed they had waited at
some convenient point of observation until daylight, and discovering
no pursuing party, returned to camp and dispatched
the poor boy who had still survived. Thomas lived to a good
old age, and for many years resided in Belmont county, Ohio.

The Indians engaged in this expedition returned to the
neighborhood of West Alexandria, and killed a Scotch woman,
also a man named Ageo. They then escaped to the Ohio,
and crossed near Yellow creek. Ageo was killed in going to
the fort, after the murder of the woman referred to. He was
shot from his horse.

 
[42]

To show the great difficulty we have had in establishing dates, this single
case comes to us, sustained by the strongest living evidence, that it occurred
in years widely apart. One party contends that it took place in 1790;
another, in 1793, and again in 1787. We have adopted that of Mr. Darby,
corroborated by Col. Bonnett. (See Darby's letter, A. end of present chapter.)

[43]

This apron has been productive of much mischief, by confounding facts,
and dates, and thus confusing the historian. Mrs. Cruger is positive that it
belonged to Mrs. Tush, who was not killed until '93. Colonel Bonnett, on the
other hand, is confident that this affair took place in '87; and is of the opinion
that the apron may have belonged to Mary Bevans, whose death, with that of
her sister and brother, we have just recorded. Hear what he says. We deem it
necessary to give this extract, as other writers, who have been misled as to
facts, may attempt to fix the date at a later period.

Colonel B., after speaking of the murder of the Bevans, at Clark's blockhouse,
adds:—

"Soon after, or early in August, 1787, the Becham boys met their fate.
The check apron alluded to in your letter, belonged to Mary Bevans, or perhaps
it might have belonged to Mary Crow, a young woman killed along with her
sister, about the same time. Be this as it may, one thing is certain, the
check apron belonged to one of the girls alluded to, and therefore could not
have been so late as the murder of George Tush's family." (MSS. letter of
Colonel Lewis Bonnett.)

1788.

THE JOHNSON BOYS.

All who have read anything of western history, will
remember the thrilling feat of the two Johnson boys. As
many very contradictory accounts have been given of that
occurrence, which so links their name with the heroic age of
the west, we were anxious to procure the full facts, and for
this purpose consulted the surviving brother, now a hale old
man of seventy-four, living in Monroe county, Ohio. In
answer to our inquiry, he has written out a detailed statement
of the whole transaction, which it affords us sincere
pleasure to herewith submit:

Dear Sir:

Yours of the 8th instant has just come to
hand, and I with pleasure sit down to answer your request,
which is a statement of my adventure with the Indians. I


301

Page 301
will give the narrative as found in my sketch book. I was
born in Westmoreland county, Pennsylvania, February 4th,
1777. When about eight years old, my father, James Johnson,
having a large family to provide for, sold his farm, with
the expectation of acquiring larger possessions further west.
Thus he was stimulated to encounter the perils of a pioneer
life. He crossed the Ohio river, and bought some improvements
on what was called Beach Bottom Flats, two and a
half miles from the river, and three or four miles above the
mouth of Short creek, with the expectation of holding by
improvement right under the Virginia claim. Soon after we
reached there, the Indians became troublesome; they stole
horses, and killed a number of persons in our neighborhood.
When I was between eleven and twelve years old, in the
month of October, 1788, I was taken prisoner by the Indians,
with my brother John, who was about eighteen months older
than I. The circumstances were as follows:—On Saturday
evening, we were out with an older brother, and came home
late in the evening. The next morning one of us had lost a
hat, and about the middle of the day, we thought that perhaps
we had left it where we had been at work, about three-fourths
of a mile from the house. We went to the place and
found the hat, and sat down on a log by the road-side, and
commenced cracking nuts. In a short time we saw two men
coming toward us from the house. By their dress, we supposed
they were two of our neighbors, James Perdue and
J. Russell. We paid but little attention to them, until they
came quite near us, when we saw our mistake; they were
black. To escape by flight was impossible, had we been disposed
to try. We sat still until they came up. One of
them said, "How do, brodder?" My brother asked them if
they were Indians, and they answered in the affirmative, and
said we must go with them. One of them had a blue buckskin
pouch, which we gave my brother to carry, and without
further ceremony, he took up the line of march for the
wilderness, not knowing whether we should ever return to

302

Page 302
our cheerful home; and not having much love for our commanding
officers, of course we obeyed orders rather tardily.
The mode of march was thus—one of the Indians walked
about ten steps before, the other about ten behind us. After
travelling some distance, we halted in a deep hollow and sat
down. They took out their knives and whet them, and talked
some time in the Indian tongue, which we could not understand.
My brother and me sat eight or ten steps from them,
and talked about killing them that night, and make our
escape. I thought, from their looks and actions, that they
were going to kill us; and, strange to say, I felt no alarm.
I thought I would rather die than go with them. The most
of my trouble was, that my father and mother would be fretting
after us—not knowing what had become of us. I expressed
my thoughts to John, who went and began to talk
with them. He said that father was cross to him, and made
him work hard, and that he did not like hard work; that he
would rather be a hunter, and live in the woods. This seemed
to please them; for they put up their knives, and talked more
lively and pleasantly. We became very familiar, and many
questions passed between us; all parties were very inquisitive.
They asked my brother which way home was, several
times, and he would tell them the contrary way every time,
although he knew the way very well. This would make them
laugh; they thought we were lost, and that we knew no better.
They conducted us over the Short creek hills in search
of horses, but found none; so we continued on foot until
night, when we halted in a hollow, about three miles from
Carpenter's fort, and about four from the place where they
first took us; our route being somewhat circuitous, we made
but slow progress. As night began to close in, I became
fretful. My brother encouraged me, by whispering that
we would kill them that night. After they had selected
the place of our encampment, one of them scouted round,
whilst the other struck fire, which was done by stopping the
touch-hole of his gun, and flashing powder in the pan. After

303

Page 303
the Indian got the fire kindled, he re-primed the gun and
went to an old stump, to get some tinder wood, and while he
was thus employed, my brother John took the gun, cocked it,
and was about to shoot the Indian: alarmed lest the other
might be close by, I remonstrated, and taking hold of the
gun, prevented him shooting; at the same time I begged him
to wait till night, and I would help him kill them both.
The other Indian came back about dark, when we took our
supper, such as it was,—some corn parched on the coals, and
some roasted pork. We then sat and talked for some time.
They seemed to be acquainted with the whole border settlement,
from Marietta to Beaver, and could number every
fort and block-house, and asked my brother how many fighting
men there were in each place, and how many guns. In
some places, my brother said, there were a good many more
guns than there were fighting men. They asked what use
were these guns. He said the women could load while the
men fired. But how did these guns get there? My brother
said, when the war was over with Great Britain, the soldiers
that were enlisted during the war were discharged, and they
left a great many of their guns at the stations. They asked
my brother who owned that black horse that wore a bell? He
answered, father. They then said the Indians could never
catch that horse. We then went to bed on the naked ground,
to rest and study out the best mode of attack. They put us
between them, that they might be the better able to guard us.
After awhile, one of the Indians, supposing we were asleep,
got up and stretched himself on the other side of the fire, and
soon began to snore. John, who had been watching every
motion, found they were sound asleep. He whispered to me
to get up, which we did as carefully as possible. John took
the gun with which the Indian had struck fire, cocked it, and
placed it in the direction of the head of one of the Indians.
He then took a tomahawk, and drew it over the head of the
other Indian. I pulled the trigger, and he struck at the same
instant; the blow falling too far back on the neck, only

304

Page 304
stunned the Indian. He attempted to spring to his feet,
uttering most hideous yells, but my brother repeated the
blows with such effect that the conflict became terrible, and
somewhat doubtful. The Indian, however, was forced to
yield to the blows he received on his head, and in a short
time he lay quiet at our feet. The one that was shot never
moved; and fearing there were others close by, we hurried
off, and took nothing with us but the gun I shot with. They
had told us we would see Indians about to-morrow, so we
thought that there was a camp of Indians close by; and fearing
the report of the gun, the Indian hallooing, and I calling
to John, might bring them upon us, we took our course
towards the river, and on going about three-fourths of a mile,
came to a path which led to Carpenter's fort. My brother
here hung up his hat, that he might know where to take
off to find the camp. We got to the fort a little before daybreak.
We related our adventure, and the next day a small
party went out with my brother, and found the Indian that
was tomahawked, on the ground; the other had crawled off,
and was not found till some time after. He was shot through
close by the ear. Having concluded this narrative, I will give
a description of the two Indians. They were of the Delaware
tribe, and one of them a chief. He wore the badges of his
office—the wampum belt, three half-moons, and a silver plate
on his breast; bands of silver on both arms, and his ears cut
round and ornamented with silver; the hair on the top of his
head was done up with silver wire. The other Indian seemed
to be a kind of waiter. He was rather under size, a plain
man. He wore a fine beaver hat, with a hole shot through
the crown. My brother asked him about the hat. He said
he killed a captain and got his hat. My brother asked him
if he had killed many of the whites, and he answered, a good
many. He then asked him if the big Indian had killed many
of the whites, and he answered, a great many, and that he
was a great captain—a chief. * * * * *

[Signed] Henry Johnson.

305

Page 305

In connection with the above, and to still further show of
what material the boys were made, in the great heroic age of
the west, we give the following, which we find in a recent
communication from Major Nye, of Ohio. The scene of
adventure was within the present limits of Wood county,
Virginia.

"I have heard from Mr. Guthrie, and others, that at Bellville
a man had a son, quite a youth, say twelve or fourteen years
of age, who had been used to firing his father's gun, as most
boys did in those days. He heard, he supposed, turkeys on
or near the bank of the Ohio, opposite that place, and asked
his father to let him take the gun, and kill one. His father,
knowing that the Indians frequently decoyed people by such
noises, refused, saying it was probably an Indian. When he
had gone to work, the boy took the gun and paddled his
canoe over the river, but had the precaution to land some
distance from where he had heard the turkey all the morning,
probably for fear of scaring the game, and perhaps a little
afraid of Indians. The banks were steep, and the boy cautiously
advanced to where he could see without being seen.
Watching awhile for his game, he happened to see an Indian
cautiously looking over a log, to notice where the boy had
landed. The lad fixed his gun at a rest, watching the
place where he had seen the Indian's head, and when it
appeared again, fired, and the Indian disappeared. The boy
dropped the gun and ran for his canoe, which he paddled over
the river as soon as possible. When he reached home, he
said, `Mother, I killed an Indian!' and the mother replied,
`No, you have not.' `Yes, I have,' said the boy. The
father coming in, he made the same report to him, and received
the same reply; but he constantly affirmed it was even so;
and, as the gun was left, a party took the boy over the river
to find it, and show the place where he shot the Indian,
and behold, his words were found verified. The ball had
entered the head, where the boy had affirmed he shot, between
the eye and ear."


306

Page 306

Such "boys" made the men of the Republic in after
years—men whom neither tyranny nor oppression could
subdue.

CAPTIVITY OF MRS. GLASS.

Early on the morning of the 27th of March, two Indians
appeared on the premises of Mr. Glass, residing a few miles
back of the present town of Wellsburgh. At the time, Mrs. G.
was alone in her house, with the exception of an infant and a
small black girl. Mrs. Glass was spinning, and had sent her
negro woman to the woods for sugar water. In a few moments
she returned, screaming at the top of her voice, "Indians!
Indians!" Mrs. Glass jumped up, and running, first to the
window, then to the door, attempted to escape. But an Indian
met her, and presented his gun; Mrs. Glass caught hold of
the muzzle, turned it aside, and begged him not to kill her.
The other Indian, in the meantime, caught the negro woman,
and brought her into the house. They then opened a chest
and took out a small box and some articles of clothing, and
without doing any further damage, departed with their
prisoners. After proceeding about a mile and a half, they
halted, and held a consultation, as she supposed, to kill the
children. This she understood to be the subject by their
gestures. To one of the Indians, who could speak English,
she held out her little boy, and begged not to kill him, as
he would make a fine chief after awhile. The Indian made a
motion for her to walk on with her child. The other Indian
then struck the negro child with the pipe end of his tomahawk,
which knocked it down, and then, by a blow with the
edge, across the back of the neck, dispatched it.

"About four o'clock in the evening they reached the river,
a mile above the creek, and carried a canoe, which had been
thrown up in some drift wood, into the river. They got into
this canoe, and worked it down to the mouth of Rush run, a


307

Page 307
distance of about five miles. They pulled the canoe into the
mouth of the stream, as far as they could; going up the run
about a mile, encamped for the night. The Indians gave the
prisoners all their own clothes for covering, and one of them
added his own blanket. Shortly before daylight the Indians
got up, and put another blanket over them. The black
woman complained much on account of the loss of her child,
and they threatened, if she did not desist, to kill her.

"About sunrise they commenced their march, up a very steep
hill, and at two o'clock halted on Short creek, about twenty
miles from the place whence they set out in the morning.
The spot had been an encampment shortly before, as well as a
place of deposite for the plunder, which they had recently taken
from the house of a Mr. Vanmeter, whose family had been killed.
The plunder was deposited in a sycamore tree. They had
tapped some sugar trees when there before, and now kindled
a fire, and put on a brass kettle, with a turkey, which they had
killed on the way, to boil in sugar water.

"Mr. Glass was working, with a hired man in a field, about
a quarter of a mile from the house, when his wife and family
were taken, but knew nothing of the event until noon. After
searching about the place, and going to several houses in quest
of his family, he went to Wells' fort, collected ten men, and
that night lodged in a cabin, on the bottom on which the town
of Wellsburg now stands.

"Next morning they discovered the place where the Indians
had taken the canoe from the drift, and their tracks at the
place of embarkation. Mr. Glass could distinguish the
track of his wife by the print of the high heel of her shoe.
They crossed over the river, and went down on the other
side, until they came near the mouth of Rush run; but discovering
no tracks of the Indians, most of the men concluded
that they would go to the mouth of the Muskingum, by water,
and therefore wished to turn back. Mr. Glass begged of them
to go as far as the mouth of Short creek, which was only two
or three miles. To this they agreed. When they got to the


308

Page 308
mouth of Rush run, they found the canoe of the Indians.
This was identified by a proof, which goes to show the presence
of mind of Mrs. Glass. While passing down the river, one of
the Indians threw into the water several papers, which he
had taken out of Mr. Glass' trunk; some of these she carelessly
picked up, and under pretence of giving them to the
child, dropped them into the bottom of the canoe. These left
no doubt. The trail of the Indians, and their prisoners, up
the run to their camp, and then up the river hill, was soon
discovered.

"About an hour after the Indians had halted, Mr. Glass and
his men came within sight of their camp. The object then
was to save the lives of the prisoners, by attacking the Indians
so unexpectedly, as not to allow time to kill them. With this
view, they crept along until they got within one hundred
yards of the camp. Fortunately, Mrs. Glass' little son had
gone to a sugar-tree, but not being able to get the water, his
mother had stepped out to get it for him. The negro woman
was sitting some distance from the two Indians, who were
looking attentively at a scarlet jacket, which they had taken
some time before. On a sudden they dropped the jacket, and
turned their eyes towards the men, who, supposing they were
discovered, immediately discharged several guns, and rushed
upon them, at full speed, with an Indian yell. One of the
Indians, it was supposed, was wounded the first fire, as he
fell and dropped his gun and shot pouch. After running
about one hundred yards, a second shot was fired after him,
by Maj. M'Guire, which brought him to his hands and knees;
but there was no time for pursuit, as the Indians had informed
Mrs. Glass that there was another encampment close by.
They therefore returned with all speed, and reached Beech
Bottom fort that night.

"The other Indian, at the first fire, ran a short distance
beyond Mrs. Glass, so that she was in a right line between
him and the white men; here he halted for a moment, to put


309

Page 309
on his shot pouch, which Mr. Glass mistook for an attempt to
kill his wife with a tomahawk."

This artful manœuvre, no doubt, saved the life of the savage,
as his pursuers could not shoot at him, without risking the
life of the woman.

The above we have slightly altered from the account already
published, and think it is entirely correct as now given. Mrs.
Glass subsequently married a Mr. Brown, and was long a
resident of Brooke county.

The Monongahela settlements suffered somewhat severely
from savage visitation during most of this year. The tomahawk
and scalping knife found their victims in almost every
neighborhood.

"In August, five Indians on their way to the Monongahela,
met with two men on Middle Island creek, and killed them.
Taking their horses, they continued on until they came to the
house of William Johnson, on Ten-mile, and made prisoners
of Mrs. Johnson and some children, plundered the house,
killed part of the stock, and taking with them one of Johnson's
horses, returned towards the Ohio. When the Indians
came to the house, Johnson had gone to a lick not far off,
and on his return in the morning, seeing what had been done,
and searching until he found the trail of the savages and
their prisoners, ran to Clarksburg for assistance. A company
of men repaired with him to where he had discovered the
trail, and keeping it about a mile, found four of the children
lying dead in the woods. The savages had tomahawked and
scalped them, and placing their heads close together, turned
their bodies and feet out so as to represent a cross. The
dead were buried, and further pursuit given over."

In the same month, two lads were surprised and killed at
Neil's station, a small stockade which stood on the Kanawha,
about a mile back of the present town of Parkersburg. The
boys were twelve and fifteen, sons of a German who lived


310

Page 310
within a few hundred yards of the block-house. They had been
to the station late in the evening, and returning, went out of
their path to hunt the cows. The savages had watched them
go down, and at a favorable moment fell upon them with
their tomahawks and killed both on the spot. Alarmed at
their delay, the parents made a search for them on the
following morning and found their bodies as described.
That night, the Indians attempted to burn the block-house
by means of straw and hay, which they thrust through the
port-holes; but in this they were foiled by the vigilance of
those within.

ROBERT CARPENTER.

A nephew of Joseph Tomlinson, named Robert Carpenter,
came near losing his life under the following circumstances.
He had gone out early in the morning for the horses, and
while hunting near Grave creek, was fired on by a party
of Indians who were concealed near the bank. The ball
took effect in his shoulder, breaking the bone, and inflicting
a severe wound. Thus disabled, the Indians soon overtook
and made him prisoner. Anxious to get possession of the
horses, but unable to catch them, the Indians concluded to
let Carpenter try it, as the animals knew him and would be
less difficult to capture.[44] Accordingly, Carpenter was untied
and started in pursuit. Going about two hundred yards,
he determined to escape, and instead of catching the horses
ran towards the house of a friend. But his flight was so
greatly impeded by the old shoes which he wore, and his disabled
arm, that the savages soon overtook him. Another


311

Page 311
attempt was then made by the Indians to get the horses, but
utterly failing, Carpenter ventured to offer his services, declaring
that he would not again try to escape, but do his best
to catch the horses, and go along with them to their country.
Finding they could not get near the animals, they concluded
to trust Carpenter once more, threatening him with all
manner of horrid deaths if he attempted again to escape.
This time he adroitly drove the horses before him a considerable
distance, and then kicking off his shoes, and taking
a firm hold of his maimed limb, started on the race of life or
death. He safely escaped to the house of Nathan Master,
living on the farm now owned by Lewis D. Purdy, Esqr.

 
[44]

It was a matter of general remark, how much the horse of the settler
dreaded an Indian. Many a pioneer and hunter owed the preservation of
his life to the sagacity of his horse. The animal seemed to snuff the presence
of the savage in the air, and neither whip nor spur could urge him by the
dreaded spot.

MURDER OF THE GRICE FAMILY.

This occurrence, which should have gone with the preceding
chapter, was unavoidably omitted, but is now given as
possessing interest to the inhabitants in the region where
the tragedy took place.

Of the families gathered at Shepherd's fort[45] was one by the
name of Grice. When it was determined to evacuate the


312

Page 312
fort, this family, instead of seeking shelter elsewhere, concluded
to return to their improvement, distant about two
miles from the forks. The family consisted of — Grice, his
wife and five children. When near the mouth of Peter's
run, a party of Indians, who had watched the movements at
the fort, fell upon them and murdered, or supposed they had,
all but one, whom they took prisoner. Rachel, a girl of
eleven years of age, was knocked down with a war-club and
her skull fractured, but she was not killed. Dr. Moore,
of Catfish, was called upon, and trepanned her. She recovered,
and afterwards married Captain Henry Jolly, a well
known citizen of Ohio. One of the victims was a married
daughter, who at the time was enceinte. The eldest son,
John, was made prisoner, who remained with them eleven
years, but at last got an opportunity, while in Kentucky, to
escape. The Indians who committed this depredation were
eleven in number. Rachel said, the man who scalped her had
blue eyes and light hair.

 
[45]

This fort was erected in 1775, by Colonel David Shepherd, at the forks
of Wheeling, upon the spot now occupied by the fine stone mansion of Mrs.
Cruger. It was almost an exact square, with block-houses at two of the
corners, so as to command the walls either way. Cabins were arranged
along the inner sides, and the place was perhaps one of the most complete
and safe in the west.

In consequence of the great loss of men at Wheeling, in September 1777,
and the death of Colonel Shepherd's son (William), and son-in-law, Francis
Duke, it was determined in the fall of that year, to abandon the place, and
send the families to Redstone. The fort was accordingly evacuated, September
27th, 1777, and soon after the Indians burned it to the ground.

In 1786, Colonel Shepherd deeming it safe to bring back his family,
rebuilt the fort, and in 1790 re-constructed it. This time it was built of
sycamore planks, three inches in thickness, and twelve feet long. They
were placed in morticed logs, one plank resting upon another. There were
bastions at the corners, and port-holes along this sides.

MURDER OF THE PURDY FAMILY.

One of the most bold and bloody murders perpetrated in
the neighborhood of Wheeling, during this year, was that on
the family of James Purdy, a worthy and industrious settler
on the hill just above Bedelion's mill. The family consisted
of Mr. and Mrs. Purdy and their four children.

The cabin in which they lived was unfinished; a blanket
supplying the place of a door. But this was not deemed
unsafe, as no Indians had appeared in the settlement for
some months. Shortly after dark, four Indians stepped into
the cabin, and without uttering a word commenced butchering
the defenceless family. Two of them fell upon Purdy, who
called to his wife for a knife, which she handed him; but he
was then too much exhausted from the repeated blows of the
tomahawk to use it, and the next moment after receiving it


313

Page 313
sunk lifeless to the floor. Mrs. Purdy was knocked down with
a war club; one child was dashed against the door-way, and its
brains scattered over the room, while an interesting little
boy, who was screaming with fright, had both his fears and
his pains quieted by a blow from the tomahawk. The two
remaining children, daughters, were then made prisoners,
and after plundering the house, effected a hurried retreat
across the Ohio. The girls were released after ten years'
captivity. Mrs. Purdy was only stunned by the blow with
the war club, and falling near the door, crawled off and
secreted herself while the Indians were eating.

ATTACK UPON KIRKWOOD'S CABIN.

Early in the spring of this year, a large body of Indians
made an attack upon the settlement at the mouth of Indian
Wheeling creek, opposite Wheeling, Virginia. A block-house
was in course of erection, but not in a condition to be occupied;
the cabin of Captain Robert Kirkwood[46] was used as a
place of resort for the neighborhood. On this occasion, Captain
Joseph Biggs, who commanded a company of scouts,
was in the cabin with fourteen of his men. About four
o'clock in the morning, Captain Biggs, feeling restless, arose
and went out into the air. Returning, he closed the door,
and what was unusual, rolled a barrel of pork against it, in
order to make it more secure. He had scarcely time to get


314

Page 314
into bed, when the attack was commenced, and a furious
assault made upon the door by means of rails, logs, &c. The
besieged placed themselves under Captain Biggs, by whom
the defence was maintained in a manner highly creditable to
him as a brave and skilful officer. He ordered every particle
of light to be extinguished, and so stationed his men as to fire
upon the enemy from every direction. The night was clear
and beautiful; the moon being nearly full, gave those within
great advantage over the enemy, as they were enabled by the
light, to shoot the savages whenever they presented themselves.
Early in the engagement, Captain Biggs received a
serious wound, but with the courage of a true soldier concealed
the nature of it until day-light. In noticing the
movements of the enemy through one of the windows of the
cabin, an Indian, who had slipped close under the side of the
house, suddenly thrust his rifle through the window at which
Captain Biggs was standing, and discharging it, lodged the
ball in the left arm of the captain, just below the shoulder.
The bone was badly fractured, and parts of it afterwards
came away.

Foiled in their attempt to effect an entrance at the door,
(which had been well secured by puncheons from the floor,)
the savages determined to try the effect of fire; and accordingly
hurled burning fagots upon the roof, which, in a few
minutes, was enveloped in flames. But again they were unsuccessful,
for the whites pushed off the roof. The Indians now
became furious, and commenced piling brush against the sides
of the house, which they fired. At one time that noble little
band thought their fate was sealed, as the flames would often
mount to the top of the walls. With perseverance and caution,
however, they succeeded in subduing the fire, and finally
extinguishing it. This they did first with water, milk, and
such other liquids as could be commanded, and finally with
sand from beneath the cabin floor. Early in the attack,
the mortar was removed from the chinks of the wall, and the
savages having suffered severely from the steady aim of the


315

Page 315
scouts through these convenient port-holes, retired behind the
half-finished block-house.[47]

Shortly before day-break, the boom of a cannon was heard
echoing among the hills, which the besieged hailed as the
harbinger of help. The firing had been heard at Wheeling,
and the gun announced that assistance would soon be at
hand. The savages, too, understood it, and without delay
gathered up their wounded and disappeared in the forest. Five
of the whites were severely wounded, one mortally. These
were, Captain Joseph Biggs, John Walker, Elijah Hedges,
John Barrett, and Joseph Van Meter. Walker was shot
through the hip, severing the urethra, and causing his death
early next day. He was removed to the residence of Colonel
Zane, Wheeling, where he died, and was buried with military
honors. A coat belonging to some of the inmates, which had
been suspended by the centre-log, and was left hanging after
the roof had been thrown off, was found, on examination, to
be completely riddled with bullets. The number of Indians
was never fully ascertained, nor the extent of their killed
and wounded. They were supposed to have been the same
concerned in the engagement with Captain Van Buskirk's
company at the mouth of Brush run, an account of which is
elsewhere given.

 
[46]

It was our intention to have given a biographical sketch of Captain
Kirkwood in this volume; but the scantiness of material at command prevents
it. He was a brave and gallant soldier, and fought with considerable
distinction in the old Delaware line, throughout the war of the Revolution.
He is most honorably mentioned in Lee's Memoirs of the Southern Campaigns.
At Camden, Holkirk's, Eutah, and Ninety-Six, Captain Kirkwood
was in the thickest of the fight, and exhibited all the elements of a brave
and accomplished soldier. He fell in the disastrous defeat of St. Clair, in
November following the attack upon his house on Indian Wheeling.

[47]

This block-house stood nearly opposite the recently erected Methodist
church, in the town of Kirkwood.

FATAL DECOY.

One of the most common, and at the same time, most
successful decoys practised by the wily savage, was that
of the turkey call. The case we are about to record belongs
to that class.

Of those forted at Grave creek, was a William McIntosh,
wife and child. Early one morning, the cry of a turkey was


316

Page 316
heard against the hill-side, across the river. McIntosh,
although warned against the deceptions of the enemy, started
over with his gun and dog. He landed his canoe at a point
nearly opposite the fort, and commenced ascending the bank.
Before taking ten steps, the "turkey," from his concealed
position, fired and shot his victim through the head.

McIntosh remaining much longer than was thought right,
some men from the fort went over on the third day, and there
found the unfortunate man scalped, with his faithful dog sitting
by his side.

SURPRISE OF A HUNTER'S CAMP.

On the 28th of January, (1791,) a hunting party, composed
of Joseph Biggs, James Boggs, (son of Captain Boggs,)
James and Alexander Mitchell, Thos. Barr, Thos. Richards,
Elijah Whittaker, Joshua Williamsom, (brother of Colonel
Williamson,) and some others whose names cannot be obtained,
crossed the Ohio from Short creek, on a hunt in the
Indian country. They went out as far as Stillwater, and
having killed considerable game were about returning. As
the party lay around their camp fire at night, a body of
Indians rose up from beneath the creek bank, and fired
directly into their midst. Boggs was shot through both hips
with a large musket ball; the rest of the party escaped
unhurt and eluded pursuit, but lost all their guns, blankets,
game, etc. The Indians scalped their unfortunate victim,—
almost denuding the entire skull, then stretched him out and
placed an old musket across his breast. His arms were
extended at full length, and frozen so firmly in that position,
that when the men went out from Wheeling to bury him,
they had to amputate the limbs to get him in a convenient
sized grave. The ground was so frozen that the men could
not bury the body at any great depth, and the result was, as
afterwards ascertained, that the bears scented out the spot


317

Page 317
and devoured the remains. These facts we have derived from
Mrs. Cruger, who was sister-in-law to Mr. Boggs. The
unfortunate man had, during the night previous to his horrible
death, what was called a "bad dream." It was that of a
swarm of black bees, some of which stung him. His companions
said he spoke frequently of the circumstance during
the day, and that he regarded it as a fatal presentiment.

One of the latest, and perhaps the very last Indian
murder committed on the river near Wheeling, was that of
Uriah McCutcheon, who was killed by a small party of
Indians near the present Harris' Ferry. According to B.
McMechen, Esq., from whom we have obtained this fact, the
unfortunate man was found shortly afterwards, tomahawked
and scalped.

DEATH OF THREE HUNTERS.

In the fall of this year, three young men, Thomas Swearengen,
son of Captain Van Swearengen, John L. Masters,
and a third whose name we have not been able to ascertain,
crossed the Ohio, and commenced hunting up the valley of
Short creek. The day was very fine, and as no Indian
depredations had been committed for some time in that
immediate neighborhood, the hunters believed they were
perfectly safe. But their hopes proved a vain delusion.
They had not gone far, when a party of Indians, doubtless
attracted by the report of the hunters' rifles, fired upon them,
killing Swearengen on the spot, and so wounding the others,
that they were easily overtaken and dispatched. The bodies
of all three were afterwards found and identified. The scene
of this disaster was some four or five miles back from the
river and creek. Some men from the Ohio side gave information
of the discovery of the bodies, and a party of Virginians
from the neighborhood of Beech bottom went over


318

Page 318
and buried them. Similar expeditions to the one we have
just spoken of, frequently went from this side into the Indian
country, and they generally paid for their temerity. We
have already noticed two or three, and now have to speak of
another. Not long after the last mentioned occurrence, a
party of seven, from the neighborhood of West Liberty,
including one of the Biggs' and also one of the Hedges',
crossed the river, and after one day's hunt, were attacked by
a considerable body of Indians, and put to rout with the loss
of three of their number.

MASSACRE OF JOLLY'S FAMILY.

Among the earlier settlers in the neighborhood of Wheeling,
was Daniel Jolly. His improvement was on the hill, about
three miles from the mouth of the creek. The land is, we
believe, now occupied by Mr. McEnall, and the site of his
cabin is still pointed out not far from the road which crosses
the hill from the old toll-gate to the river. The family of
Jolly consisted of himself, wife and four children, with one
grand-child.

On the 8th day of June, a small party of Indians, who
had secreted themselves behind some gooseberry bushes in
the garden, fired upon the family, killing Mrs. Jolly instantly
and wounding a son, daughter and grand-son. Her eldest
son, John, had just reached the house from the corn-field,
and was in the act of wiping the perspiration from his brow
with the sleeve of his shirt as the ball struck him in the
mouth. He fell, badly wounded, and the next instant the
savages were tomahawking him. Killing and scalping the
other wounded ones, and taking prisoner one son and a
nephew of Mr. Jolly, named Joseph McCune, they pillaged,
then fired the house and made a rapid retreat. Joseph
McCune was killed after proceeding a short distance because
he could not travel fast, as he suffered from phthisic.


319

Page 319

Mrs. Jolly was standing in the door at the moment she
was shot, looking in direction of the spring, to which she had
sent one of her children. The boy at the spring, whose name
was James, escaped, also another member of the family in
the field. A daughter, Mary, was absent at her uncle Joseph
McCune, who lived on the ridge road, about five miles from
the forks of Wheeling. Mr. Jolly had gone on a journey to
the Monongahela to receive a payment for some property
which he had sold previous to moving out.

The boy made prisoner remained in captivity seven years,
and was then regained by his brother at Pensacola. He was
discovered trading at Nashville; and on being questioned, the
facts of his captivity were elicited, whereupon a gentleman
wrote to Colonel Zane, who communicated the intelligence to
the boy's father. These particulars we have derived principally
from Mrs. Cruger, Mr. McIntyre, and Mr. Darby.

DEATH OF CAPTAIN VAN BUSKIRK.

Early in June[48] of this year occurred the last conflict,
on the upper Ohio, between an organized party of Virginians
and Indians. In consequence of the numerous depredations
on the settlements now embraced in Brooke and Hancock
counties, it was determined to summarily chastise these
marauders; and accordingly, a party of men organized
under the command of Captain Lawson Van Buskirk, an
officer of tried courage and acknowledged efficiency. A party
of Indians had committed sundry acts of violence, and it was
believed they would endeavor to cross the Ohio on their retreat,


320

Page 320
at some point near Mingo Bottom.[49] The party of Captain
Van Buskirk, consisted of about forty experienced frontiermen,
some of whom were veteran Indian hunters. The number of
the enemy was known to be about thirty. The whites crossed
the river below the mouth of Cross creek, and marched up the
bottom, looking cautiously for the enemy's trail. They had
discovered it along the run, but missing it, they concluded
to take the ridge, hoping thus to cross it. Descending the
ridge, and just as they gained the river, the Indians fired
upon them, killing Captain Van Buskirk, and wounding John
Aidy. The enemy were concealed in a ravine amidst a dense
cluster of paw-paw bushes. The whites marched in single
file, headed by their captain, whose exposed situation will
account for the fact that he was wounded with thirteen
balls. The ambush quartered on their flank, and they were
totally unsuspicious of it. The plan of the Indians was to
permit the whites to advance in numbers along the line before
firing upon them. This was done; but instead of each selecting
his man, every gun was directed at the captain, who fell, with
thirteen bullet holes in his body. The whites and Indians
instantly tree'd, and the contest lasted more than an hour.
The Indians, however, were defeated, and retreated towards
the Muskingum, with the loss of several killed, while the
Virginians, with the exception of their captain, had none
killed and but three wounded.

Captain Van Buskirk's wife was killed just eleven months
previous to the death of her husband. They lived about three
miles from West Liberty. She had been taken prisoner by the
Indians, and on their march towards the river, her ancle was
sprained so that she could not walk without pain. Finding
her an incumbrance, the wretches put her to death on the hill,
just above where Wellsburg now stands. On the following day
the body of this unfortunate woman was found by a party who
had gone in pursuit.

 
[48]

The writer in Howe's Ohio, gives the occurrence as taking place in
August, but our information is reliable for placing it in June. The late Mrs.
Lear Shepherd, mother of Jeremiah Shepherd, Esq., of Marshall county, Va.,
and sister-in-law of Captain Van Buskirk, was one of the persons from whom
we derived much of the information now given.

[49]

This was the site of an old Mingoe town, about four miles below
Steubenville.


321

Page 321

1794.

THE TUSH MURDER.

The valley of Wheeling creek, one of the most beautiful
and productive in the state, was the theatre of many a painful
and bloody drama. Scarcely a quiet bend, or a surrounding
hill, or a rippling tributary, that is not memorable as connected
with the wars of the Indians. To one unacquainted with its
tragic history, it would indeed be difficult to imagine that
these clear waters were once tinged with the blood of helpless
women and children, and these stern old hills ever echoed to
the terrible whoop of the savage. Such, however, is the
melancholy fact, as our pages abundantly attest. The case
which we are about to detail was, perhaps, the most dreadful
that occurred in the settlement of the valley.

Of those who settled at an early day in this region, was
George Tush. His residence was about twelve miles from the
river, on the farm now owned by Mr. Albert Davis. The
family consisted of himself, wife, and five children. During
the spring and summer of 1794, the settlements on Wheeling
creek had been almost entirely exempt from Indian visitation,
and many of the inhabitants began to console themselves with
the reflection, that day was about to dawn upon their long
night of terror. But, alas, their fondly imagined security was
soon to be dispelled. On the evening of Saturday, September
6th, (1794,) as George Tush was in the act of feeding his hogs,
in a sty close to his cabin, he was fired upon by three savages,
who had concealed themselves, and waited until he should
leave the house. A ball struck him transversely upon the
breast, cutting a deep gash, and inflicting a serious and painful
wound, as it carried off a portion of the bone. It lodged in
the shoulder blade. Tush, losing entirely his presence of
mind, or, in all charitableness, we may allow that his pain


322

Page 322
deprived him of self-control, rushed madly by his own door,
in direction of the forest, leaving his helpless family to the
mercy of relentless savages. The next moment the Indians
were in the house. The mother was instantly made prisoner,
and in powerless but quivering agony, compelled to witness
the horrid butchery of her innocent children. In an instant
the youngest born was dashed against a tree, and the other
four fell beneath the reeking tomahawk. Pillaging the house
of such articles as they could carry off, a hurried retreat
was made, lest the escaped husband should follow in pursuit.
The feeble woman was brutally urged on before them. But,
alas, the scenes which she had just witnessed, together with
her own situation, rendered her movements both slow and painful.
Fearing discovery, the wretches tomahawked their helpless
victim, and left her at a point about eight miles from the
place of captivity. Her remains were found some years
afterwards by her husband, while hunting. He recognized
them by the bones of an infant with which she was at the
time largely enceinte.

Of the children tomahawked and scalped, one, a little girl
of four years, recovered, and the infant, whose brains were
supposed to have been dashed out, was found alive on the
following day, lying upon its dead sisters and brothers.
That child still lives, and is the wife of George Goodrich,
residing near Shelbyville, Ia. The children had, a few days
before, gathered a quantity of acorns, which, it is supposed,
prevented the hogs disturbing the remains.

Tush, in his fright, ran some distance, and jumped from a
ledge of rocks fifteen feet in height. This so disabled him
that he could not get to Jacob Wetzel's house, which was
just across the creek, until late at night. He was taken to
Wheeling a day or two after, and there remained until his
wound was healed. (See letter of Mr. Darby, in a Note at
the end of present chapter, for some interesting facts connected
with this case.)


323

Page 323

DEATH OF TWO BROTHERS.

Late in the fall of 1794, two brothers, named John and
Joseph Scott, accompanied by a man named Thomas Manning,
started on a hunting expedition to Stillwater. They believed
the season so far advanced that no danger need be apprehended
from Indians. The three men traversed the country
lying between Wheeling and Stillwater without molestation,
or indication of Indians. On the first night of their arrival
out, they kindled a fire, and after supper prepared for rest.
Manning, who was an experienced hunter, attempted to dissuade
the Scotts from remaining near the fire. They, however,
disregarded the advice, and laughed at his fears. But
Manning declared he would not sleep there, and accordingly
moved off a short distance. Scarcely had he changed his
position, when a party of Indians opened a fire upon them,
killing the brothers instantly, and wounding Manning severely,
by breaking his left arm. Reserving his fire, the Indians
did not rush upon him, and supposing he was mortally wounded,
ran upon the Scotts, and plied the tomahawk, that the
work of death might be complete. Manning escaped, and
made his way to Wheeling. Immediately a party of whites
went out and buried the unfortunate brothers. The savages
had singularly maimed one of the ill-fated men.

The Scotts were active and industrious men, good hunters,
and much respected by all who knew them. Joseph married
Debby Hardesty. He lived on the point where the warehouse
of Anderson & Pancoast now stands, in Bridgeport. John
lived on the island.


324

Page 324

BLOODY EXPLOIT.

Jonathan Zane was perhaps one of the best shots in the
west. He prided himself particularly upon his skill in this
respect. The following incident shows that he was not only
a good shot, but a dead shot. We derive the facts from Mr.
Reuben Miller, of Bridgeport, Ohio, long a personal friend of
Mr. Zane.

About the year 1808, the two (Miller and Zane) were
walking near where Phillips' foundry now stands, in Wheeling,
when Zane remarked, "About here, I once killed five
Indians. I was returning home from hunting my horses,
and in passing through the high weeds which at that time
grew all around, I saw five Indians jump into the river, and
swim for the island. I fired, and one of them sunk. Loading
and firing three times in quick succession, three others
were killed before reaching the opposite bank." The fifth
and last, seeing the fate of his companions, concealed himself
behind a sawyer, near the island shore, hoping thus to escape
the deadly aim of the white man. After several ineffectual
attempts to dislodge him, the effort was about to be given
over, when Zane noticed a portion of his abdomen protruding
below the log. Drawing a fine aim on the exposed part, he
fired, and the savage rolled into the stream.

ATTACK ON MR. ARMSTRONG.

A Mr. Armstrong, one of the early settlers at Belpre,
having secured some land on the Virginia side, built a mill
and cabin near the head of Blannerhasset's Island, and in the
spring of 1794 moved over his family, consisting of his wife
and five children. Shortly after their change of residence, a
party of Indians concealed themselves on the river hill immediately


325

Page 325
back of Armstrong's house, and in full view of the
stockade at Belpre. At early dawn, Mr. Armstrong heard
that so often fatal decoy, the turkey-call, and taking his dog
and gun, sallied forth to secure a shot before they should leave
the roost. One of the sons, taken prisoner, and now living
near Columbus, Ohio, relates what followed. "After proceeding
a short distance, either from the dog, or some other
circumstance, Armstrong became alarmed, retreated to the
house and barred the door. The Indians pursued, and endeavored
to get it open, but failing on the first attempt, they
took a rail to effect their purpose. While they were endeavoring
to gain entrance, Mr. Armstrong snapped his gun, in an
attempt to shoot, but it did not go off; he then ascended
the loft, and removing some of the roof, escaped through the
opening, while the Indians were breaking down the door.
The alarm was given to the stockade in upper Belpre, and
a party went over. They met Mr. Armstrong and the two
eldest sons, who had been in the mill. Mrs. Armstrong they
found dead on the outside of the cabin. It appeared as if she
had attempted to escape from the roof, as her husband did;
but being a heavy woman, had probably fallen and broken her
leg. Two children were dead, and a little girl still alive, but
insensible, though when disturbed, she would say, `What's
that?' Mrs. Armstrong and two children were scalped; one
child about two years of age was not. Two sons who were
in the cabin were taken prisoners, and carried to their towns,
where they remained until the close of the war, when their
elder brothers brought them from the Indian country."

Between the years 1784 and 1793, several murders were
committed along the river below Grave creek; the exact dates
of some of these we have not been able to ascertain, but will
nevertheless give a brief notice of the occurrences. Adam


326

Page 326
Roe and family, who had been forted at Tomlinson's, considering
it safe to return to their improvement, and becoming
very tired of fort life, determined to start for the mouth of
Fishing creek, and were all killed ten miles below.

Proctor was an early settler near the mouth of a stream
now known as Proctor's run. Finding the Indians becoming
troublesome, he proposed to remove his family to Wheeling,
but the savages were likely to intercept him, and he was compelled
to look for some other place. A few miles up the run is a
remarkable rock, presenting a concealed entrance, but opening
out into a fine large chamber, perfectly dry, and spacious
enough to contain thirty or forty persons. Into this Proctor
moved with his family, and for some time succeeded in eluding
the wily savages. He however, continued imprudently
to venture out, and the Indians discovering his tracks, stationed
a spy to ascertain his place of abode. This once done,
they made an attack, killing the occupant with two of his
children. Mrs. Proctor having a child in her arms, elicited
the sympathy of an old Indian who stood by, and declared
that she should not be killed. She was then made prisoner,
but succeeded that night in eluding their vigilance, and
making her escape. She reached Wheeling the next day in
safety.


327

Page 327

NOTE.

There being some discrepancy between the accounts of Mrs. Cruger and
Mr. Darby, as to the time of certain occurrences in the settlement of the
west, we addressed the latter a note, and in reply, received the following
interesting letter, which will fully explain itself.

W. De Hass, Esq.:
Dear Sir,—

Your note of this day I have duly received, and with sincere
pleasure proceed to comply with your requisitions; especially, as the facts
will have a more fitting and enduring place of record, than if stated in a
public print—which it was my intention to have done, had you not presented
a superior vehicle.

Though not offered as material to the historical facts, I preface my recollections,
with a statement of my position at the time of their occurrence,
and my age when brought on the theatre. I was born on the 14th August,
1775, and arrived with my parents on the ground where Washington, Pennsylvania,
now stands, December 25th, 1781, of course in my seventh year.
Though so young, I very distinctly remember such striking circumstances
as attended Indian war, and to which I was either an ear or eye-witness.

In the summer previous to the removal of his family, my father came to
Washington county, and built a cabin, and made a crop on William Wolf's
farm, on one of the head branches of Buffalo, about five miles west of where
the borough of Washington now stands. We had come out, and were living
in the cabin, when early in 1782, the Indians committed some murders, and
the people took refuge in their block-houses, and we, with others, were,
through part of February and March, forted in Jacob Wolf's block-house.
The Great Western road traverses the site of this once rude fortress,[50] in
which, sixty-eight years past, the writer of these words was sheltered from
the fury of savages.

Simultaneous with the above stated circumstances, was planned and carried
into effect, the campaign under the nominal command of Colonel David
Williamson, and which led on to the deplorable massacre of the Moravian
christianized Indians, on the Tuscarawas. In after life, I personally knew
several men who participated in this affair, and particularly Colonel Williamson;
and am now constrained to express my full conviction, that the


328

Page 328
fatal issue was not premeditated, but the effect of some momentary impulse.
You will have, no doubt, means more ample than any in my power to supply,
to set this part of frontier history in correct points of view.

As the season or summer of 1782 advanced, another, and much more important
expedition against the Indians was planned, and mustered under the
joint commands of Colonels David Williamson and William Crawford. This
little army penetrated the Indian country, was met, and utterly defeated.
Colonel Crawford was made captive, and burned by the savages. In the
very neighborhood where I was then living, about two miles from Catfish,
(Washington). John Campbell, William Nimmons, William Huston, and William
Johnston, never returned, though their individual fate was, I believe,
never revealed. I mention the facts from their tendency to fix their
memory on my mind; the more, as they influenced all my after life. My
parents never returned to their cabin near Wolf's fort. Through 1782, and
into 1783, we resided on land as already stated. In 1783, 1784, and into 1785,
we resided on the land long known as Officers' farm, then owned by James
Brownlee. Early in 1785, my father purchased from Thomas Goudy, the
farm, afterwards long owned by Benedict Reynolds, and on which my parents,
with their children, resided from early in 1785 to 1793.

In my father's first visit to the west, and before the removal of his family,
of the many persons he made acquaintance with, one was Mr. Becham, and
a second, Mr. Crow, the fathers of the victims whose fate you have to record.
I do not remember to have seen the former, but the latter was frequently at
our house on the Reynold farm, and spent great part of a day with us,
only a few days before the murder of his two daughters, and the astonishing
escape of his other daughter, Christina, as you have found stated by Colonel
Lewis Bonnett.

I had a half-brother, five years older than myself, and while life remains,
I must remember his return home, and communicating to his parents, the
murder of two sons, and the scalping and tomahawking of a third, named
Thomas, who survived; the children of Mr. Becham. I had then never been,
or expected to be, west of our long-deserted cabin on Buffalo. The year, I
cannot attempt to state, but can decidedly say, it was not later than 1788,
and I think was in 1787.

My first residence on Wheeling waters, was commenced early in 1793, in
the Bonnett, Wetzel, Keller, Mercer, &c. neighborhood, about five or six
miles above Shepherd's fort, now Mrs. Cruger's farm. Amongst other persons,
I became acquainted with in this neighborhood, was George Tush, who
resided with his family near Bonnetts and Wetzels.

Late in 1793, I went to, and opened a school in the then very small, but
as on the extreme frontier, the very important village of Wheeling; in
which, and in its immediate neighborhood, I remained until 1795. Thus, I
was there, during the important year of 1794, important in an especial manner
to the long distressed frontier on the Ohio. The power of the savages was


329

Page 329
broken; fear of their inroads was in great part effaced; but the lapse of
time was too brief to permit the horrors of their inroads to be forgotten.
The confidence of safety was still felt, and it was in this state of mind, that
the people of Wheeling received the fearful news of the murder of Mrs. Tush
and her children. The wounded and still bleeding husband and father was
brought to our midst, and placed under the care of George Cookis and his
wife. I have already stated that I had a previous personal acquaintance
with Tush; and by a curious coincidence, the Becham murder, the Crow murder,
and other similar tragedies acted years before, were all brought up to
our most vivid remembrance, and we had, beside the Tush family, other
events to give activity to our recollections. * * *

In conclusion, I must say, that if any one more than another, desires
complete success to your work, I am that man. The deepest fountains of
my heart are opened, when mentally scanning the scenes of former years—
of days long gone by. You will have the credit of aiding in the preservation
of names of persons, the value of whose services in life, the present generation
can but faintly estimate. They were the heroes and martyrs who
braved the danger, and endured the hardships of a savage frontier—they
prepared the way which led to the smiling country which now blooms in
plenty and peace. When in my old age I can, by the exercise of a sacred
duty, have my name associated with those you will place on record, I must
sincerely thank Eternal Power for the greatest of earthly favors. My path
through life has yet had strewn along it more thorns than roses; but your
book, when I receive it, will cure the pain of many sharp thorns, and
sweeten the remaining years of a long and changeful existence. Such reading
will recall deeds of heroism, and manly traits of character which no
other section of earth can give examples to excel. With sentiments of sincere
gratitude for your confidence, and hope of your success,

I am, &c., &c.,
William Darby.
 
[50]

Wolf's fort, or block-house, stood near the spot now occupied by the
dwelling-house of Mr. Brownlee, five miles west of Washington, Pa. It was
a regular stockade.



No Page Number