University of Virginia Library

Search this document 
  
expand section 
  
expand section 
  

expand section1. 
expand section2. 
expand section3. 
expand section4. 
expand section5. 
expand section6. 
expand section7. 
expand section8. 
expand section9. 
expand section10. 
expand section11. 
expand section12. 
expand section13. 
expand section14. 
expand section15. 
expand section16. 
expand section17. 
expand section18. 
expand section19. 
expand section20. 
collapse section21. 
expand section21.1. 
 21.2. 
 21.3. 
 21.4. 
expand section21.5. 
expand section21.6. 
expand section21.7. 
expand section21.8. 
expand section21.9. 
expand section21.10. 
expand section21.11. 
expand section21.12. 
collapse section21.13. 
  
  
expand section21.14. 
expand section21.15. 
expand section21.16. 
expand section21.17. 
expand section21.18. 
 21.19. 
expand section21.20. 
expand section21.21. 
expand section21.22. 
 21.23. 
expand section22. 
expand section23. 
expand section24. 
expand section25. 
expand section26. 
expand section27. 
expand section28. 
expand section29. 
expand section30. 
expand section31. 

7.5. 5. In what Cases sumptuary Laws are useful in a Monarchy.

Whether it was from a republican spirit, or from. some other particular circumstance, sumptuary laws were made in Aragon, in the middle of the thirteenth century. James the First ordained that neither the king nor any of his subjects should have above two sorts of dishes at a meal, and that each dish should be dressed only one way, except it were game of their own killing. [11]

In our days, sumptuary laws have been also enacted in Sweden; but with a different view from those of Aragon.

A government may make sumptuary laws with a view to absolute frugality; this is the spirit of sumptuary laws in republics; and the very nature of the thing shows that such was the design of those of Aragon.

Sumptuary laws may likewise be established with a design to promote a relative frugality: when a government, perceiving that foreign merchandise, being at too high a price, will require such an exportation of home manufactures as to deprive them of more advantages by the loss of the latter than they can receive from the possession of the former, they will forbid their being introduced. And this is the spirit of the laws which in our days have been passed in Sweden. [12] Such are the sumptuary laws proper for monarchies.

In general, the poorer a state, the more it is ruined by its relative luxury; and consequently the more occasion it has for relative sumptuary laws. The richer a state, the more it thrives by its relative luxury; for which reason it must take particular care not to make any relative sumptuary laws. This we shall better explain in the book on commerce; [13] here we treat only of absolute luxury.

Footnotes

[11]

Constitution of James I in the year 1234, art. 6, in "Marca Hispanica," p. 1429.

[12]

They have prohibited rich wines and other costly merchandise.

[13]

Lettres persanes, 106. See below, xx. 20.