1. |
1.1. |
1.2. |
1.3. |
2. |
2.1. |
2.2. |
2.3. |
2.4. |
2.5. |
3. |
3.1. |
3.2. |
3.3. |
3.4. |
3.5. |
3.6. |
3.7. |
3.8. |
3.9. |
3.10. |
3.11. |
4. |
4.1. |
4.2. |
4.3. |
4.4. |
4.5. |
4.6. |
4.7. |
4.8. |
5. |
5.1. |
5.2. |
5.3. |
5.4. |
5.5. |
5.6. |
5.7. |
5.8. |
5.9. |
5.10. |
5.11. |
5.12. |
5.13. |
5.14. |
5.15. |
5.16. |
5.17. |
5.18. |
5.19. |
6. |
6.1. |
6.2. |
6.3. |
6.4. |
6.5. |
6.6. |
6.7. |
6.8. |
6.9. |
6.10. |
6.11. |
6.12. |
6.13. |
6.14. |
6.15. |
6.16. |
6.17. |
6.18. |
6.19. |
6.20. |
7. |
7.1. |
7.2. |
7.3. |
7.4. |
7.5. |
7.6. |
7.7. |
7.8. |
7.9. |
7.10. |
7.11. |
7.12. |
7.13. |
7.14. |
7.15. |
7.16. |
7.17. |
8. |
8.1. |
8.2. |
8.3. |
8.4. |
8.5. |
8.6. |
8.7. |
8.8. |
8.9. |
8.10. |
8.11. |
7.12. |
8.13. |
8.14. |
8.15. |
8.16. |
8.17. |
8.18. |
8.19. |
8.20. |
8.21. |
9. |
9.1. |
9.2. |
9.3. |
9.4. |
9.5. |
9.6. |
9.7. |
9.8. |
9.9. |
9.10. |
10. |
10.1. |
10.2. |
10.3. |
10.4. |
10.5. |
10.6. |
10.7. |
10.8. |
10.9. |
10.10. |
10.11. |
10.12. |
10.13. |
10.14. |
10.15. |
10.16. |
10.17. |
11. |
11.1. |
11.2. |
11.3. |
11.4. |
11.5. |
11.6. |
11.7. |
11.8. |
11.9. |
11.10. |
11.11. |
11.12. |
11.13. |
11.14. |
11.15. |
11.16. |
11.17. |
11.19. |
11.20. |
12. |
12.1. |
12.2. |
12.3. |
12.4. |
12.5. |
12.6. |
12.7. |
12.8. |
12.9. |
12.10. |
12.11. |
12.12. |
12.13. |
12.14. |
12.15. |
12.16. |
12.17. |
12.18. |
12.19. |
12.20. |
12.21. |
12.22. |
12.23. |
12.24. |
12.25. |
12.26. |
12.27. |
12.28. |
12.29. |
12.30. |
13. |
13.1. |
13.2. |
13.3. |
13.4. |
13.5. |
13.6. |
13.7. |
13.8. |
13.9. |
13.10. |
13.11. |
13.12. |
13.13. |
13.14. |
13.15. |
13.16. |
13.17. |
13.18. |
13.19. |
13.20. |
14. |
14.1. |
14.2. |
14.3. |
14.4. |
14.5. |
14.6. |
14.7. |
14.8. |
14.9. |
14.10. |
14.11. |
14.12. |
14.13. |
14.14. |
14.15. |
15. |
15.1. |
15.2. |
15.3. |
15.4. |
15.5. |
15.6. |
15.7. |
15.8. |
15.9. |
15.10. |
15.11. |
15.12. |
15.13. |
15.14. |
15.15. |
15.16. |
15.17. |
15.18. |
16. |
16.1. |
16.2. |
16.3. |
16.4. |
16.5. |
16.6. |
16.7. |
16.8. |
16.9. |
16.10. |
16.11. |
16.12. |
16.13. |
16.14. |
16.15. |
16.16. |
17. |
17.1. |
17.2. |
17.3. |
17.4. |
17.5. |
17.6. |
17.7. |
18. |
18.1. |
18.2. |
18.3. |
18.4. |
18.5. |
18.6. |
18.7. |
18.8. |
18.9. |
18.10. |
18.11. |
18.12. |
18.13. |
18.14. |
18.15. |
18.16. |
18.17. |
18.18. |
18.19. |
18.20. |
18.21. |
18.22. |
18.23. |
18.24. |
18.25. |
18.26. |
18.27. |
18.28. |
18.29. |
18.30. |
18.31. |
19. |
19.2. |
19.2. |
19.3. |
19.4. |
19.5. |
19.6. |
19.7. |
19.8. |
19.9. |
19.10. |
19.11. |
19.12. |
19.13. |
19.14. |
19.15. |
19.16. |
19.17. |
19.18. |
19.19. |
19.20. |
19.21. |
19.22. |
19.23. |
19.24. |
19.25. |
19.26. |
19.27. |
20. |
20.1. |
20.2. |
20.3. |
20.4. |
20.5. |
20.6. |
20.7. |
20.8. |
20.9. |
20.10. |
20.11. |
20.12. |
20.13. |
20.14. |
20.15. |
20.16. |
20.17. |
20.18. |
20.19. |
20.20. |
20.21. |
20.22. |
20.23. |
21. |
21.1. |
21.2. |
21.3. |
21.4. |
21.5. |
21.6. |
21.7. |
21.8. |
21.9. |
21.10. |
21.11. |
21.12. |
21.13. |
21.14. |
21.15. |
21.16. |
21.17. |
21.18. |
21.19. |
21.20. |
21.21. |
21.22. |
21.23. |
22. |
22.1. |
22.2. |
22.3. |
22.4. |
22.5. |
22.6. |
22.7. |
22.8. |
22.9. |
22.10. |
22.11. |
22.12. |
22.13. |
22.14. |
22.15. |
22.16. |
22.17. |
22.18. |
22.19. |
22.20. |
22.21. |
22.22. |
23. |
23.1. |
23.2. |
23.3. |
23.4. |
23.5. |
23.6. |
23.7. |
23.8. |
23.9. |
23.10. |
23.11. |
23.12. |
23.13. |
23.14. |
23.15. |
23.16. |
23.17. |
23.18. |
23.19. |
23.20. |
23.21. |
23.22. |
23.23. |
23.24. |
23.25. |
23.26. |
23.27. |
23.28. |
23.29. |
24. |
24.1. |
24.2. |
24.3. |
24.4. |
24.5. |
24.6. |
24.7. |
24.8. |
24.9. |
24.10. |
24.11. |
24.12. |
24.13. |
24.14. |
24.15. |
24.16. |
24.17. |
24.18. |
24.19. |
24.20. |
24.21. |
24.22. |
24.23. |
24.24. |
24.25. |
24.26. |
25. |
25.1. |
25.2. |
25.3. |
25.4. |
25.5. |
25.6. |
25.7. |
25.8. |
25.9. |
25.10. |
25.11. |
25.12. |
25.13. |
25.14. |
25.15. |
26. |
26.1. |
26.2. |
26.3. |
26.4. |
26.5. |
26.6. |
26.7. |
26.8. |
26.9. |
26.10. |
26.11. |
26.12. |
26.13. |
26.14. |
26.15. |
26.16. |
26.17. |
26.18. |
26.19. |
26.20. |
26.21. |
26.22. |
26.23. |
26.24. |
26.25. |
27. |
28. |
28.1. |
28.2. |
28.3. |
28.4. |
28.5. |
28.6. |
28.7. |
28.8. |
28.9. |
28.10. |
28.11. |
28.12. |
28.13. |
28.14. |
28.15. |
28.16. |
28.17. |
28.18. |
28.19. |
28.20. |
28.21. |
28.22. |
28.23. |
28.24. |
28.25. |
28.26. |
28.27. |
28.28. |
28.29. |
28.30. |
28.31. |
28.32. |
28.33. |
28.34. |
28.35. |
28.36. |
28.37. |
28.38. |
28.39. |
28.40. |
28.41. |
28.42. |
28.43. |
28.44. |
28.45. |
29. |
29.1. |
29.2. |
29.3. |
29.4. |
29.5. |
29.6. |
29.7. |
29.8. |
29.10. |
29.10. |
29.11. |
29.12. |
29.13. |
29.14. |
29.15. |
29.16. |
29.17. |
29.18. |
29.19. |
30. |
30.1. |
30.2. |
30.3. |
30.4. |
30.5. |
30.6. |
30.7. |
30.8. |
30.9. |
30.10. |
30.11. |
30.12. |
30.13. |
30.14. |
30.15. |
30.16. |
30.17. |
30.18. |
30.19. |
30.20. |
30.21. |
30.22. |
30.23. |
30.24. |
30.25. |
31. |
31.1. |
31.2. |
31.3. |
31.4. |
31.5. |
31.6. |
31.7. |
31.8. |
31.9. |
31.10. |
31.11. |
31.12. |
31.13. |
31.14. |
31.15. |
31.16. |
31.17. |
31.18. |
31.19. |
31.20. |
31.21. |
31.22. |
31.23. |
31.24. |
31.25. |
31.26. |
31.27. |
31.28. |
31.29. |
31.30. |
31.31. |
31.32. |
31.33. |
31.34. |
19. Which is more suitable to the Prince and to the People, the
farming the Revenues, or managing them by Commission? The Spirit of the Laws | ||
The managing of the revenues by commission is like the conduct of a good father of a family, who collects his own rents himself with economy and order.
By this management of the revenues the prince is at liberty to press or to retard the levy of the taxes, either according to his own wants or to those of his people. By this he saves to the state the immense profits of the farmers, who impoverish it in a thousand ways. By this he prevents the people from being mortified with the sight of sudden fortunes. By this the public money passes through few hands, goes directly to the treasury, and consequently makes a quicker return to the people. By this the prince avoids an infinite number of bad laws extorted from him by the importunate avarice of the farmers, who pretend to offer a present advantage for regulations pernicious to posterity.
As the moneyed man is always the most powerful, the farmer renders himself arbitrary even over the prince himself; he is not the legislator, but he obliges the legislator to give laws.
I acknowledge that it is sometimes of use to farm out a new duty, for there is an art in preventing frauds, which motives of interest suggest to the farmers, but commissioners never think of. Now the manner of levying it being once established by the farmer, it may afterwards be safely entrusted to a commission. In England the management of the Excise and of the Post-office was borrowed from that of the farmers of the revenue.
In republics the revenues of the state are generally managed by commission. The contrary practice was a great defect in the Roman government. [17] In despotic governments the people are infinitely happier where this management is established — witness Persia and China. [18] The unhappiest of all are those where the prince farms out his sea-ports and trading cities. The history of monarchies abounds with mischiefs done by the farmers of the revenue.
Incensed at the oppressive extortions of the publicans, Nero formed a magnanimous but impracticable scheme of abolishing all kinds of imposts. He did not think of managing the revenues by commissioners, but he made four edicts: [19] that the laws enacted against publicans, which had hitherto been kept secret, should be promulgated; that they should exact no claims for above a year backward; that there should be a prætor established to determine their pretensions without any formality; and that the merchants should pay no duty for their vessels. These were the halcyon days of that emperor.
19. Which is more suitable to the Prince and to the People, the
farming the Revenues, or managing them by Commission? The Spirit of the Laws | ||