University of Virginia Library

Search this document 
Familiar Epistles To Frederick J---s, Esq

On the Present State of the Irish Stage. Second Edition with Considerable Additions [by J. W. Croker]
  
  
  

collapse section 
 1. 
 2. 
 3. 
 4. 
 5. 
 6. 
SIXTH EPISTLE.


97

SIXTH EPISTLE.

Εγω μεν δη οιμαι απερ υπεθεμην απειργασθαι----ει δε τις ταναντια εμοι γιγνωσκοι τα εργα αυτων επισκοπων, ευρησει αυτα μαρτυρουντα, τοις εμοις λογοις. Xenoph. Cyr. Lib. VIII.

Good natur'd muse that from the sky
Breathe on encomiastic Pye,
And deck his periodic lays
With honied trope and flowery phrase;
Deign on your suppliant bard to shower
The gentlest influence of your power,
And teach my voice to celebrate
The glories of the Thespian state;

98

'Tis my last work—my last request,
This labour o'er from verse I rest—
Besides my lays to J---s belong,
What muse to J---s denies a song.
She hears me not—in vain I pray,
Fair Eulogy is far away,
Teaching young Preachers to disclose
The beauties of poetic prose,

99

And guiding laureate bards to try
Flights of prosaic poetry.
But lo! uncalled, from routs and drums
Dame Censure to my closet comes;
Of journals floats her patchwork gown,
Post, Courier, Chronicle and Sun,
And, to supply the 'kerchief's ends,
A Cobbett from her sides depends;
Instead of attar, round her head
Steams of tea their incense shed—
Her ears two figur'd serpents deck,
And beads of black-beans twine her neck,
Wreathed o'er her forehead nettles nod,
In place of fan, a wormwood rod

100

She bears; and hanging from her breast
Churchill in miniature expressed.
“Write on,” she cries, “obey my power;
“These are my subjects, this my hour:
“Thalia and Melpomene
“Their kingdoms abdicate to me,
“And all distinctions I o'erwhelm
“By union of my double realm.—
“Of yore there was a bound between
“The tragic and the comic scene.
“Smirking features—tripping gait
“Ne'er troubled the severer state;
“Nor hollow voice, nor formal stalk
“E'er trespassed on the comic walk,

101

“Each kept its humour and its place,
“Peculiar gait, and natural face.
“But now confounded, melted, mix'd,
“No frontier barrier betwixt,
“Our actors different changes try
“The tragic grin, the comic cry.
“Each face so severed into halves,
“That one side weeps while t'other laughs:

102

“Thus Irish weddings oft display
“Mix'd scenes of frolic and of fray;
“And at their funerals and wakes,
“Close by the coffin laughter shakes.
“Or thus in prints, you think you've got
“The features of a jolly sot:
“But look again, and you behold
“The furious visage of a scold.
“Though these my subjects are unfit
“For Otway's pathos, Congreve's wit,
“They in such dramas hope to tower,
“As suit their heteroclite power.

103

“—In tragedies that offer ranting
“For spirit, and for pathos canting,
“Blustering for sorrow, oaths for sighs,
“For vigour, rage and blasphemies:

104

“Where passions either creep or fly,
“Meanly low, or madly high,
“And bedlam-nature stalks or flutters.
“Either on stilts or in the gutters.—

105

“—In comedies where pun and hit
“But ill supply the want of wit,
“And all the incident consists
“In active heels, and brawny fists;
“Where polished heroes nothing say
“But “zounds keep moving, what's to pay?

106

“And for his plot the Author trusts
“To mending coats, and breaking busts.—
“—In operas where lovers come
“To dulcet sound of bass and drum,

107

“And damsels thrill their tender lay to
“Trombone and trumpet obligato,
“Where harmony's accordant choir
“Is lost in crash of wood and wire,
“And he o'er all his peers is proudest,
“Who roars the longest and the loudest.”

108

“Thus 'spite of all their boasted nine,
“The modern theatre is mine;
“There every night supreme I sit
“O'er boxes, gallery and pit:
“There in my fetters, kingly J---s
“Utters his unavailing groans,

109

“Long shall he groan, nor hope to gain
“His suffering kingdoms from my reign,

110

“'Till in his party he can boast
“A brave unmutilated host—
“'Till Hamlet lead his danish force,
“And English Richard take to horse—
“'Till Dunsinane send forth its lord,
“And Martius wave his Roman sword—
“'Till to his aid the tragic band
“Of every time, from every land,

111

“On German nonsense turn the war,
“And chain down conquest to his car.”
“In vain shall he expect to ride
“In safety o'er the Public tide,
“To buffet every gale that blows,
“And sweep the sea of all his foes;

112

“Whilst in his puny fleet are reckoned
“First-rates none, but one o' th' second,
“And all the rest—his bold defenders
“Are frigates, luggers, hulks, and tenders.”

113

“For my part, (metaphor aside)
“His weakness is my strength and pride,
“I die if he plucks up a spirit,
“For Censure lives on want of merit.”
She said and vanished,—thro' my room
Vapours arose of acrid fume.—
Thus when a ghost his mission ends,
And thro' the yawning trap descends,

114

The yawning trap in clouds expires,
Sulphureous smell of brimstone fires.
Dear J---s I'm glad the beldame's fled,
Rest she for ever with the dead;
Ne'er may her features, sour and cramp,
‘Visit the glimpses of our lamp,
Making night hideous;’ ne'er again
With bitter taunt and cynic mein,
May she invade the sacred bound
That fences bard and players round;
But let us lay this worse than ghost,
And send her to the red-sea coast
In the due forms of magic school,
And exorcise the fiend by rule.

115

First let us grasp with daring hand
Th' Avonian talismanic wand,
And summon here on their allegiance
The powers that pay to it obedience;—

116

Hecate dark, and Ariel light,
And merry Robin sportive sprite;
Titania, Oberon and all
That hear the fairy monarch's call,
Theirs be the region of the airs,
And constant watch etherial, theirs.
Then comes the ministerial train
Chaunting the Muses' sacred strain,
In robes of ceremony dressed,
With sacerdotal stole and vest,

117

Each Actor holding Shakespeare's page,
The priests and rubrick of the stage.
Such as our Thespian faith requires,
Not begging monks and wandering friars.
Then in a burning chauldron's blaze,
Throw Reynold's and Morton's plays,
Each page of Allingham's and Cobbe's,
And heavy Boaden's clumsy jobs;
The insane verse, and madder prose
Of Lewis, Coleman's puppet-shows—
And all the trash the Germans send here
Thro' Thomson, Noeden, Plumtree, Render,
Be all on the buzaglo placed,
Pacts with the demon of false-taste.

118

Next gather in a chrystal bowl
The tears down Pity's cheeks that roll,
That from the riven bosom flow,
Touch'd by the wand of tragic woe;
Scatter the blessed drops around,
And sanctify the holy ground;
No envious fiends their footsteps set
On earth that Pity's tear has wet.
'Tis done—the solemn rites are paid
And Censure's in the ocean laid.
And now from fair Augusta's towers
Collect, dear J---s, your scenic powers;
Not mere allies that play a score
Of nights, “and then are heard no more,”

119

That for a moment shine, and then
To darkness give us up again;
Not mummers fit to please the gallery,
Collected at a five pound salary;—
Not Poucets to say parts by rote,—
Not fingers who can't sing a note.
Drive from your stage all foreign nonsense,
And shows that only please at one sense—

120

Trash that usurps the comic name,
Mad farce and maudlin melodrame.
Throw off the trammels of the mode,
A shifting yet a ponderous load;
Nor let your native sense and taste
By others follies be disgraced,

121

Catch timid merit as it springs,
Give to your liberal soul full wings,
The stages golden age restore,
And Censure shall return no more.

I at this moment, when my Printer is going to shut up his Press, learn from one of the newspapers, that the mimæ and balatrones are about to publish answers to these Epistles.—Who the disinterested champions of the Manager's propriety, and his servants talents are; whether in prose ‘Respondere parant sue condunt amabile carmen,’ I have no means of knowing, nor reason for caring. I am not desirous of controversy; but if any further exertion in the defence of common sense, decency, and the drama, should become necessary, I shall, perhaps, request the Public indulgence for a continuation of these Epistles; but if, on the contrary, I find that the Patentee and the actors persevere in admitting the justice of my remaks, by a renunciation of the errors which occasioned them, I shall calmly bear in triumphant silence, all the efforts of Kitchenstuff Answerers and Gazetteers. Saturday, March 24, 1804. POSTSCRIPT. My business does not permit me to bestow my time so totally on this little Book, as to enable me to say, that this second Edition contains no typical or substantial errors: but I have exerted all convenient diligence, in making it correct both in matter and form—In both perhaps, I have failed, yet I should hope that I may be permitted to say,

Sunt bona sunt quædam mediocria sunt mala plura
Quæ legis, hic aliter nonfit, avite liber.


 
Extremum hunc Arethusa mihi concede laborem,
Pauca meo Gallo------
------ neget quis carmina Gallo.

Virg. Ecl. X.

This is not a random rhyme. I exceedingly lament the foolim and indecent style of oratory, which so often makes the sacred chair, the “tinsel throne of glittering nonsense;” the serious disposition of thought which our admirable church-service is so calculated to inspire, is either put to shame or to flight, by the wild and feigned declamation which, as a critic, I despise, and as a Christian detest. I would recommend it to those reverend young Poets, to indulge their taste for the Muses, in reading Cowper's description of a petit-maitre clergyman, and to recollect the advice of Boileau:

Et, fabuleux chrétiens, n'allons point, dans nos songes,
Du Dieu de vérité fair un Dieu de mensonges.
To some Readers this note would require an apology; such Readers I have no desire to please, and shall make none.

Since the days of the universal Garrick, every stroller thinks he can play every thing; tragedy, comedy, farce, and pantomime.—Actors seem now to think it quite disgraceful to be excellent in one line alone:

“The mouse that is content with one poor hole,
“Can never be a mouse of any soul.”

In this respect the Audience frequently imitates them—I have seldom seen more merry faces, than at a German tragedy—a German tragedy, is a kind of “Tragedy for warm weather,” and a German comedy also approaches so nearly to the standard of that celebrated piece, that there is no longer any distinction between the species of the drama: to the modern we may apply what Tacitus says of the ancient Germans “Genus spectaculorum unum et in omni cœtu idem.”—I can easily imagine, that many a German Dramatist has completed his piece, before he resolved whether it should be a Tragedy or a Comedy. Those gentlemen seem to possess the power, that Mercury, in Plautus, humourously ascribes to himself, when he observed the Spectators vexed (as modern Audiences often are) at finding their comedy was in truth a tragedy:—

Quid contraxistis frontem? quia tragœdium
Dixi futuram hanc, Deus sum, commeutavero
Eadam hanc si vultis faciam ex tragœdia
Comœdia------

Prol. in Amphitruorum.

“Audiences are now drawn together by the translated trash of some foreign novelty—they wait the appearance of a ghost or a goblin; they hope to be roused from their weary lethargy, into hysterical laughter, or hysterical tears, by the farcical or the horrid—they swallow with gaping wonder, the eccentric flights, the profane rants, the illuminated morality, the bombastic diction of imported patchwork from their German favourites.” Preston's Reflec. on the Germ. Style, p. 59. Every one who is acquainted with German literature, well knows that not one of their dramas (Germania quos horrida parturit Fœtus) deserves to be excepted from this general censure. The English reader I refer to all the plays of Schiller and Kotzebue, which have been translated into our language. He will not find one piece undisgraced by vice or folly: some indeed excel in folly, others in vice, but in general “they are as like one another as half-pence, each seeming monstrous 'till its fellow come to match it.” As you like it.

What would Longinus have thought of such passion and sublimity, as the following passages (taken at random from Schiller) exhibit: “Now let the storm rage, tho' it should swell me up to the throatRobbers. “O. Moor. I am no spirit—but living as thou art—oh! life of wretchedness. “Y. Moor. What, wast thou not buried? “O. Moor. That is, a dead hound lies in the grave of my father.” Robbers. “What, talk you of nobility in Genoa? (indignantly) let them all throw their ancestry and honors into the scale, and one hair from the white beard of my old uncle, shall make it kick the beam.” Fiesco. Schiller. Of these effusion, for the faithful translation of the two first of which I am accountable, Longinus would say, as he does of those of the water-poet of his day, ποιητου τινος τω οντι ουχι νηφοντος εστι. Sec. XXXII. or he would have referred them βακχεια τινι των λογων. to a certain drunkenness of expression, which was sometimes objected to Plato.

“The public appetite began to be sated with non-sense, which now required to be reinforced with practical jokes, and corporal activity.” Preston's Reflec. p. 65.

These are specimens of the phraseology of our new comic school, taken from “a Cure for the Heart-ache,” and some other farrago of folly, of which I, happily, forget every thing but the cant word that I have quoted.

On the important incidents of a tailor's mending his own coat, and a sharper breaking a cracked china figure, two modern pieces entirely turn.

Here let me say a word or two on the state of our ‘corps d'opera’ (opera inanis!) The three female singers, Misses Howells and Davidson, and Mrs. Stewart, are on every account incapable of playing even secondary parts, and indeed seem to me to be only fit to lengthen the procession in Alphonso, or swell the choruses of the Castle Spectre. We have no professed male singer but Mr. Phillips, and thus the whole of our musical department depends on his slender pipe. Now as it happens that, from some cause or other, this gentleman cannot conveniently play all the parts, both male and female, of an opera on one night, it is evident that it were unreasonable to expect any musical entertainment at the Dublin theatre. But that we should not have to complain of a total want of this species of amusement, recourse has been had to a most brilliant expedient, which for its singular ingenuity, I shall relate in detail: Some one had heard, that a distressed country company had once played Hamlet with the omission of Hamlet's character, and it therefore occurred to them, that a musical entertainment, with the music omitted, would be in the present posture of affairs the most satisfactory extrication which could be devised.—The scheme was, it seems, adopted, and the Battle of Hexham had the honor to be selected for the experiment. The aforesaid Misses H. and D. were to sing all the choruses, and Mr. Phillips's name appeared in the front of the bills as principal in the glees. Night after night did Mr. Phillips's non-appearance disappoint the weary audiences, 'till at last Messrs. Jeffery and Dyke, who usually enact waiters, senators, and such folk, kindly consented to make themselves ridiculous, by singing the first and bass parts in such time and tune, as it should please God. So far all was prosperous. But here another unforeseen accident occurred, for it was by some means or other discovered, that the first and third would be useless without a second. Necessity, says the Proverb, is the mother of invention, and necessity took a violon-cello-teacher, dressed him in a fine brown jerkin, equipped him by the assistance of a burned cork with most terrific moustachios, and finally turned him out upon the stage a finished second, in whom nothing was forgotten or omitted, but a voice to sing—and after this manner the musical drama of the Battle of Hexham was said and sung by his Majesty's servants!!! “ex uno disce omnes.”

I find from the admonitions of the Kitchen-stuff Gazette, that I have been, in the foregoing note, guilty of a most wicked and diabolical mistake, by inserting the name of Mr. Dyke, instead of that of Mr. Denman, who really sung the third, and who, to use Taratalla's own words, “is one of the best and most scientific bass singers living, on or off the stage”—“O Terque quaterque beatus! I am ‘au desespoir’ at the disgrace into which this error has thrown me; Dyke or Denman, Denman or Dyke, I beg pardon of either, of both, or neither of the gentlemen, as they please; I have an equal respect for each, and tho' I have not the happiness of their acquaintance, they are, I am ready to believe

“------ arcades ambo
“Et cantare pares ------”
while Mistyllus and Taratalla are the respondere parati.”

Pausanias, in his account of the Cadmean family, (Bœot. c. 5.) says, that Harmony was the daughter of Mars and Venus. Could I suspect any of our composers of being, ‘litterulis græcis imbutus’ I should guess that, from this passage, he derived the elegant notion of accompanying love-songs with horns, triangles, kettle-drums, and other martial instruments—so that now-a-days,

De nos orchestres, l'harmonie
N'est que du bruit et du fracas
Pour peindre la mélancholie
Oh offre le bruit des combats
Pour peindre la paix, l'innocence,
On prend trombonnes et clarions
Pour accompagner la romance
Bientot on prendra du canon!!!—

Marant.

Whenever it shall please his great and good friends, the potentates of Germany, to send the excellent Kotzebue to the world of spirits, I make no doubt that Shakespeare will address him, as Menander did Philemon.—The fame of Menander no person is ignorant of, and if we may judge of his works by the imitations which we have of them, his great reputation was not above his merits. Of Philemon, the Kotzebue of his day, we only know, that he was the rival and conqueror of Menander, who, with the amiable frankness and honest confidence of Genius, asked his successful competitor—“Quæso Philemo bona venia dic mihi quum me vinces non crubescis?—” A.G. Noct Att li. 17. c. 4.

The following specimen of a theatrical Lloyd's List, will give a tolerable recapitulation of my opinions of the Crow-street company:

Moor's-head, Jan. 23, 1804.

“Admiral Jones in spite of the very hard weather still continues to keep his station off the Bagnio-slip. If the Peter-street squadron should attempt to put to sea, we are confident the gallant Admiral will give a good account of them. His force is as follows:”

    Ships. Guns. Commanders.

  • Montague 74 Talbot
  • Veteran 50 Hitchcock (Mrs.)
  • Charon 44 Vice Ad. Fullam
  • Assurance 44 R. Jones
  • Gorgon 44 Galindo (Mrs.)
  • L'Entreprenante 44 Walstein
  • Le Modeste 38 Hargrave
  • Alligator 36 Williams
  • Tartar 32 Williams (Mrs.)
  • Fairy 16 Stewart (Mrs.)
  • Bittern 16 Lindsay
  • Borer 12 Coyne

“Remains in port, La Musette (en slûte) Phillips.”

“We are sorry to observe, that the Favourite—Cres-well—and the Insolent—Stewart, have parted company in the late breezes”—

Tantâ mole viri turritis puppibus instant!!!

If the foregoing scale be correct, he has none either of the first or second-rates, and but one of the third.

Revisit'st thus the glimpses of the moon
Making night hideous.

Hamlet.

The anxiety which so many persons exhibited for the discovery of my name, surprized me at first; but I now find, many of them did so out of mere orthodoxy, and in obedience to the “editto del S. offizio” an extract of which I shall add as a specimen of the enlightened liberality of the year 1802:

“Tutte persone così ecclesiastica come secolare debbono revelare e notificare tutti e ciascuno di quelli de' quali sappono e abbiano avieto o avranno notizia—che si siano ingeriti o s'ingeriscano in far experimenti di negromanzia o di qualsivoglia altra sorte di magia!!!”

Dat. dal S. Offizio di Pezaro questo dé 26 Aprile 1802.

Should not one think, that 1802 was put by an error of the Press for 1302.

Sebastian Michaelis was not much madder than “S. Tomaso Francisco Roncalli, maestro di S. Teologia” in the nineteenth century—poor human nature!

The learned Reader will perceive some incongruities in this exorcism, que je me garderai bien d'annoncer aux ignorans.

Macbeth.

Tempest.

Robin Goodfellow. Midsum. Night's Dream.

Midsum. Night's Dream.

A procession of priests chaunting high mass, is sometimes of wonderful efficacy against ghosts and goblins, who, whatever profession they might have followed when alive, have, after their corporeal death, as great an aversion to high mass and all Church ceremonies as any Calvinist in Scotland.

Les exorcistes imposerent silence aux diables, on jetta dans le feu les pactes les uns après les autres. Hist du proces d'Urb. Grand. This liberal and enlightened operation was performed in presence of some of the chief men of the Church and of the Law, in the year 1631, in the now atheist land of France.

Of the supposed effects of lustration no one can be ignorant—I hope ours is conducted dans les formes.

I had rather never see a good actor on our stage than see him only for a few nights, which only serve to throw the rest of the season into a deeper night—

Et obtentâ densantur nocte tenebræ.
Nor should it be forgotten, that these strangers are birds of prey as well as of passage.

Imperavit (Marcus Antoninus) etiam scenicas donationes, jubens ut quinos aureos scenici acciperent. Jul. Cap. in Vit. M.A. Mr. Jones in this point imitates the Roman Emperor with a scrupulous accuracy, as he never gives a higher salary than 5l. per week. In London they give 10l. 15l. and 20l.—Surely it would be (as the tradesmen say) worth his while to give two or three good Actors here, as much as they can get elsewhere.

I am not one of those rigid fanatics who dislike all kinds of childish gaiety, and therefore, I say nothing about Mr. Jones's Ballets, and the four interesting little girls that try to dance in them. I own I should be better pleased that the stage was not made absolutely a dancing school, and a place of practice for embryo Parisots; but as the children are always neatly dressed, and generally contrive to keep time, in the present state of the scenic art, we have no reason to complain.—Let me add a strange anecdote which I have heard, tho' I can hardly believe:—A person with a very good sounding honest Irish name, something like M'Donough, or M'Swiney, or O'Flanagan, was desirous of setting up in this city as a dancing master, and obtaining an engagement as ballet dancer at the Theatre—“What, with such a name?” impossible! my good friend, go, go and get another.”—The Milesian was wise enough to take the hint, and Signior (I shall not mention his new appellation) afterwaads danced ‘mutato nomine’ with great success at Crow-street, and now teaches, as I am told, in the highest circles in Dublin.

Mr. Jones's liberality is a favourite topic of expatiation amongst his friends, and I believe not unjustly; but I intreat him to exercise it in procuring a few good Players for the Theatre Royal, an expedient of generosity which he has not yet practised to any considerable extent.

Gentle Reader who hast travelled these six heavy stages thro' with me, accept my thanks for the patience, with which you have borne the roughness of the road, and the mistakes and wanderings of our course, “beggar that I am, I'm poor even in thanks,” and have no other reward to offer, than, that I assure you, I shall not again trespass on your kindness and good nature—valete, and if you can plaudite.