From the London
Weekly Dispatch. (London,
England.)
LEAVES OF GRASS. By Walt Whitman. Horsell, Oxford Street.
WE have before us one of the most extraordinary specimens of Yankee intelligence and
American eccentricity in authorship, it is possible to conceive. It is of a genus so peculiar
as to embarrass us, and has an air at once so novel, so audacious, and so strange as to verge upon
absurdity, and yet it would be an injustice to pronounce it so, as the work is saved from this
extreme by a certain mastery over diction not very easy of definition. What Emerson has
pronounced to be good must not be lightly treated, and before we pronounce upon the merits of
this performance it is but right to examine them. We have, then, a series of pithy prose sentences
strung together — forming twelve grand divisions in all, but which, having a rude rhymical
cadence about them, admit of the designation poetical being applied. They are destitute of rhyme,
measure of feet, and the like, every condition under which poetry is generally understood to exist
being absent; but in their strength of expression, their fervor, hearty wholesomeness, their
originality, mannerism, and freshness, one finds in them a singular harmony and flow, as if by
reading, they gradually formed themselves into melody, and adopted characteristics peculiar and
appropriate to themselves alone. If, however, some sentences be fine, there are others altogether
laughable; nevertheless, in the bare strength, the unhesitating frankness of a man who "believes
in the flesh and the appetites," and who dares to call simplest things by their plainest names,
conveying also a large sense of the beautiful, and with an emphasis which gives a clearer
conception of what manly modesty really is than any thing we have, in all conventional forms of
word, deed, or act so far known of, that we rid ourselves, little by little, of the
strangeness with which we greet this bluff new-comer, and, beginning to understand him better,
appreciate him in proportion as he becomes more known. He will soon make his way into the
confidence of his readers, and his poems in time will become a pregnant text-book, out of which
quotation as sterling as the minted gold will be taken and applied to every form and phase of the
"inner" or the "outer" life; and we express our pleasure in making the acquaintance of Walt
Whitman, hoping to know more of him in time to come.