Henry Tuckerman; quoted in Jay Leyda,
The Melville Log (1951), II, 664.
[2]
Hugh W. Hetherington, Melville's
Reviewers: British and American 1846-1891 (1961), p.
253.
[3]
See Leonard Lutwack, "Herman Melville and
Atlantic Monthly Critics," Huntington Library
Quarterly, XIII (1950), 414-416.
[4]
Atlantic Monthly, XLV (1880),
858.
Titles were given to "Contributors' Club" pieces only in the
Atlantic index, which appeared semi-annually.
[5]
See, for example, Richard Chase, Herman
Melville: A Critical Study (1949), p. 146, who seems
to
have been the first, but hardly the last, to venture this theory.
