University of Virginia Library

Shaw, Dorsey Record 'Stardust'

Victor has recently issue versions of
"Stardust" by both Tommy Dorsey
and Artie Shaw. T.D.'s version is a
carbon-copy of his "I'll Never Simile
Again", with vocals by Frank Sinatra
and The Pied Pipers occupying
practically the whole platter. The
result is a beautiful phrasing and
intonation that should be a delight to
anyone's ears.

His "Stardust" may not become
quite as popular as was "I'll Never",
but Mr. Dorsey surely deserves credit
for creating something so beautiful. In
contrast is Mr. Shaw's version of
"Stardust". It has no vocals, out relies
on breathtaking solos (Mr. Butterfield
on trumpet, Mr. Shaw on clarinet, Mr.
Jenney on trombone) and perfect
ensemble. Speaking in terms of genuine
music, this is the best recording of
Hogey Carmichael's immortal tune we
have ever heard.

"Best Records of 1940?"

We therewith present our
nominations for the 15 best records of
the past year, made by "name" bands.
Barnet, Charlie - "Lament for May",
"Southern Fried"; Basic, Count -
"How Long How Long Blues", "The
World is Mad"; Bradley, Will - "Down
the Road A Piece"; Ellington, Duke -
"Grievin", "Concerto for Cootie", "A
Warm Valley"; Goodman, Benny -
"Memories of You", "Royal Garden
Blues"; James, Harry - "Back Seat
Boogie"; Kirk, Andy - "Big Jim
Blues"; Miller, Glen - "Stardust";
Spanier, Muggsy - "Someday
Sweetheart"; Shaw, Artie -
"Stardust".