University of Virginia Library

APPENDIX 2

COPIES EXAMINED

I have examined all copies in person except as indicated. References are given
to reel numbers in the University Microfilms International (UMI) film set Early
English Books 1475–1640 (Ann Arbor, MI, [1937]-), subsequently digitized in
Early English Books Online (EEBO) (eebo.chadwyck.com). Thomas J. Wise tam-
pered with certain copies of ToP, now at the British Library and the Humanities
Research Center, University of Texas. For details beyond those given here, see
D.F. Foxon, Thomas J. Wise and the Pre-Restoration Drama: A Study in Theft and
Sophistication (London: Bibliographical Society, 1959).

bBRp: Bristol Central Library

SR 74. Reported by Roger Gaskell, who also sent digital copies. In a pam-
phlet volume, old maroon library buckram.

bC: Cambridge University Library

• Syn.7.61.1998
• Syn.7.63.3791. "Speech to the King" bound after sig. a. Sophisticated: D4
  supplied from a copy of the first printing (states D4r:1, D4v:1a2).

bCsc: St. Catharine's College Library, University of Cambridge

• Z.55. Examined in digital copy only. In a C19 to early-C20 collector's
  binding.
• Z.59. Examined in digital copy only. In a pamphlet volume, old leather.

bE: National Library of Scotland, Edinburgh

H.3.d.39(1). Examined in photocopy only. Bound with STC 22456 in later
19th-century quarter leather. Title page mended at inner margin.

bET: Eton College Library

S.170.Plays 27(04). Examined in digital copy only. Bound with six other C17
English plays in C18 gold-tooled mottled calf. Storer bookplate; given to the
library by Anthony Morris Storer, 1799. UMI reel 1585:6.

bL: British Library, London

• 644.c.44. David Garrick copy. Tampered with by Thomas Wise: A3, B3,
  C2–4 stolen, leaving stubs, as recorded by a pencil note in the book dated
  Jan. 1903. B3 and C2–3 were probably transferred to Ashley 1696. A3 was
  used to make up the Wrenn copy now at nTxU; a photocopy of that leaf
  is now bound into 644.c.44. C4 was found laid into Ashley 1697, and is
  now re-inserted in 644.c.44.
• Ashley 1695. Thomas J. Wise copy. Evidently the source of the t.p. illustra-
  tion in the Ashley Catalogue, vol. 5, recto of plate leaf preceding p. 161.
• Ashley 1696. Thomas J. Wise copy. Tampered with by Thomas Wise:
  B3 and the bifolium C2.3 were used to make up the Wrenn copy now at
  nTxU. Their lack was probably supplied from copy 644.c.44. Either Ash-
  ley 1696 or Ashley 1698 was probably the source of the t.p. illustration in
  the Ashley Catalogue, vol. 5, verso of plate leaf preceding p. 161.
• Ashley 1697. Thomas J. Wise copy.

---

206




• Ashley 1698. Thomas J. Wise copy. Disbound; paper flaw on B4. Either
  Ashley 1698 or Ashley 1696 was probably the source of the t.p. illustration
  in the Ashley Catalogue, vol. 5, verso of plate leaf preceding p. 161.
• Ashley 1699. Thomas J. Wise copy.
• Ashley 5388. Thomas J. Wise copy.
• C.12.f.15(7). Some cropping at head.

bLg: Guildhall Library, London
Closed access SR.4 Pageants.

bLv: Victoria and Albert Museum National Art Library, London

• 25.c.78. Alexander Dyce copy (Dyce Collection, 9113). Mid-C19 half calf
  with marbled boards (uniform with 25.c.79).
• 25.c.79. Alexander Dyce copy (Dyce Collection, 9114). Mid-C19 half calf
  with marbled boards (uniform with 25.c.78). "Speech to the King" bound
  at end. Washed: quires are all different shades.

bLONG: Longleat House, Warminster, Wilts.

Reported by Matthew Baalham. Half calf for Thomas Thynne, 2nd Marquis
of Bath (1862–1946).

bO: Bodleian Library, Oxford University

• Douce S 186. Francis Douce copy. UMI reel 1559:12.
• Mal. 160(3). Edmond Malone copy. UMI reel 1464:7. Misidentified as
  Huntington copy on EEBO.
• Mal. 254(5). Edmond Malone copy. Title page repaired along inner mar-gin; D4 repaired at top and bottom.

bOwo: Worcester College Library, Oxford University

• Plays 4.1022. In a pamphlet volume. -D4.
• Plays 4.1031. In a pamphlet volume.
• Plays 4.1032. In a pamphlet volume. Title page backed.

nCLU-C: University of California, William Andrews Clark Memorial Library, Los Angeles, CA

*PR3I44.T81. Bound by Riviere & Son. Some small mends to inner margin
of sig. a.

nC-S: Sutro Library, San Francisco, CA

822.S558t. Marbled boards, calf spine, ca. 1900. All page numbers more or
less cropped; state of D4v indeterminate because of this.

nCSmH: Huntington Library, San Marino, CA

• 69428. C19 sprinkled calf. Bookplates of Thomas Jefferson McKee and
  Henry William Poor (the latter's sale, Anderson Galleries, 14 Jan. 1909:942,
  $13; re-sold four months later as from "the library of Mrs. Constance E.
  Poor", Anderson Galleries, 14 May 1909:545, $9.50 to George Smith for Henry Huntington). Small paper fill, inside top of D4; the few missing let-
  ters supplied in pencil. UMI reel 1188:7.
• 69432. 19th-century calf. Bridgewater copy (en bloc purchase by Hunting-
  ton, 1917).
• 69433. Never bound, uncut, four stitching holes, now re-stitched with three
  holes, bolts cut, 20 x 15 cm. Badly printed line endings touched up in early
  MS. on B2v:20–22. Sotheby, Wilkinson & Hodge sale, 23 April 1904 (to

  ---

  207

  
  
  
  Joseph Sabin); folding morocco case by Riviere & Son added that year,
  according to dated cost code; Frederick R. Halsey copy (en bloc purchase by Huntington, 1915).
• 69434. Inlaid, some headlines cropped. MS. initials of John Philip Kemble, "Collated & perfect", 1798; Devonshire copy (pamphlet volume 81, item 7). Acquired by Huntington with the Kemble - Devonshire collection in
  1914; removed and bound separately in black morocco by Macdonald.

nCaOHM: McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario

Mills Lower Level B 13846. Reported by Myron C. Groover. Bookplate of
Irving Kent Hall, 1901. Small paper fill in gutter of A2.

nCtY
EC: Yale University, Elizabethan Club, New Haven, CT

Eliz 218. Reported by Kathryn James. Red morocco signed by Riviere & Son.
Bridgewater duplicate stamp on title verso. Gift of Alexander S. Cochran to
the Elizabethan Club, Dec. 1911.

nDFo: Folger Shakespeare Library, Washington, DC

• STC 22459b c.2 (Bd.w. STC 1578). In a 1963 binding replacing "calf of ca.
  1780, one board off". Quire A only, following t.p. of STC 1578.
• STC 22459. Binding signed by Riviere & Son. Cropped at head and re-
  margined; state of D4v indeterminate for this reason. a1.2 not conjugate.
• STC 22459a c.1. Red morocco by F. Bedford. Griswold family crest
  stamped on cover; bookplate of Almon W. Griswold.
• STC 22459a c.2. Blue morocco by Riviere & Son; some deckles retained.
  -a2, some repairs to sig. D.
• STC 22459b c.1 (Bd.w. STC 4619). In a pamphlet volume bound in (prob-
  ably later) C17 calf. "Speech to the King" bound after sig. a.
• STC 22459b.2. C19 half green morocco, marbled boards. "Speech to the
  King" bound at end. Pencil notes: "From Mr: Kershaw's Lib. No. 1317–
  Bot: by him from Lacy (?)." (parentheses in source). Collated by Quaritch,
  25 Jan. 1924.
• STC 22459.2. Later wrappers. Title page repaired at inner margin.

nDLC: Library of Congress, Washington, DC

PR1241.L6 #188:6. Bound with five other plays in C18 calf. Title page mu-
tilated and backed; -a2; sig. D repaired at inner margin.

nICN: Newberry Library, Chicago, IL

Case Y 135.S62885. Reported by Jill Gage. Interleaved. Front cover with
initials "IZ[L?]G"; back cover with armorial of a lion rampant holding a fishing seine.

nICU: University of Chicago, IL

PR3144.T84 1633. Reported by Catherine Uecker. Acquired by the library
early C20. Heavily cropped at head (state of C1r-v and C4v indeterminate-for this reason), interleaved; t.p. and D4 mutilated.

nIU: University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, IL

IUA11400. Reported by Tad Boehmer. Bound with nine other plays by Shir-
ley. Bought 22 July 1942 from Dawson's Book Shop, Los Angeles, CA (Cata-
logue 161:36).

nMB: Boston Public Library, MA

G.3976.37. Reported by Jason Moschella. Thomas Pennant Barton copy.
With two other items in a late C19 library binding; some pages untrimmed.

nMH-H: Harvard University, Houghton Library, Cambridge, MA

• STC 22459. C18–19 sprinkled calf. T.p. repaired at inner margin; A1
  conjugacy not certain.
• STC 22459a.5. Early C19 calf. T.p. on a stub.

nMWiW-C: Williams College, Chapin Library, Williamstown, MA

STC 22459a.5. Henry Huth copy (his catalogue, vol. 4, p. 1349); his sale,
Sotheby, Wilkinson & Hodge, 8 July 1918:6825 ("new vellum"), �23. 10s. to
B.F. Stevens and Brown; subsequently sold by James Drake to Alfred Chapin
for the same amount; donated by Chapin to Williams College, 1 Feb. 1923.

nNhD: Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH

Rauner Ticknor VA Sh6t. Examined in digital copy only. George Ticknor
copy; bequeathed to Dartmouth by William Dexter, 1943; afterwards re-
bound in brown library buckram. Ticknor notes of prices at the Roxburghe
and Rhodes sales. -Sig. A; sig. a cropped at head; top half of last leaf torn
away.

nNjP: Princeton University, Firestone Library, Princeton, NJ

3930.3.394. Examined in digital copy only. C19 quarter leather, marbled
boards. Cost code of Dawson's Book Shop, Los Angeles, CA, with price
$22.50; acquired by Princeton in early 1940s. Hole in a2 affecting two lines.
Digitized at http://libweb5.princeton.edu/visual_materials/Misc/Bib

2458362_Shirley_Triumph_of_Peace_1633_NjP.pdf.

nPU: University of Pennsylvania, Kislak Center, Philadelphia, PA

PR3144.T75 1634. Reported by Lynne Farrington. Signature of Courtney
Kenny and date 1719. Acquired 1968 and probably rebound at that time
(marbled boards, leather spine, vellum tips). -a2.

nTxU: University of Texas, Harry Ransom Humanities Research Center, Austin,
TX

• Pforz 935 PFZ. Examined in digital copy only. Brown morocco by Riviere.
  Robert Hoe copy (initials, trace of bookplate); W. Carew Hazlitt? (Shake-
  speare Library Pt. 2, Anderson Galleries, 28–30 Oct. 1918:312); Carl H.
  Pforzheimer (Unger & Jackson 935). Evidently not item 3029 in the Hoe
  sale (Perkins copy with armorial bookplate, modern wrappers).
• Wh Sh66.633ta WRE. Examined in digital copy only. Binding signed by
  Riviere & Son. Bought from a Mr. Butcher (possibly the father of Robert
  W. Butcher of the Lancashire Fusiliers) 67 by Thomas Wise for John Henry
  Wrenn, 1902. Subsequently tampered with by Wise: A3 supplied from bL
  644.c.44; B3 and C2–3 supplied from bL Ashley 1696.

Meisei University, Tokyo

• MR 1063. Examined in digital copy only. Bridgewater copy ("3." in box
  on A1r). -sig. a.
• MR 3092. Examined in digital copy only. -sig. a.
• MR 3093. Examined in digital copy only. -sig. a.

W.W. Greg's copy

"Third impression", a2 in photographic facsimile. Half calf. With "Speech
to the King" bound after sig. a ("fore-margin closely shaved"), illustrated
in his 1946 article (see main article, footnote 1). Sold at Sotheby's, London,
28 March 1960:60; present owner untraced.